Says Walmart employees represent the largest group of Medicaid and food stamp recipients in many states, costing the taxpayer $1,000 per worker.
Alan Grayson on Saturday, November 24th, 2012 in a Huffington Post column
Alan Grayson says more Walmart employees on Medicaid, food stamps than other companies
Leave it to Alan "Congressman with Guts" Grayson to get a security escort from Walmart on Thanksgiving.
Grayson, who returns to Congress next year after losing his old seat in 2010, ditched his family on Thanksgiving to hand out turkey sandwiches to employees of an Orlando-area Walmart.
Amid employee walkouts across the country, Grayson approached workers with his turkey tidings and told them about their right to join a union.
Walmart employees are paid so little, he argued, they often seek government programs for help.
"In state after state, the largest group of Medicaid recipients is Walmart employees. I'm sure that the same thing is true of food stamp recipients. Each Walmart ‘associate’ costs the taxpayers an average of more than $1,000 in public assistance," Grayson wrote in a Huffington Post column on Nov. 24, 2012.
He doubled down in a subsequent interview with The Young Turks show on Current TV, saying Walmart employees represent "the largest group of food stamp recipients."
Democrats and labor unions have long been critical of the non-union retailer and have recently been emphasizing that its low wages end up costing government because workers seek food stamps and other aid. ("Wal-Mart" is the corporation. "Walmart" is a store.)
We wondered if Grayson was right that the chain's impact was that large, so we dug into the numbers.
Largest group of Medicaid recipients?
Newspapers, lawmakers and liberal policy groups for years have analyzed which companies have large numbers of employees that seek public health insurance assistance.
In nearly all 24 states in which a study was completed, Grayson’s point proved accurate, according to a list from Good Jobs First, a labor-funded group that has criticized government support for Wal-Mart.
We should note not every study examined Medicaid, the joint state-federal partnership that insures the poor and disabled. Many reports focused on state-run programs aimed at people with low-paying jobs who don’t qualify for Medicaid and don’t make enough to provide insurance their families (these are often called SCHIP).
Philip Mattera, Good Jobs First research director, pointed to two simple reasons for it: Wal-Mart pays relatively low wages and is the biggest employer in the country.
Here's a sampling:
In Florida, Wal-Mart topped all companies operating in Florida with the largest number of employees and family members (12,300) eligible for Medicaid, according to a 2005 Tampa Bay Times story. Wal-Mart also ranked highly (No. 2) for dependents enrolled in Florida Healthy Kids or KidCare, trailing Miami-Dade County employees.
In Missouri, where Wal-Mart is the largest employer behind state government, the state’s social services department determined Walmart employees outnumbered all others with employees and family members enrolled in MO HealthNet, the state’s Medicaid plan, in the first quarter of 2011. However, at almost 14 percent, it did not represent the highest percentage of workers enrolled or responsible for an enrollee (Dollar General, for instance, was much higher at 42 percent).
And in Pennsylvania, a 2006 Philadelphia Inquirer investigation revealed the company had the highest percentage of employees enrolled in Medicaid. One in six of Walmart’s 48,000 Pennsylvania employees were enrolled in Medicaid, costing the state about $15 million a year (it’s likely higher because the Inquirer’s story did not cover employees’ dependents on Medicaid, or any other public assistance such as food stamps).
There was at least one exception on Good Jobs First’s list. In Vermont in 2005, Wal-Mart placed fourth of companies with employees and families enrolled in Medicaid, trailing Price Chopper, McDonald’s and Hannaford, according to Good Jobs First, which cited a 2005 Vermont Guardian report.
As labor groups pushed states to consider laws that would make Wal-Mart and companies like it pay more for employee health benefits, the New York Times reported on a 2005 internal memo from a Wal-Mart executive that showed the company knew a "significant number of associates and their children who receive health insurance through public insurance programs."
The memo from Susan Chambers, Wal-Mart's executive vice president for benefits, said 5 percent of Walmart associates were on Medicaid compared to an average of national employers of 4 percent. In sum, she wrote, 46 percent of associates’ children were either on Medicaid or uninsured. Her memo did not address employees on food stamps.
"On both of these issues – affordability and public assistance – it is important to note that our offering and performance are on par with other retailers," Chambers wrote. "Wal-Mart’s critics, however, hold it to a ‘large company’ standard, not a retailer standard."
She continued: "Despite the difference in industry economics, critics believe we should behave more like a GM or a Microsoft than a Target or a Sears."
So on Medicaid, the sampling of states shows Grayson’s assessment of this happening in "state after state" is accurate.
Largest group for food stamp recipients?
There’s no national tally of where food stamp recipients work.
A handful of researchers and reporters have mined state data for Walmart employees on food stamps, though not as frequently as the Medicaid studies.
