The Obama administration "has been outsourcing" by sending money to "solar and wind energy companies that end up making their products outside the United States."
Mitt Romney on Tuesday, July 10th, 2012 in a town hall in Grand Junction, Colo.
Romney says stimulus money for solar and energy was "outsourced" to overseas companies
Faced with criticism that he sent American jobs overseas, Mitt Romney tried to turn the tables on President Barack Obama by calling him the "outsourcer-in-chief" and highlighting foreign spending from the economic stimulus.
At a town hall meeting in Grand Junction, Colo., Romney said, "this president has been outsourcing a good deal of American jobs himself by putting money into energy companies, solar and wind energy companies that end up making their products outside the United States."
The Romney campaign backed up the claim by citing a report from the Investigative Reporting Workshop that found about 65 percent of the wind turbines on stimulus-funded projects came from foreign manufacturers.
PolitiFact has examined a number of claims about stimulus dollars going overseas, especially in the area of alternative energy. We have found an element of truth to these statements but that generally the numbers are exaggerated. Critics of the stimulus have tallied government loans, grants and tax credits going to a foreign firm but they often ignore that most of the money goes to domestic subsidiaries, and most of the work takes place on U.S. soil. In this case, though, Romney is less specific -- and more accurate.
Indeed, many foreign companies benefited from American tax credits and Energy Department grants, and those programs created some jobs in foreign countries. A study by the U.S. Department of Energy estimates that anywhere from 30 percent to 70 percent of wind power spending goes overseas. Another federal study put the number at about 40 percent. That's because many components for wind turbines are not manufactured in the United States.
In fact, it is extremely difficult to know exactly where everything is made. Some foreign companies have American subsidiaries. Some American firms import many parts. The Romney campaign cited the 65 percent figure from investigative reporter Russ Choma, but right after Choma gave that number he wrote, "I can't say how many of the turbines built by American manufacturers were overseas, and how many of the turbines built by foreign manufacturers were built here."
For solar power, the dependence on foreign components could well be greater than for wind. The Earth Policy Institute reports that the U.S. produces only about 4 percent of the total world output of photovoltaic cells. According to a government study, many American manufacturers import most of their components for final assembly in the U.S.
Overall, when the federal government supports the use of wind and solar power, it is virtually certain that some if not most of the materials will come from overseas. That is more true for solar than it is for wind.
However, it is one thing for federal stimulus dollars to be spent overseas; it is another to label this as outsourcing. In many cases, the reason the products come from foreign makers is that no one makes them here.
Choma wrote on his blog that his work has been taken out of context.
"I found nobody wanted to talk about how battered our industry was from past mistakes," Choma wrote. "Maybe before we promise hundreds of thousands of jobs, we should deal with the fact there isn’t an industry to create those jobs in."
Given the nuances of the industry -- and its recent growth in the U.S. -- it's important to examine the claims about outsourcing. The Republican National Committee put up a website on this theme called "Obamanomics Outsourced". As one example, the site claims that subsidiaries of the Danish wind turbine maker Vestas received tax credits worth nearly $52 million.
What it didn’t say was that the subsidiaries, Vestas Nacelles, Vestas Blades, and Vestas Towers, are all based in Colorado. The tax credits, under a program called 48C, were created as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, aka the stimulus.The Vesta American operation got the tax credits in exchange for building manufacturing plants that would hire American workers. While Vesta recently announced layoffs, work continues at the plants.
"I would call this the opposite of outsourcing," said Peter Kelley, spokesman for the American Wind Energy Association, an industry trade group.
"This is insourcing. It’s important to draw foreign investment that creates jobs here in the U.S."
The RNC website says the wind power industry overall lost 10,000 jobs after 2009, but Kelley notes most of those were in construction, which had peaked that year. He says those newly constructed wind facilities have led to a workforce of 75,000 wind-related jobs. Some are tied directly to running the wind farms, but about 30,000 are in manufacturing.
"These are better than construction jobs," said Kelley, "because they pay good wages and they last longer."
We found further evidence that the wind power industry is expanding. A 2011 report from the U.S. International Trade Commission notes that three foreign companies opened their first U.S. manufacturing plants in 2010. Internal Revenue Service data shows that all three of the firms received those energy tax credits under the federal stimulus. The trade commission analyst says the expansion of American production contributed to a decrease in imports of wind energy components and an increase in American exports.
