Get PolitiFact in your inbox.

Joe Biden
stated on October 30, 2007 in Philadelphia:
Rudy Giuliani is "probably the most underqualified man since George Bush to seek the presidency."
true pants-fire
By Michael Van Sickler November 6, 2007

Rudy has run the nation's largest city

During the Oct. 30 Democratic debate, Sen. Joe Biden won the biggest laugh of the night when he said "there's only three things that (Rudy Giuliani) mentions in his sentences — a noun, a verb and 9/11."

But the first part of this passage had this doozy: "And the irony is Rudy Giuliani, probably the most underqualified man since George Bush to seek the presidency, is here talking about any of the people here."

When the audience laughed, Biden clarified by saying, "I mean this sincerely; he is genuinely not qualified to be president."

We talked to historians to assess Biden's statement and see how Giuliani stacks up. (Our detailed look at the candidates' experience can be found in our story here.)

Historians like Sean Wilentz, a Princeton history professor who is sharply criticial of George W. Bush, said you can't discount Giuliani's eight years as mayor of New York City.

Featured Fact-check

"Experience on the local level doesn't carry much weight in presidential campaigns," Wilentz said. "But it's the city of New York. It's no ordinary city, and that's an advantage he has."

Add a crisis like 9/11, where Giuliani was involved in the ground zero rescue effort, and he has experience other candidates don't have, said Stanley Renshon, a political science professor for the City University of New York.

"Giuliani got a taste of what it was like to be president," Renshon said. "He was the only person at the epicenter of an attack on American soil."

He also has six years as U.S. attorney in New York, where he prosecuted mob figures and Wall Street titans.

By contrast, Biden's fellow Democrat John Edwards has only six years of experience in the Senate. Barack Obama has only three in the U.S. Senate and eight in the Illinois Senate. We find Biden's rhetoric is not backed up by the facts because it ignores Giuliani's considerable experience as U.S. attorney and mayor of the nation's largest city. That's not just wrong, that's Pants on Fire wrong.

Our Sources

Interview with Stanley Renshon, City University of New York

Interview with Sean Wilentz, History Department at Princeton University

The Almanac of American Politics, 2006 and 2004

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Michael Van Sickler

Rudy has run the nation's largest city

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up