Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Editor's Note: PolitiFact has reviewed court filings and other information for hundreds of defendants facing charges related to the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol in an ongoing effort to document what role misinformation played. This report reflects some of our findings about the way that hundreds of false claims about the 2020 election being stolen contributed to the events of that day. Our reporting will continue; read a previous report here. To comment on this story, please go to our Facebook page. Send feedback or tips via email to [email protected].
The moment showed unexpected order in what was otherwise the chaotic invasion of the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6.
A group of about 11 people snaked single-file through the crowd toward the building’s east side. They wore helmets and olive-green combat gear, vests and backpacks. Each stretched one arm forward to clasp the shoulder of the person in front of them.
An FBI investigator recognized the configuration when he saw it unfold in one of the hundreds of videos that surfaced from that day. It was "a tactical formation used by infantrymen in the military," the investigator later wrote in a federal complaint charging the people involved with federal crimes, including conspiracy. "The purpose of maintaining direct physical contact with one another is to efficiently communicate, especially in crowded or noisy areas."
Jessica Watkins was a 38-year-old former Army Ranger and veteran of the war in Afghanistan. She joined right out of high school in 2001 and completed airborne training before being deployed, according to reporting by BuzzFeed.
Watkins was forced out of the military "after her sexual orientation was discovered," her attorney wrote in a motion for home detention.
She later joined a nonprofit working on HIV prevention and took a job as a full-time firefighter and EMT when she returned to civilian life.
Watkins formed a small paramilitary group called the Ohio State Regular Militia, of which she described herself the commander. Her partner told Buzzfeed she was motivated to organize the group after a string of tornadoes left thousands of people without power in Dayton, Ohio. Prosecutors have referred to the militia in court documents as a "dues-paying subset of the Oath Keepers."
Most recently, Watkins was working at The Jolly Roger, a small bar in Woodstock, Ohio, that she owned and operated with her boyfriend.
But it wasn’t long until COVID-19 started to take a toll on the business.
"My small business is a bar," Watkins wrote on the conservative social media platform Parler just days before the Capitol riot. "Empty on a Saturday. ... Guess I am going to go pack for DC now. See you there."
The pandemic continued to worsen, protests against lockdowns and police brutality sprang up in cities and towns across the country, her militia started to patrol the protests and Watkins started to fall in with the Oath Keepers.
By the fall of 2020, she was in direct contact with the organization’s leadership about plans to travel to D.C. to overturn the results of a presidential election that she believed was stolen.
In one Nov. 9 text, she told someone that she was "awaiting direction" from Trump following the results of Joe Biden’s victory. She recruited and trained people who expressed interest in joining the militia, according to prosecutors, telling one, "I need you fighting fit by the inauguration."’
On Nov. 17, when a recruit asked her for her predictions for 2021, Watkins replied, "I can't predict. I don't underestimate the resolve of the Deep State. Biden may still yet be our President. If he is, our way of life as we know it is over. Our Republic would be over. Then it is our duty as Americans to fight, kill and die for our rights," court documents show.
Donovan Crowl, then a 50-year-old former Marine corporal who held occasional jobs in construction, had frequented Watkins’ bar and eventually joined her militia and the Oath Keepers organization.
Crowl, prosecutors said, traveled with Watkins to the Capitol for the insurrection. As he marched up the Capitol steps with the stack he donned a combat helmet, ballistic goggles and a handheld radio, photo and video evidence showed.
When authorities later searched Watkins’ Woodstock, Ohio, home after the riot, they recovered what appeared to be instructions on how to make explosives with bleach.
They also found camouflage hats and jackets, a black tactical kit with medical supplies, radios, helmets and "numerous" firearms, according to court records. The clothing and gear, prosecutors said, matched the attire worn by members of the stack.
On Nov. 9, days after the 2020 presidential election showed Biden winning, Oath Keepers from across the country met virtually on GotoMeeting video conferencing service. The organization’s founder, Stewart Rhodes, called on members to go to Washington, D.C.
