Says that Wall Street hedge fund managers "pay a lower tax rate than does a sheet metal worker in Parma or a school teacher in Cleveland."
Sherrod Brown on Tuesday, August 2nd, 2011 in a television interview
Sen. Sherrod Brown says Wall Street hedge fund managers pay a lower tax rate than a typical sheet metal worker or a teacher
The bipartisan plan to raise the nation’s debt ceiling included formation of a 12-member congressional committee to consider cuts in spending and tax reform.
After voting in support of the plan, Ohio's Sen. Sherrod Brown said in an interview that Congress needed to turn its focus to job creation exclusively. And he said that tax reform should close loopholes that the debt-ceiling deal didn't touch.
For example, he said, "They didn’t close the tax loopholes for Wall Street hedge fund managers who pay a lower tax rate than does a sheet metal worker in Parma or a school teacher in Cleveland."
That got PolitiFact Ohio’s attention. Could wealthy Wall Street investors have a lower tax rate on their compensation than average workers?
We asked Brown's office how he supported his remark. Press secretary Allison Preiss responded with a pile of sources.
Let's start the review by identifying our subject. Hedge funds are investment funds similar to mutual funds, but are not subject to the same rules and regulations, are typically more aggressive, and traditionally have been limited to wealthy investors. Most set very high minimum investment levels.
Managers of hedge funds typically charge investors 2 percent for managing their money, meaning that a $10 billion hedge fund takes in $200 million in fees. Managers also can collect a percentage of the profits from trades they make, usually 20 percent.
AR Magazine, the hedge fund trade publication, began estimating compensation in the industry a decade ago, the Reuters news agency said earlier this year, noting that "calculating the earnings of top hedge fund managers involves a degree of guesswork and alchemy, since funds don't publicly disclose compensation."
AR's annual report on the 25 richest hedge fund managers said they collected about $22 billion in compensation last year.
Topping the charts in hedge fund pay was John Paulson of Paulson & Co., who earned a reported $4.9 billion. That is billion with a B, and that is for the year 2010.
A study by the University of Chicago Graduate School of Business and the National Bureau of Economic Research found that the top 25 hedge fund managers combined appear to have earned more than all the CEOs of the companies in the S&P 500 combined. That study put the average pay at hedge funds for "highly compensated employees" -- not just the managers at the top of the scale -- at $3.2 million a year.
Using the federal income tax rate schedule for 2010, a single individual earning $3.2 million (or $4.9 billion) would fall in the top tax bracket that applies to wages, bonuses and other compensation, which is 35 percent. That rate starts at income of about $370,000.
But hedge fund managers typically don’t pay taxes on their income the same way other Americans do, as PolitiFact has noted before.
The bulk of hedge fund managers’ income is typically considered "carried interest" -- that is, their share of profits from the funds they manage. When a fund has capital gains and those gains flow to the manager, they are taxed as a capital gain, not as ordinary income.
The tax rate on capital gains is 15 percent, rather than the 35 percent on compensation that would be paid by everyone else, including other types of Wall Street managers. (The taxpayers with the top 400 incomes paid an average rate of 18.11 percent in 2008, according to the most recent update of the Internal Revenue Service, which issues an annual report on the top 400 taxpayers.)
Hedge fund managers don't necessarily pay even 15 percent, however. They can pay no current income tax at all, by leaving their carried interest money in the hedge fund and deferring the tax bill to a later date -- even decades later -- when they eventually cash out of the fund.
What about the other two individuals in Brown's statement?
According to the most recent figures from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, in May 2010, the average salary for a sheet metal worker in the Cleveland area, spanning Elyria to Mentor, is $47,200.
According to a May 2010 survey by The Plain Dealer, using information from the Ohio Department of Education, the average teacher salary in Cleveland is $65,575.
Using the federal income tax rate schedule, both single individuals and heads of households at those income levels would fall in the tax bracket of 25 percent.
That 25 percent is higher than the capital gains rate of 15 percent that the carried interest tax loophole allows hedge fund managers to pay on their income.
On the Truth-O-Meter, that gives Brown's statement a rating of True.
Published: Monday, August 22nd, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.
WEWS, "Senators Brown and Portman agree the focus now needs to be on jobs," Aug. 2, 2011
Los Angeles Times, "Highlights of the bipartisan debt-ceiling deal," Aug. 01, 2011
Email interview with Sen. Brown press secretary Allison Preiss, Aug. 4, 2011
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "Hedging Your Bets: A Heads Up on Hedge Funds and Funds of Hedge Funds," March 26, 2008
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "Mutual Funds: A guide for investors," August 2007
Reuters, "Paulson, at $4.9 billion, tops hedge fund earner list," April 1, 2011
University of Chicago Graduate School of Business and National Bureau of Economic Research, "Wall Street and Main Street: What Contributes to the Rise in the Highest Incomes?," July 2007
U.S. Internal Revenue Service, 2010 Tax Table
U.S. Internal Revenue Service, 2011 Tax Rate Schedules
PolitiFact, "Barack Obama says tax rates are lowest since 1950s for CEOs, hedge fund managers," June 29, 2011
New York University Law Review, "Two and Twenty: Taxing Partnership Profits in Private Equity Funds," April 2008
Reuters, "What's on the table in U.S. debt talks," June 30, 2011
U.S. Internal Revenue Service, "The 400 Individual Income Tax Returns Reporting the Highest Adjusted Gross Incomes Each Year, 1992-2008"
Willamette Week, "9 Things The Rich Don't Want You To Know About Taxes," April 13, 2011
Burea of Labor Statistics, Glossary
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wages, May 2010
The Plain Dealer, "Average teacher salaries in Cuyahoga County, 2008-09," May 29, 2010
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Ohio Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.