The health care bill "dumps 15 to 18 million low-income Americans into a Medicaid program that none of us want to be a part of because 50 percent of doctors won't see new patients."
Lamar Alexander on Thursday, February 25th, 2010 in the televised health care summit
Health care reform bill will expand Medicaid, increasing demands on doctors
Little known fact: The health care bill will open up Medicaid to millions of Americans.
The expansion has been overshadowed by debate over the public option, taxes on "Cadillac" health care plans, and a litany of other controversial items in the overhaul.
But during the Feb. 25, 2010, health care summit between President Barack Obama and members of Congress, Sen. Lamar Alexander, a Tennessee Republican, pointed to the provision as one of his biggest problems with the bill.
"It dumps 15 to 18 million low-income Americans into a Medicaid program that none of us want to be a part of because 50 percent of doctors won't see new patients," Alexander told Obama in his opening remarks. "So it's like giving someone a ticket to a bus line where the buses only run half the time."
No one likes to wait for the bus, so we decided to look into Alexander's claim.
Currently, Medicaid is available to low-income individuals who are pregnant, disabled, elderly or have children 18 years old or younger; the program covers about 60 million patients. The Senate and House health care bills, and Obama's latest health care proposal, would open up the program to all people under 65 with a low income. The Obama proposal and the Senate bill would offer Medicaid benefits to those with incomes up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level, while the House version would allow those with incomes up to 150 percent of the federal poverty level to enroll.
All that would mean a major expansion of the program. Medicaid is funded jointly by the states and the federal government, but administered by the states. So, the proposed expansion has proven particularly controversial among state officials, who say local budgets are already strapped and can't handle additional enrollees. One of the biggest complaints among doctors is that Medicaid reimbursements are already too low.
We asked Alexander's office for some information on the statement, and his spokesman, Ryan Loskarn, pointed us to two recent studies about impacts of the potential law change.
The first, compiled by the Congressional Budget Office, was published on Dec. 19, 2009, and looked at the impact of the Senate bill's Medicaid expansion provision. The CBO estimated that the expansion would increase the number of enrollees in Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program by about 15 million, costing states about $26 billion over 10 years. (CBO does not specify how many of those would be only Medicaid patients, but the experts we spoke with told us that they would make up the vast majority of new enrollees.)
The second study was published on Jan. 8, 2010, by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. According to the report, the Senate bill would put 18 million people on the Medicaid beneficiary list. An additional 2 million with employer-sponsored health insurance would enroll in Medicaid for supplemental coverage. So, if anything, Alexander is understating the high end of the overall estimate.
Meanwhile, the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, a group that analyzes health care policy, estimated that Medicaid would enroll as many as 17.1 million new beneficiaries under the health care bill.
So, by all accounts, Alexander is in the ballpark on how many people would be newly eligible for Medicaid.
To back up the second part of Alexander's claim -- that 50 percent of doctors won't see new Medicaid patients -- Alexander's office pointed us to a 2007 Wall Street Journal article about access issues in Medicaid. The story mentioned a 2006 report from the Center for Studying Health System Change that estimated nearly half of doctors have stopped accepting or limited the number of Medicaid patients.
According to that 2006 study, about 52 percent of doctors surveyed said they were accepting all new Medicaid patients, while only 21 percent said they were accepting no new patients. Presumably, the rest of the doctors surveyed were limiting to some degree the number of new Medicaid patients they were accepting.
So, to say that 50 percent of doctors are accepting no new Medicaid patients based on that study is incorrect, said Alwyn Cassil, the group's director of public affairs.
Furthermore, the Center for Studying Health System Change updated those figures in 2009 and provided more detail. Currently, 40.2 percent of doctors are accepting all new Medicaid patients, 12.4 percent are accepting most, 19.2 percent are accepting some, and 28.2 percent are accepting no new patients.
Cassil did emphasize the fact that the 2006 study and the 2009 study are hard to compare because the group has changed its survey methods in the last few years. In 2006, for example, the group spoke with doctors over the phone. This time around, they administered a written survey. So, the group doesn't know if the most recent statistics are really worse than they were a few years ago or if patient rejection was simply underreported during the last survey.
Nevertheless, Alexander raises a good point, Cassil said.
"It is a valid point to raise, physician willingness to accept new Medicaid patients," she said. "If you're going to be throwing another 15 million into the program, you've got to be thinking about that."
Joan Alker, executive director for the Georgetown Center for Children and Families, agreed that Alexander's statement is generally true, but glosses over some important details.
"I would say that certainly, access to physicians is a concern and that there's room for improvement," she said. "But being on Medicaid provides more access to patients," than they would get if they had no insurance at all. Alexander's statement "suggests that having Medicaid is meaningless, which is misleading."
Leighton Ku, a health policy professor at George Washington University, said that those statistics are more nuanced than they seem. First, he pointed out, Medicaid patients surveyed often don't report great difficulty in finding doctors. But more importantly, Medicaid patients tend to be concentrated; there are many doctors that see just a few Medicaid patients, and a handful of clinics that see a lot. So, it's reasonable to think that some doctors aren't seeing new Medicaid patients because there are not many in their area. Finally, he said, many primary care physicians aren't seeing new patients at all, whether they are on Medicaid or have private insurance.
In the first part of his statement, Alexander is in the ballpark: Anywhere from 15 to 18 million new patients could enroll in Medicaid if the health care overhaul is put into law. We also found that Alexander's underlying point, that some Medicaid patients might have trouble finding doctors, is a valid concern. But he overstates the percentage of doctors that won't accept new Medicaid patients and based that claim on old data. As a result, we find Alexander's claim to be Half True.
Published: Monday, March 1st, 2010 at 4:33 p.m.
Congressional Quarterly, transcript of the health care summit, Feb. 25, 2010
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Are You Eligble?, accessed Feb. 26, 2010
The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, Side-by-Side Comparison of Major Health Care Reform Proposals, accessed Feb. 26, 2010
The New York Times, States Consider Medicaid Cuts As Use Grows, by Kevin Sack and Robert Pear, Feb. 19, 2010
The Congressional Budget Office, letter to Democratic Senate Leader Harry Reid, Dec. 19, 2009
Office of the Actuary, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Estimated Financial Effects of the "Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act," as Passed by the Senate on December 24, 2009, Jan. 8, 2010
The Wall Street Journal, Note to Medicaid Patients: The Doctor Won't See You, by Vanessa Furmans, July 19, 2007
Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, Expanding Medicaid: Coverage for Low-Income Adults under Health Reform, February 2010
Center for Studying Health System Change, Tracking Report, August 2006
Center for Studying Health System Change, A Snapshot of U.S. Physicians: Key Findings from the 2008 Health Tracking Study Physician Survey, September, 2009
Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, Medicaid Beneficiaries and Access to Care, October, 2009
Phone Interview, Leighton Ku, Professor in the Department of Health Policy, George Washington University, Feb. 26, 2010
Phone Interview, Alwyn Cassil, Director of Public Affairs, Center for Studying Health System Change, Feb. 26 and March 1, 2010
Phone Interview, Joan Alker, Georgetown Center for Children and Families, March 1, 2010
E-Mail Interview, Ryan Loskarn, spokesman for Sen. Lamar Alexander, Feb. 26, 2010
We want to hear your suggestions and comments.
For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.
Keep up to date with Politifact:
- Sign up for our e-mail (about once a week)
- Put a free PolitiFact widget on your blog or Web page
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Truth-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on GOP Pledge-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Obameter items
- Advertise on PolitiFact
- Shop the PolitiFact store for T-shirts, hats and other PolitiFact swag