In Ohio, the state Department of Job and Family Services report found Wal-Mart to be the state’s top employer for workers and family members who receive Medicaid (16,098), food stamps (14,799) and cash assistance (803), according to January 2012 numbers. A state spokesman cautioned the report does not tell the difference between full- and part-time employees, or employees who do not yet qualify for benefits, or why employees sought Medicaid.
In Maine, Wal-Mart topped employers with the largest number of workers on MaineCare, food stamps and temporary cash assistance, according to a 2005 Lewiston Sun Journal report, but it did not break down how many employees receive each subsidy. The company was fourth in the percentage of employees on public assistance.
In Florida, 1.9 million households receive food stamps, and nearly 500,000 have earned income as of October 2012. Of those with earned income, 9,095 households get paychecks from Wal-Mart, according to a report prepared for PolitiFact by the state Department of Children and Families.
The Florida taxpayer tab for their food stamps: $2.6 million.
DCF cannot determine how this bill compares to other Florida employers. The employer data field in DCF’s database is not mandatory and is usually filled in by hand. That leads to a lot of different entries for the same workplace (Wallmart, Wall mart, Wal-mart, Walmart, etc), making it difficult to draw conclusions about all employers.
Grayson cited a figure circulated by the liberal Daily Kos that "as many as 80 percent of workers in Wal-Mart stores using food stamps." (We couldn't find a study that backs up that number, but did find it was mentioned as an anecdote.)
Grayson could not provide solid evidence to us that he was right, but he said it was accurate largely because Walmart is simply such a big company.
"Walmart is the largest private employer in the country, by a substantial margin," Grayson wrote. "Even if 100 percent of the employees of the second largest employer were on food stamps – an unlikely scenario, to say the least – Walmart employees would still be the largest group."
He added: "Given the similarity between qualification rules for Medicaid and food stamps, if Walmart is #1 in a state for Medicaid, it’s very likely that it is #1 for food stamps, too."
Here, too, there is support for Grayson's point, but it is not conclusive.
There's less factual support for this aspect of Grayson's claim. We found the data is eight years old.
Grayson’s spokesman cited a 2004 study called the "Hidden Cost of Wal-Mart Jobs" by the University of California Berkeley’s Labor Center. The study, which Wal-Mart has criticized, analyzed Walmart employees’ use of safety net programs in California.
The researchers found taxpayers paid $86 million a year to subsidize Walmart workers’ wages -- $32 million for health programs and $54 million in other assistance. ("Other assistance" could be food stamps, subsidized housing and school lunches, and use of the Earned Income Tax Credit, which is a tax credit for low- to moderate-income workers.)
The average taxpayer bill per employee was $730 for health expenses and $1,222 for other expenses, researchers found. The totals for other large California retailers totaled $521 for health and $880 for other.
Also widely cited by the anti-Walmart contingent is a 2004 Democratic U.S. House committee report that examined the company’s record on many issues, including public subsidizing of employees’ wages. A 200-person Walmart store could require $420,750 in tax dollars for employee assistance a year, working out to $2,103 per worker, according to the Democratic Staff of the Committee on Education and the Workforce report.
Walmart does not dispute that many of its employees receive public health assistance. But company spokesman Kory Lundberg criticized Grayson citing the Berkeley study, saying, "They’re pointing out data that’s at least seven to eight years old."
Plus, he said, it’s expected the company would top such lists because its employs the most people.
And even though just over half of its employees take the company health care plan, Lundberg said, workers often have other options for health insurance, including from the military, Medicare, or a parent’s or spouse’s plan.
Grayson's claim about Wal-Mart employees on Medicaid and food stamps has support from several reports, although it's worth noting that some of them come from Democratic or labor-funded groups that are critical of Wal-Mart.
Comprehensive figures are not available, but we did find considerable evidence that echoes Grayson’s point about employee dependence on public health assistance in several states. His claim about Walmart employees on food stamps is not as substantiated, but we did not find any substantial evidence that contradicted his point.
His claim about the $1,000 cost has the least support because it's based on two studies that are eight years old.
Also, the presence of Wal-Mart at the top of the list is not necessarily unexpected given its size and the nature of wages for retailing.
On balance, we rate the claim Mostly True.
Published: Thursday, December 6th, 2012 at 10:33 a.m.
