Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
President Donald Trump has said Democrats need to be pressured to end a "horrible law" that separates children from their parents at U.S. borders.
But Democrats including Oregon Sen. Jeff Merkley counter that Trump is the one to blame for a "cruel new child separation policy."
What exactly is going on?
There is no law mandating the separation of families, contrary to Trump’s claims.
However, the Trump administration has introduced a "zero-tolerance" policy calling for the prosecution of all individuals who illegally enter the United States.
This policy has the effect of separating parents from their children when they enter the country together, because parents are referred for prosecution and the children are placed in the custody of a sponsor, such as a relative or foster home, or held in a shelter.
More than 650 children were separated from their parents during a two-week period in May as a result of the new approach being implemented.
As the Trump administration argues, referring immigrants for prosecution is not new policy. But prior administrations did not enforce the practice the way Trump has.
Before Trump came into office, families were detained together, sent back immediately or paroled into the country, said Peter Margulies, an immigration law and national security law professor at Roger Williams University School of Law. Now, prosecution is happening across the board and has become the uniform policy.
"The policy has ramped up substantially with the new administration," Margulies said. "Making that a staple of immigration policy is a new feature."
The Trump administration has justified the policy by pointing to an increase in southwest border apprehensions in 2018.
Attorney General Jeff Sessions said an "escalated effort" was needed to address a crisis at the southwest border. So Sessions directed the implementation of a new "zero-tolerance" policy to prosecute all illegal entry referrals from the Department of Homeland Security.
When an adult is referred for prosecution, a child traveling with the adult is turned over to the U.S. Health and Human Services Department. That agency is responsible for placing the child with a sponsor as the child’s immigration case is resolved.
From May 6 to May 19, 658 children were separated from their parents due to the zero-tolerance policy, Richard Hudson, an official with U.S. Customs and Border Protection, said during a May 23 Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing.
Prosecutions were rare prior to the Trump administration, partly because they cost a lot of money and are time-consuming, Margulies said. "Previous administrations felt broad use of the 'prosecute-first' option was needlessly harsh," he said.
The fact that previous administrations did not broadly prosecute all illegal entries contradicts Trump’s claim that "we have to break up families."
Some have also conflated the "zero-tolerance" policy with reports of nearly 1,500 immigrant children "lost" by the administration. The government said that in late 2017 it had been unable to reach 1,475 children after placing them with sponsors. But these were children who came alone, not with their parents, and officials said some sponsors are here illegally and don’t want to be contacted by authorities. (We sort out those facts in this story.)
The Trump administration has been considering separating families at the border since the early months of his presidency, hoping that harsh treatment would deter illegal immigration.
Reuters reported in March 2017 that "part of the reason for the proposal is to deter mothers from migrating to the United States with their children."
"With safety in mind, the Department of Homeland Security continually explores options that may discourage those from even beginning the journey," said DHS in a statement to Reuters.
Also in March 2017, then-DHS Secretary John Kelly (now White House chief of staff) told CNN he was considering separating children from parents to deter illegal immigration.
Kirstjen Nielsen, tapped to replace Kelly as DHS Secretary, told lawmakers on May 15 that she had not been directed to separate families for deterrence purposes. Yet, other administration officials have made comments about the "zero-tolerance" policy having the effect of discouraging border-crossing attempts.
"The children will be taken care of — put into foster care or whatever. But the big point is they elected to come illegally into the United States and this is a technique that no one hopes will be used extensively or for very long," Kelly said during a May 11 NPR interview.
Sessions echoed the point in a June 5 interview with conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt.
"It’s certainly not our goal to separate children, but I do think it’s clear, it’s legitimate to warn people who come to the country unlawfully bringing children with them that they can’t expect that they’ll always be kept together," Sessions said.
On the same day as the interview, NBC News reported that officials are running out of space to shelter children separated from their parents. An HHS backlog is causing overstays at "border stations" that serve as the first stop for children before they are transferred over to HHS for longer-term placement, the report said.
Immigrant advocates and humanitarian groups have vigorously protested the "zero-tolerance" effort.
Many of the families apprehended at the border come from Central America fleeing gang violence and poverty and seeking asylum in the United States.
Jennifer Podkul, director of policy for Kids in Need of Defense, which represents unaccompanied immigrant and refugee children in their deportation proceedings, said a United Nations convention "specifically states asylum seekers should not be criminally prosecuted for entering without documentation because those fleeing persecution often do not have time/ability to get proper authorization before they are forced to flee."
The United Nations human rights office has also called for an end to the Trump administration’s practice that separates children and parents, saying that using immigration detention and family separation "as a deterrent runs counter to human rights standards and principles."
"The U.S. should immediately halt this practice of separating families and stop criminalizing what should at most be an administrative offense — that of irregular entry or stay in the U.S.," said Ravina Shamdasani, a spokeswoman for the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.
Nikki Haley, U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, pushed back, saying the organization was showing "its hypocrisy by calling out the United States while it ignores the reprehensible human rights records of several members of its own Human Rights Council."
Merkley, the Oregon senator, said he attempted to access a facility holding immigrant children in Brownsville, Texas, on June 3, but was refused entry. He was able to access a different facility in McAllen, Texas.
In the radio interview, Hewitt asked Sessions if he would go with Merkley or help him get into a facility holding immigrant children. Sessions said he’d "be glad to talk to him about it."
Merkley tweeted to the Justice Department in response: "Glad the Attorney General is willing to talk. Let’s meet and discuss this administration’s policy of separating children from their parents. AG Sessions, will you come with me to see a facility where these children are being held?"
As of this report’s publication, the agency had not publicly replied.
Justice Department, Attorney General Announces Zero-Tolerance Policy for Criminal Illegal Entry, April 6, 2018
Phone interview, Peter Margulies, an immigration law and national security law professor at Roger Williams University School of Law, June 5, 2018
Email and phone interview, Department of Homeland Security press office, June 5, 2018
Email interview, KIND press office, June 5, 2018
Sen. Jeff Merkley website, At Border, Merkley Demands Answers on Cruel Child Separation Policy, June 3, 2018
NBC News, Hundreds of migrant kids separated from parents are stuck at border stations, June 5, 2018
New York Times, Taking Migrant Children From Parents Is Illegal, U.N. Tells U.S., June 5, 2018
Reuters, Exclusive: Trump administration considering separating women, children at Mexico border, March 3, 2017
Hugh Hewitt, Jeff Sessions interview, June 5, 2018
Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing, TVPRA and Exploited Loopholes Affecting Unaccompanied Alien Children, May 23, 2018
PolitiFact, Sorting out the facts about nearly 1,500 lost children, Trump family separation policy, May 29, 2018
PolitiFact, Donald Trump blames Democrats for own immigration policy separating families, May 29, 2018
NPR, Transcript: White House Chief Of Staff John Kelly's Interview With NPR, May 11, 2018