And the share of American-made parts is growing. The wind association estimates the value of the American-made content went from 25 percent in 2004 to over 60 percent in 2011.
Still, foreign suppliers have remained the largest beneficiaries of the spending on wind power. Imports may have declined but at about $1.2 billion in 2010, they were still about ten times larger than exports.
Domestic production of solar energy components have struggled more. According to the Congressional Research Service, these manufacturing plants "appear to have relatively short life spans." Eight plants closed in 2011 alone.
It has been a goal of the Obama administration to expand domestic renewable energy manufacturing. Both the wind and solar industries depend enormously on federal policy. Wind, and to a lesser degree, solar, grew during the last decade thanks to the high price of oil and high demand, but especially thanks to the Renewable Energy Production Tax Credit and other incentive. That credit expires this year and the industry predicts major job losses if that happens.
Government policy dating back to 2005 spurred the growth of the alternative energy sector but the state of the industry in the United States remains precarious.
Romney said, "This president has been outsourcing a good deal of American jobs himself by putting money into energy companies, solar and wind energy companies that end up making their products outside the United States."
There is some truth to Romney's statement because stimulus dollars did go to foreign companies, largely because there was a shortage of American firms producing key components for generating wind and solar power. But given that situation, it is inaccurate to call it "outsourcing" because there is not a source domestically.
Also, it's important to note that domestic manufacturing tied to wind power benefited considerably from the stimulus. Thanks to the Renewable Energy Production Tax Credit, the domestic sector was growing before Obama took office and accelerated during his first three years. However, federal policy has been less effective in the area of solar power.
We rate the claim Half True.
Published: Friday, July 20th, 2012 at 2:06 p.m.
POLITICO, Romney Hits Obama as ‘Outsourcer-in-chief’, July 10, 2012
ABC News, Romney Hits Back, July 10, 2012
PolitiFact, TV ad claims stimulus ships tax dollars overseas, May 4, 2012
PolitiFact, Ad says stimulus tax credits funded solar company in Mexico, May 2, 2012
Republican National Committee, Obamanomics Outsourced
San Francisco Chronicle, SunPower to open plant in Milpitas, April 23, 2010
Congressional Research Service, U.S. Solar PV Manufacturing: Industry Trends, Global Competition, Federal Support, June 13, 2012
Earth Policy Institute, Eco-Economy Indicators: solar power, October 27, 2011
American Wind Energy Association, FACT CHECK: WIND BORN IN U.S.A, DESPITE "OUTSOURCING" FLAP
Washington Post, Obama and Outsourcing: A Guide to the GOP Charges, July 12, 2012
National Renewable Energy Library, Preliminary Analysis of the Jobs and Economic Impacts of Renewable Energy Projects Supported by the 1603 Treasury Grant Program, April 2012,
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Preliminary Evaluation of Recovery Act Grant Program Finds Positive Effects on Renewable Energy Capacity and Jobs, May 11, 2010
CNN, Wind Industry Pulled Into Candidates’ Debate on Outsourcing, July 11, 2012
Investigative Reporting Workshop, Renewable Energy money still going abroad, February 8, 2010
Russ Choma, Section 1603 Now a $6.4 Billion Program, March 25, 2011
Congressional Research Service, U.S. Wind Turbine Manufacturing: Federal Support for an Emerging Industry, September 23, 2011
Tribune Democrat, Gamesa Layoffs a Surprise, November 27, 2009
US International Trade Commission, Shifts in US Wind Turbine Equipment Trade in 2010, June 2011
IRS, Section 48C Tax Credits Allocated January 7, 2010,
Nixon Peabody Law, New Section 48C Provides a 30% Tax Credit, August 14, 2009
Database of State Incentives for Renewables and Efficiency , Renewable Energy Production Tax Credit
FactCheck.org, "Stimulus Jobs In China?," October 29, 2010
Investigative Reporting Workshop, "Workshop's Wind Stories Kicking Up Political Dust," September 27, 2010
The Washington Post, Obama’s Record On Outsourcing Draws Criticism From The Left , Julne 9, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments.
For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.
Keep up to date with Politifact:
- Sign up for our e-mail (about once a week)
- Put a free PolitiFact widget on your blog or Web page
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Truth-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on GOP Pledge-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Obameter items
- Advertise on PolitiFact
- Shop the PolitiFact store for T-shirts, hats and other PolitiFact swag