"We’re going to defend the president, the duly elected president, and we call on him to do what needs to be done to save our country," Rhodes said. "Because if you don’t, guys, you’re going to be in a bloody, bloody civil war, and a bloody — you can call it an insurrection or you can call it a war or fight."
Rhodes, a former U.S. Army paratrooper and Yale Law School graduate, added that the group would be awaiting the president’s orders: "We hope he will give us the orders. We want him to declare an insurrection, and to call us up as the militia."
The Oath Keepers is a large but loosely organized paramilitary group that recruits current or former military and law enforcement and emphasizes military training. The organization’s leaders, like Rhodes, as well as its members have shared misinformation about so-called government plots since its founding in 2009, months after President Barack Obama was sworn in. The organization, according to the Southern Poverty Law Center, has grown into one of the largest radical anti-government groups in the country.
The modern militia movement came into focus in the U.S. in the mid 1990s and largely consists of right-wing, armed paramilitary groups with anti-government or conspiracy-orientated ideologies. Militia groups began to form not long after the deadly standoff at Waco, Texas, in 1993, and by the spring of 1995, they had spread to almost every state, according to the Anti- Defamation League.
Timothy McVeigh, the perpetrator in the Oklahoma City bombing at a federal building that killed 168 people and injured more than 680 others in 1995, was a veteran of the Gulf War and sympathizer with the U.S. militia movement who sought to retaliate against the federal government for its role in Waco. McVeigh’s act was the worst act of domestic terrorism by a U.S. citizen.
Anti-government groups like the Oath Keepers aren’t typically picky about membership, experts said, but military experience is considered a plus.
"The Oath Keepers have a specific motivation to reach out to veterans in regards to their motto to honor their oath, but their reasoning is also functional," said Samuel Jackson, an assistant professor and expert on the militia movement at the University at Albany, New York. "Many of these people have experiences in combat but also intelligence and psychological operations. There’s a huge variety of skills that would be useful for an organization that perceives, anticipates and, at times, might want to bring about violence."
Members believe that the U.S. government has been "co-opted" by a "cabal of elites" who are actively trying to strip American citizens of their rights, prosecutors argue in their court filings.
Rhodes, 56, has frequently appeared on Alex Jones’ conspiracy theory-laden show InfoWars, and members have served as security at prominent GOP events and for Trump allies like Republican operative Roger Stone.
Rhodes warned his followers during that Nov. 9 meeting to come prepared to fight antifa, a left-wing, anti-fascist movement, according to court dcuments that show he asked some to come fully armed.
"If the fight comes, let the fight come. Let antifa — if they go kinetic on us, then we’ll go kinetic back on them," Rhodes said, according to court documents that show he asked some to come fully armed.
Kelly Meggs, a 52-year-old car dealership manager from Dunnellon, Fla., answered the call. As the self-described leader of the Florida Oath Keepers, Meggs told others on Facebook that he was in touch with the far-right extremist Proud Boys group, and another right-wing militia organization known as the Three Percenters.
"We have decided to work together and shut this s--- down," he wrote Dec. 19, court filings show. The coordination made sense he said in another message a few days later: "They always have a big group. Force multiplier."
The Proud Boys would get in front of antifa and then police officers would try to separate the two groups, he said. That’s when Oath Keepers would come in.
"We will come in behind antifa and beat the hell out of them," he wrote.
When Jan. 6 arrived, the group prepared themselves for battle, equipped with communication devices and various tactical items including vests, helmets, ballistic goggles and hard-knuckle gloves, prosecutors said.
Between around 11 a.m. and 4 p.m. Rhodes exchanged roughly 10 phone calls with members, court documents show, including several with Meggs. He also messaged the Leadership Signal Chat at 1:25 p.m.
