Says Mitt Romney "called the Arizona law a model for the nation."
Barack Obama on Tuesday, October 16th, 2012 in the second presidential debate
Barack Obama says Mitt Romney called the Arizona immigration law a 'model for the nation.'
In the second presidential debate at Hofstra University, President Barack Obama repeated a claim that he and many of his allies have repeated for months.
Referring to a high-profile Arizona immigration law known as S.B. 1070, Obama said Romney "called the Arizona law a model for the nation."
Soon after Obama made that claim, Romney fired back. "I did not say that the Arizona law was a model for the nation in that aspect," Romney said at the debate. "I said that the E-Verify portion of the Arizona law, which is the portion of the law which says that employers could be able to determine whether someone is here illegally or not illegally, that that was a model for the nation."
They both can’t be right. So which one is correct?
PolitiFact Texas looked at this question earlier this year. We’ll recap and update their analysis here.
First, some background on the law. In June, the Supreme Court delivered a mixed ruling on the Arizona law. It threw out parts that would have made state crimes out of federal immigration violations, including provisions requiring immigrants to obtain or carry immigration registration papers, making it a state criminal offense for an illegal immigrant to seek work or hold a job and allowing police to arrest suspected illegal immigrants without warrants, according to the Associated Press.
But the court let stand a "show me your papers" requirement that police officers check the status of people stopped for various reasons who might appear to be in the U.S. illegally. Even then, the AP reported, the justices said the provision could be subject to additional legal challenges. And they removed some teeth by prohibiting officers from arresting people on immigration charges.
The notion that Romney called S.B. 1070 a "model for the nation" stems from a comment he made during a Feb. 22, 2012, Republican presidential debate in Arizona.
As John King of CNN framed his question to Romney, the audience applauded mention of Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Arizona’s Maricopa County, who is known for his advocacy of hard-line immigration policies. King said to Romney: "You've talked, governor, about self-deportation, if businesses do their job, asking for the right documents, the people will leave. But what about arresting? Should there be aggressive, seek them out, find them and arrest them as Sheriff Arpaio advocates?"
Romney answered, "You know, I think you see a model here in Arizona. They passed a law here that says that people who come here and try and find work, that the employer is required to look them up on E-Verify. This E-Verify system allows employers in Arizona to know who's here legally and who's not here legally. And as a result of E-Verify being put in place, the number of people in Arizona that are here illegally has dropped by some 14 percent, where the national average has only gone down 7 percent."
E-Verify is a federal, Internet-based system that employers can use to verify whether someone is authorized to work in the United States. Participation is voluntary for most U.S. businesses -- there is no federal mandate. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s website says that more than 280,000 employers across the country are using the system.
After the Arizona debate, many reporters, opinion columnists, Democrats and liberal groups interpreted that statement by Romney as him saying that SB 1070 as a whole should be a model, either for the nation or for other states.
However, Dan Nowicki, the Arizona Republic’s national political reporter, questioned those interpretations in a March 3, 2012, news article that noted that Arizona’s requirement that businesses use E-Verify is not contained in SB 1070 but rather in an earlier state law, the Legal Arizona Workers Act.
"It's clear from the (debate) transcript that Romney was describing part of the state's 2007 employer-sanctions law, which has been upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court," Nowicki wrote. "That Arizona law requires employers to use a federal electronic system to verify whether new hires are eligible to work in the United States and provides punishment for companies that hire undocumented immigrants."
In other words, Romney in the debate saluted the E-Verify element of a 5-year-old Arizona law — which was not part of the 2010 immigration-enforcement law.
It’s important to note that Romney is not opposed to the Arizona law. In fact, at the same debate, he said that if elected, he would drop federal lawsuits against the Arizona law "on day one."
Romney expressed support for the law at least as early as Sept. 13, 2011, during an event in Arizona sponsored by the Christian Broadcasting Network. According to the CBN account, Romney said, "Well, I support the Arizona law by recognizing what Arizona has done -- underscored the failure of the federal government to do its job."
Then, shortly after the Supreme Court decision, Romney echoed this view, saying he believes that "each state has the duty — and the right — to secure our borders and preserve the rule of law, particularly when the federal government has failed to meet its responsibilities."
And Romney spokesman Ryan Williams confirmed to PolitiFact after the debate that the candidate’s view remains the same. "He said very clearly he supports the right of states to craft individual laws to help them address failures of the federal government, but he has never said that S.B. 1070 is a ‘model for the nation," Williams said.
Obama said Mitt Romney "called the Arizona law a model for the nation." That statement mischaracterizes Romney’s salute to Arizona’s mandate that employers electronically verify the legal status of employees, which was passed in 2007 and was not included in S.B. 1070. We rate the statement False.
Published: Wednesday, October 17th, 2012 at 12:48 a.m.
Barack Obama, transcript of the second presidential debate at Hofstra University, Oct. 16, 2012
PolitiFact, "Barack Obama says Mitt Romney calls Arizona immigration law a 'model for the nation,'" July 17, 2012
News article, "High court rejects part of Arizona immigration law," The Associated Press, June 25, 2012
CNN.com, transcript, Arizona Republican presidential debate, Feb. 22, 2012
CBN News, "Romney, Bachmann Talk Immigration in Arizona," Sept. 15, 2011
Web page, Citizenship and and Immigration Services, U.S. Department of Homeland Security, "What is E-Verify?" (accessed April 6, 2012)
Arizona Republic, "For Romney, ‘model’ policy on migration isn’t SB 1070," March 3, 2012
Web page, Arizona attorney general’s office, "Frequently Asked Questions about the Legal Arizona Workers Act" (accessed March 28, 2012)
KNXV-TV (Phoenix), "SB 1070 co-author tells ABC15 he’s an advisor for Mitt Romney," Jan. 31, 2012
New York Times, "Romney’s plan for ‘self-deportation’ has conservative support," Jan. 24, 2012
New York Times, "Supreme Court Could Pose New Challenge for Romney on Immigration," June 20, 2012
Interview with Ricardo Ramirez, regional press secretary for the Southwest, Democratic National Committee, March 28, 2012
Email statement in response to PolitiFact Texas, Gabriela Domenzain, Director of Hispanic Press, Obama for America, July 17, 2012
Email interview with Ryan Williams, spokesman for Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign, Oct. 16, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments.
For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.
Keep up to date with Politifact:
- Sign up for our e-mail (about once a week)
- Put a free PolitiFact widget on your blog or Web page
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Truth-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on GOP Pledge-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Obameter items
- Advertise on PolitiFact
- Shop the PolitiFact store for T-shirts, hats and other PolitiFact swag