PolitiFact Ohio, "Rep. Robert Hagan slams Walmart over workers needing public assistance," Jan. 12, 2011
PolitiFact, "Bernie Sanders says Walmart heirs own more wealth than bottom 40 percent of all Americans," July 31, 2012
Alan Grayson’s Facebook page, "My Thanksgiving - a turkey sandwich at Walmart," Nov. 24, 2012
WESH 2 News, "Dozens protest at Orlando Walmart," Nov. 23, 2012
Current TV, Young Turks interview with Alan Grayson, Nov. 26, 2012
Email interviews with Rep. Alan Grayson, Dec. 4-5, 2012
Interview with Erin Gillespie, Department of Children and Families spokesman, Nov. 29, 2012
Interview with Philip Mattera, research director of Good Jobs First and director of the Corporate Research Project, Nov. 29, 2012
Interview with Todd Jurkowski, Grayson spokesman, Nov. 29, 2012
Interview with Kory Lundberg, Wal-mart spokesman, Nov. 30, 2012
Interview with Ken Jacobs, chair of University of California Berkeley Center for Labor Research and Education, Dec. 4, 2012
Interview with Benjamin Johnson, Ohio Department of Job and Family Services, Dec. 5, 2012
Ohio Department of Job and Family Services, January 2012 data for employers with employees on public assistance, accessed Dec. 5, 2012
Interview with Amanda Brown, USDA Food and Nutrition Service spokeswoman, Dec. 4, 2012
Email interview with Moira Bulloch, United Food and Commercial Workers International Union spokeswoman, Nov. 30, 2012
Florida Department of Children and Families, public records request for data on Walmart employees receiving food stamps and Medicaid, Dec. 5, 2012
Democratic staff of the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Education and the Workforce, "Everyday Low Wages: The Hidden Price We All Pay For Wal-Mart," Feb. 16, 2004
Various factsheets from Making Change at Walmart
Walmart Subsidy Watch, Walmart subsidy report for Florida, accessed Nov. 29, 2012
Wall Street Journal, "Wal-Mart Cost-Cutting Finds Big Target in Health Benefits," Sept. 30, 2003
The New York Times, "States are battling against Wal-Mart over health care," Nov. 1, 2004
The New York Times, Wal-Mart internal memo on supplemental benefits, 2006
The New York Times, "Wal-Mart memo suggests ways to cut employee benefits costs," Oct. 26, 2005
The Washington Post, "Many workers at Wal-mart don’t use its health plans," Jan. 7, 2011
The New York Times, "Wal-Mart cuts some healthcare benefits," Oct. 20, 2011
The Huffington Post, "Wal-Mart’s new health care policy shifts burden to Medicaid, Obamacare," Dec. 1, 2012
University of California Berkeley Labor Center, "Hidden Cost of Wal-mart Jobs: Use of safety Net Programs by Wal-mart Workers in California," Aug. 2, 2004
Daily Kos, "Walmart: America’s real ‘welfare queen,’" Oct. 12, 2012
Good Jobs First, Hidden Taxpayer Costs, updated Jan. 18, 2012
Missouri Department of Social Services, MO Healthnet employer match report for first quarter of 2011, Oct. 31, 2011
Philadelphia Inquirer, "Many Wal-Mart workers use Medicaid; One in six of its employees require the assistance program," March 2, 2006
Providence Journal, "Some workers getting health care through Medicaid," March 30, 2007 (accessed via Nexis)
The Seattle Times, "More than 3,100 Wal-Mart state health aid," Jan. 24, 2006
New Jersey Policy Perspective, "ATTENTION SHOPPERS: You Pay the Health Insurance Bills
For Some of New Jersey’s Largest Employers," August 2005
Wisconsin, BadgerCare employer report for the first quarter of 2012, accessed Dec. 3, 2012
Connecticut Husky Part A employers, as of July 22, 2011
CNN Money.com,"Judge overturns Maryland’s Wal-Mart law,"Nov. 19, 2006
Policy Matters Ohio, "Public benefits subsidize major Ohio employers," July 31, 2007
Dayton Daily News, "Employees of Big Companies Fill Ohio's Medicaid, Food Stamp Rolls, Report Says," Sept.29, 2009
Massachusetts Division of Health Care and Policy, "Employers who had fifty or more Employees using MassHealth, Commonwealth Care, or the health safety net in state FY09," June 2010
Lewiston Sun Journal, "Working, on welfare: Thousands in Maine have jobs but get assistance," (accessed via Google Newspapers)
University of California Berkeley Labor Center, "Internal Wal-Mart memo validates findings of UC Berkeley study," Oct. 26, 2005
University of California Berkeley Labor Center, "A downward push: The impact of Wal-Mart stores on wages and benefits," December 2007
We want to hear your suggestions and comments.
For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.
Keep up to date with Politifact:
- Sign up for our e-mail (about once a week)
- Put a free PolitiFact widget on your blog or Web page
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Truth-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on GOP Pledge-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Obameter items
- Advertise on PolitiFact
- Shop the PolitiFact store for T-shirts, hats and other PolitiFact swag