"Pence is doing nothing. As I predicted," he wrote, referencing Vice President Mike Pence’s decision to approve the certification of Biden’s win in spite of pressure from Trump and others to refuse. "All I see Trump doing is complaining," he wrote about 15 minutes later. "I see no intent by him to do anything. So the patriots are taking it into their own hands. They’ve had enough."
The situation outside of the Capitol quickly deteriorated. A crowd gathered outside the east side doors threw objects, sprayed chemicals at police, and pulled violently on the doors to forcibly push their way into the Capitol, the indictment said.
The Oath Keepers traveled in its military stack up the Capitol steps. Video shows them pushing into the mob and advancing toward the Rotunda doors.
"Who’s our president?" someone is heard shouting off-camera.
"Trump!" the crowd responds.
"Who’s our president?"
As the doors open and people start to enter, someone sends up a cheer, "Oath Keepers!"
Another man is heard registering his amazement: "We’re the first wave, man! This has never been done."
Inside, the stack remained in formation and told Oath Keepers outside that they made it in.
"We’re in the f------ Capitol!" Watkins said in a video after they made it into the Capitol rotunda. Watkins and Crowl turned the camera around for a selfie.
Experts who study and track extremist and anti-government militia organizations said most members of these types of far-right groups have been immersed in conspiracy theories for years and employ misinformation to get people angry and recruit them to their causes.
"The concept of a new world order, a tyrannical government, of entities wanting to take away their guns. Those are tried-and-true narratives that have animated people within the broader anti-government movement," said Oren Segal, the vice president of the Anti-Defamation League’s Center on Extremism. "And, they found a friend in QAnon that approached this from a different, semi-incoherent space, but that was making some of the same allegations."
One way that manifested was in the group’s apparent belief that it would be fighting antifa on Jan. 6. As Crowl wrote on Facebook the day prior, they were going "tifa hunt’in."
"We expect good hunting," he wrote.
The reality was far different. In court files of more than 550 people arrested in connection with the storming of the Capitol as of early September, PolitiFact found only one who mentioned an association with far-left causes, a man who identified himself as a journalist but who had no press credentials. While some in conservative circles pointed to defendant John Sullivan as "known antifa," PolitiFact and other fact-checkers have found no evidence of that based on interviews and reviews of public records.
Most of those present that day were pro-Trump allies who believed their candidate’s false assertion that the election had been stolen. Yet Trump allies, including some associated with Oath Keepers and Proud Boys, baselessly called the attack an antifa set-up, a claim that PolitiFact and others have repeatedly debunked.
"I think many of the people who were there were planning on engaging in that conflict with antifa," said Jackson, the militia expert. "They believed someone needed to be ready to push back against antifa violence ... and this ties into how much they believe that antifa is a well-formed group for which violence is really central."
The 2020 election wasn’t the first time the Oath Keepers expressed mistrust in the country’s oldest democratic process.
Many were ordered to station themselves at polling locations across the country during the 2016 presidential election to "watch out" for voter fraud. The group believed that if Trump didn’t win the popular vote by a landslide, Jackson told us, it was the work of Democrats deliberately undermining the votes.
They organized their call to action shortly after Trump started prophesying that the election would be rigged.
"I hear these horror shows, and we have to make sure that this election is not stolen from us and is not taken away from us," Trump said in October 2016 to a crowd in Pennsylvania. "And everybody knows what I’m talking about."
This isn’t all about the past. Nine months after the nation watched hundreds of people enter and ransack the U.S. Capitol, the Oath Keepers and groups like the Proud Boys remain active.
In the face of federal charges and national spectacle, experts say, members of these groups — whether they are defendants who were there that day or not — find themselves grappling with the gravity of what transpired.
Watkins, in a February court hearing disavowed Oath Keepers and rescinded her membership, saying she was "humbled" and "humiliated" by the charges against her.
Her attorneys told the federal government that Watkins has disbanded her militia, and rid herself of all firearms.
"She has declared she is sickened by what happened in the Capitol on Jan. 6," they wrote in a motion arguing for bond, saying she wants to return home to a simple life.
