As a congressman, Mark Neumann "voted four times to increase our debt."
Eric Hovde on Friday, July 13th, 2012 in a television ad
Hovde says Neumann voted four times to increase U.S. debt
In the Republican U.S. Senate race, Mark Neumann has portrayed himself as a budget-cutter extraordinaire during his four years in Congress, but one of his rivals is painting him as a piggish paragon of waste.
"In Congress Mark Neumann voted for over 2,000 earmarks, including the ‘Bridge To Nowhere,’" a TV ad by fellow Republican Eric Hovde charges. "Congressman Neumann voted four times to increase our debt."
Neumann did vote in 1998 for a massive transportation bill that included many earmarks, including that infamous Alaska bridge project, we reported in an item during Neumann’s failed 2010 bid for the Republican nomination for governor.
But what about the claim of voting to raise the nation’s debt ceiling?
The debt ceiling is the legal cap on borrowing by the federal government. Raising it is routinely done under presidents of both parties, but periodically that move stalls, as in the summer of 2011 when a stalemate pushed the nation to the edge of default.
Neumann’s record on the issue takes us back to 1995 when he entered Congress as a member of the GOP freshman class that ushered in the Republican Revolution under new House Speaker Newt Gingrich.
Voting records show Neumann had four chances to vote for or against extending the debt ceiling.
In all four instances, he voted to increase the limit, according to the online database maintained by the Library of Congress:
-- October 26, 1995: Neumann helped squeak through an attempt to boost the debt limit, in a broader bill, on a 227-203 vote largely along party lines. President Bill Clinton vetoed the bill.
-- November 9, 1995: Neumann, along with nearly every House Republican, voted to temporarily push the public debt limit to $4.967 trillion. Clinton vetoed this as well.
-- March 7, 1996: Congress again sent Clinton a broad fiscal bill that included an increase in the debt limit to $5.5 trillion. The vote was bipartisan, with 127 Democrats joining the majority on a 328-91 vote. Thirty Republicans dissented, but Neumann joined the majority. Clinton signed it.
-- July 30, 1997: Neumann again voted with most Republicans and 52 Democrats to boost the limit to $5.95 trillion, again as part of a broader bill. The tally was 346-85, with 32 Republicans voting no. The president signed it.
Like so many of the claims in the four-way GOP primary, Hovde’s ad takes a snippet of information that is accurate, but strips it of important context.
The thrust of the ad is that the votes show Neumann to be pro-spending and government growth. In the 2012 campaign Neumann is running on a platform to balance the budget on a five-year plan.
A look at the votes shows they came as Neumann and other conservatives pushed the Democratic president for significant spending cuts. Compromise talks failed, leading, famously, to two temporary government shutdowns.
The 1995 votes were part of the legislative battle over the GOP’s balanced budget act, which aimed to accomplish a balanced budget in seven years.
In fact, in three of the four votes Hovde cites, the debt-limit increase was part of very broad fiscal measures.
The March 1996 debt action, for example, was tucked into a multifaceted bill to reduce federal regulation of business, and as we noted it drew significant Democratic support.
Finally, the August 1997 increase in the debt limit was approved as part of an act the New York Times described as "sweeping legislation intended to balance the federal budget for the first time since 1969."
The government actually ran a surplus from 1998 to 2001, thanks to what observers said was a combination of an earlier tax increase, spending restraints, economic growth and stock market gains.
Foreshadowing the 2011 showdown, Neumann, an early crusader on the perils of debt, was trying to leverage the deadline over raising the debt ceiling to get deeper spending cuts.
That sounds a lot like Hovde’s position, which he laid out at a candidate forum in April 2012. He said he could support a debt-ceiling increase but only if its tied to strict spending restraints that balance the budget within two years.
In a TV ad, Hovde paints Neumann as a go-along-to-get-along congressman who was cavalier about federal spending and helped raise the nation’s debt.
Neumann did vote four times to extend the debt ceiling, but the ad leaves out important details: The votes were part of a historic drive by Republicans to balance the budget, and were wrapped into huge fiscal bills.
That pushes his claim down to Half True on the Truth-O-Meter.
Published: Sunday, August 5th, 2012 at 9:00 a.m.
Eric Hovde campaign TV ad, July 13, 2012
Phone and email interviews with Sean Lansing, Eric Hovde campaign spokesman, July 31, 2012
Email interview with Chip Englander, spokesman for Mark Neumann campaign, July 31, 2012
Phone interview with Donald Marron, director, Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, July 31, 2012
PolitiFact National, itemon Newt Gingrich budget claim, Dec. 16, 2011
Congressional Research Service, "The Debt Limit: History and Recent Increases," May 22, 2012
Roll calls researched on Library of Congress THOMAS site
PolitiFact National, "The new politics of the vote on the debt ceiling," April 29, 2011
New York Times Magazine, "Adventures of a Republican Revolutionary," Nov. 3, 1996
White House Office of Management and Budget, Statutory Limits on Federal Debt: 1940–Current, accessed Aug. 1, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.