Saturday, October 25th, 2014
Pants on Fire!
Advancing Wisconsin
Says Republican gubernatorial candidate Scott Walker "increased his own pay by $50,000."

Advancing Wisconsin on Thursday, October 28th, 2010 in campaign literature distributed by an outside group

Group says GOP gubernatorial candidate Scott Walker gave himself a $50,000 raise as Milwaukee County executive

Campaign literature distributed by Advancing Wisconsin

A group that backs Democrat Tom Barrett in the 2010 campaign for governor of Wisconsin accuses the Republican nominee, Scott Walker, of fattening his own wallet as Milwaukee County executive.

In a flier, the group Advancing Wisconsin casts Barrett as a fighter for jobs and education and as a cutter of waste. Walker is denounced as favoring big corporations over families on taxes and opposing a minimum wage increase "even though he increased his own pay by $50,000."

That’s a claim that might raise both your eyebrows.

An elected official raising his own pay, by himself? And by fifty large?

As readers of PolitiFact Wisconsin know, some of this is old ground. We ruled as True a claim by Walker that he had given back more than $370,000 of his salary to Milwaukee County.

So, where is Advancing Wisconsin headed with its claim?

First a little history.

Walker was elected county executive in 2002 in the wake of a scandal over lavish county pensions. One of Walker’s campaign pledges, which he kept, was that he would return $60,000 of his pay to the county every year.

At the time, the county executive’s salary was $132,724. In 2004, the County Board cut the salary to $129,114 in 2004. (It’s important to note only the board, not the county executive, can change the salary.)

As support, Advancing Wisconsin cites a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel story from March 2008. The article notes Walker said then if re-elected in April 2008, he would return $10,000 of his salary each year to the county.

Walker was re-elected and now gives back $10,000, rather than $60,000.

To Advancing Wisconsin, that’s increasing his pay by $50,000, even though Walker is still taking home less than what his salary provides.

Hmmm.

If you were one of the many people who suffered a pay cut during the Great Recession, and your employer later restored most of that money, would you feel you had received a pay increase?      

In Walker’s case, the pay cuts were voluntary, but otherwise the scenario is the same.

We asked Advancing Wisconsin executive director Meagan Mahaffey if she had more to back up her organization’s claim. She said that when Walker made his 2002 promise to return $60,000 per year, he "did not indicate that it was a temporary pledge."

Nor did he say it was an eternal one.

And Walker was upfront with voters when he set the salary giveback for his current term as county executive at $10,000 per year. He was re-elected on that basis.

So let’s review our math.

In support of Democrat Tom Barrett, Advancing Wisconsin is claiming Republican candidate Scott Walker "increased his own pay by $50,000" as Milwaukee County executive. To be sure, Walker used to give back $60,000 of his pay and he’s now giving back $10,000. It’s a smaller giveback, but follow us closely here, still a giveback. To say otherwise, is a cheap shot and, frankly, turns math on its head.

We’ll light up the group’s shot in the dark: Pants on Fire.