Watkins' lawyers argue that her intention all along was simply to provide security to the speakers of the rally and to safely escort protestors away from the Capitol to their vehicles — not to be an insurrectionist. They said she was given a VIP pass to the rally and even "met with secret service agents."
But her comments shortly after the riot paint a different picture.
"Me after forcing entry into the Capitol building," read one of Watkins’ posts on Parler after the riot.
"Yeah we stormed the Capitol today. Teargassed, the whole 9. Pushed our way into the Rotunda. Made it into the Senate even. The news is lying (even Fox) about the Historical Events we created today."
PolitiFact reached out to the attorneys for Watkins, Crowl, Meggs and Caldwell, as well as representatives for other defendants belonging to the Oath Keepers. Some declined to comment. We didn’t hear back from others.
Intelligence agencies warned in March of the ongoing threat that racially-motivated extremist groups might carry out mass-casualty attacks on civilians, while militia organizations like the Oath Keepers would target police and government personnel and buildings.
Fallout from the Jan. 6 riot, as well as conspiracy theories and the election lie, "will almost certainly spur" some domestic extremists "to try to engage in violence this year," read the assessment from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.
Segal of the ADL’s Center on Extremism said that the instability these groups are experiencing can create its own threat as people splinter off into smaller, less visible groups.
"I think with time it's going to be clear that either the events of the 6th, or the narrative that animated people to action on the 6th, will continue into the near future," Segal said. "Jan. 6th may very well be the incubator for plots of the future, and we don't have the luxury to assume otherwise."
PolitiFact reporters Bill McCarthy and Gabrielle Settles and researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.
U.S. Department of Justice, "Capitol Breach Cases," accessed through Sept. 10 2021
United States District Court For the District of Columbia, United States of America v Thomas Caldwell, Donovan Crowl, Jessica Watkins, Sandra Parker, Bennie Parker, Graydon Young, Laura Steele, Kelly Meggs, Connie Meggs, Kenneth Harrelson, Jonathan Walden, Roberto Minuta, Joshua James, Joseph Hackett, Jason Dolan, William Isaacs, David Moerschel and Brian Ulrich, Accessed May-Sept 20, 2021
United States District Court For the District of Columbia, Criminal Complaint; Kelly Meggs, Connie Meggs, Graydon Young and Laura Steele, Feb. 11, 2021
YouTube, Capitol rioters included trained ex-military, cops, Jan. 15, 2021
United States District Court For the District of Columbia, Nordean Biggs Rehl Donohoe - Indictment, March 10, 2021
United States District Court For the District of Columbia, Kelly Meggs detention memo, March 23, 2021
United States District Court For the District of Columbia, Thomas Caldwell; Donovan Crowl; Jessica Watkins - Affidavit, Aug. 4, 2021
Court Listener, Memorandum in Support of Pretrial Detention — Document #15 as to Jessica Marie Watkins, March 17, 2021
Court Listener, Motion for Bond, Jessica Watkins — Document #26, Feb. 20, 2021
Court Listener, Motion for Bond, Jessica Watkins — Document #89, March 18, 2021
United States District Court For the District of Columbia, Pezzola Superseding Indictment, Accessed May-Sept. 10, 2021
Court Listener, Affidavit in Support — Document #5, Attachment #1, March 24, 2021
U.S. Justice Department, Fifth Superseding Indictment Unsealed in Oath Keeper Conspiracy Case Related to Jan. 6 Capitol Breach, Aug. 9, 2021
U.S. Justice Department, Seven Months Since the Jan. 6 Attack on the Capitol, Aug. 6, 2021
LawyersCommittee.org, Smith v. Trump criminal complaint, Aug. 26, 2021
Various searches on Court Listener, accessed through Sept. 20, 2021
Various searches on social media, accessed through Sept. 20, 2021
BuzzFeed, Meet The Woman Facing Some Of The Most Serious Capitol Riot Charges, Jan. 27, 2021
WayBack Machine, Ohio Regular Militia archived posts, As of Jan. 7, 2021
The New Yorker, A Former Marine Stormed the Capitol as Part of a Far-Right Militia, Jan. 14, 2021
PolitiFact, Misinformation and the Jan. 6 insurrection: When ‘patriot warriors’ were fed lies, June 30, 2021
PolitiFact, Jan. 6 defendants were armed with guns, other weapons, documents show, July 13, 2021
PolitiFact, Yes, Jan. 6 Capitol assault was an "armed insurrection", Feb. 15, 2021
PolitiFact, There’s no proof antifa stormed the Capitol. The rumor spread quickly anyway, Jan. 7, 2021
PolitiFact, No, George Soros is not a Nazi who funds antifa, Aug. 6, 2020
PolitiFact, No proof man who filmed Capitol riot led it, or was antifa, July 30, 2021
PolitiFact, Face-painted man in horned fur cap at Capitol riot supports Trump and QAnon, not antifa, Jan. 7, 2021
YouTube, Police battle Trump supporters storming Capitol, five killed," Jan. 6, 2021
Washington Post, Who caused the violence at protests? It wasn’t antifa., June 22, 2021
NPR, Dozens Of Westerners Join Kurds To Fight ISIS In Syria, March 15, 2018
OathKeepers.org, Oath Keepers CALL TO ACTION to Spot, Document, and Report Vote Fraud or Intimidation on Election Day, 2016, Oct. 25, 2016
New York Times, Donald Trump’s Call to Monitor Polls Raises Fears of Intimidation, Oct. 18, 2016
New York Times, How a Presidential Rally Turned Into a Capitol Rampage, Jan. 12, 2021
History.com, Oklahoma City bombing, updated April 16, 2021
Anti-Defamation League, The Militia Movement, Accessed Sept. 20, 2021
Anti-Defamation League, H.E.A.T. map, Accessed August-Sept. 20, 2021
Center for Strategic & International Studies, Who Are Antifa, and Are They a Threat? June 4, 2020
Center for Strategic & International Studies, The Escalating Terrorism Problem in the United States, June 17, 2020
The Intercept, Leaked Documents Show Police Knew Far-right Extremists Were the Real Threat at Protests, Not "antifa", July 15, 2020
Washington Post Rep. Matt Gaetz and other GOP politicians baselessly suggest antifa is to blame for pro-Trump mob rioting into Capitol, Jan. 7, 2021
Phone interview with Samuel Jackson, assistant professor and expert on the militia movement at the University at Albany, New York, July 21, 2021
Phone interview with Oren Segal vice president at the Anti-Defamation League’s Center on Extremism, July 23, 2021
Phone interview with Brian Levin director of the Center for the Study of Hate & Extremism and professor of criminal justice at California State University, San Bernardino, July 26, 2021
Zoom/Email interview with Mark Pitcavage historian and senior research fellow at the Anti-Defamation League’s Center on Extremism, Aug. 5, 2021
Phone interview with Mark Bray historian and part-time lecturer at Rutgers University, Aug. 10, 2021
Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Domestic Violent Extremism Poses Heightened Threat in 2021, March 1, 2021
C-SPAN, House Homeland Security Hearing on National Security Threats, Sept. 17, 2020
Southern Poverty Law Center, Oath Keepers, Accessed July 25, 2021
ProPublica, What Parler Saw During the Attack on the Capitol, Jan. 17, 2021
PBS, Members of Several Well-Known Hate Groups Identified at Capitol Riot, Jan. 9, 2021
Washington Post, ‘A place to fund hope’: How Proud Boys and other fringe groups found refuge on a Christian fundraising website, Jan. 18, 2021
Washington Post, Prosecutors allege ‘alliance’ between Proud Boys and Oath Keepers on Jan. 6, March 24, 2021
CBS News, Proud Boys and Oath Keepers expected at September 18 rally in D.C., Sept. 2, 2021