Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
President-elect Barack Obama's widely reported intention to appoint Sanjay Gupta, a 39-year-old neurosurgeon and CNN reporter, as the nation's surgeon general has drawn flak from several directions.
Gupta is known primarily for his work as a TV reporter, though he's clearly identified as a medical doctor. A number of commentators have attacked Gupta's health care reporting for criticizing Michael Moore's film Sicko in a segment on CNN. A blogger at Gawker joked that Gupta must have beat out Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman. Some advocates of the Commissioned Corps, a team of federal health workers led by the surgeon general, say the job should go to someone who rose through the ranks.
Defenders of the choice, including former Surgeon General Joycelyn Elders, Democratic National Committee chair Howard Dean, and the consumer advocates at the nonprofit Center for Science in the Public Interest, have cited Gupta's communication skills.
Here's how Dean put it in a Jan. 7, 2009, appearance on MSNBC's Hardball :
"I think he's a great appointment," Dean told host Chris Matthews. "I'll tell you why he's a great appointment. The biggest job of the surgeon general is to translate health care and health care needs into plain English that people can understand, ordinary people can understand. That's what Sanjay Gupta has been doing for a living for quite a while."
Communication is indeed a major part of the job. Surgeons general have long held the symbolic post of the "nation's doctor," offering advice on smoking cessation, obesity, AIDS prevention and a host of other public health issues through speeches, news conferences, congressional testimony and formal reports.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, under which the surgeon general serves, lists this sort of public outreach as the first of seven official duties of the surgeon general.
In congressional hearings about the nature of the position in 2007, former Surgeon General C. Everett Koop said "he or she should be the health educator for Americans par excellence." A subsequent surgeon general, David Satcher, said the office has evolved since its inception in 1873 but "what has not changed about the Surgeon General’s Office is its direct responsibility for communicating with the American people based on the best available science, and its responsibility for responding to public health emergencies."
So yes, by job description, tradition and widespread consensus, the surgeon general is the medical communicator in chief, you might say.
But that's not the whole truth.
The surgeon general also oversees the Commissioned Corps of the U.S. Public Health Service, 6,000 uniformed public health workers assigned to other government agencies, such as the National Institutes of Health. His administrative duties over the corps are limited, to be sure, because the positions are funded and the officers overseen day-to-day by the heads of the agencies to which they're assigned. But he sets standards for the corps, has significant administrative responsibilities and serves as the group's titular leader.
More significant is the surgeon general's customary responsibility to represent the federal government on various elite boards and commissions. Past surgeons general have sat alongside national and global health experts at the National Library of Medicine, the American Medical Association and the World Health Organization, for example. In these settings, medical gravitas would seem to matter far more than mass-communication skills.
But most importantly, Dean glossed over a crucial component of the public outreach part of the job — you have to know what to say. Surgeon generals don't just present public health initiatives, they craft them. Surgeon generals' reports — the landmark example of which is Smoking and Health, the 1964 report in which the government first spelled out to the public that smoking causes lung cancer — are generally years in the making.
"It's not like you just sit down and write this report," Richard Carmona, who served as the 17th surgeon general, from 2002 to 2006, said in a telephone interview. "They take a long time and they only happen if you have the credibility and knowledge to extract this information properly. You're working with people at the Centers for Disease Control, the National Institutes of Health, you're looking at heart science, clinical science — your credibility comes in. Your peers have to respect you and see you as a nonpartisan arbiter of the best science."
Gupta is a practicing neurosurgeon and an assistant professor of neurosurgery at Emory University School of Medicine, and he writes a column for Time magazine in addition to reporting for CNN. We'll leave it to Congress and others to decide whether that qualifies him to be surgeon general.
And if Gupta does get the position, he and Obama have a certain amount of latitude to make of it what they like.
But being doctor to the nation has traditionally involved more than just advising it on health issues — you have to check up on it first. Surgeon general is a public health position, not a public affairs position. Communication may be the "biggest part of the job" in a sense, but many other medical and administrative skills are required.
We find Dean's statement Half True.
MSNBC's Hardball, Jan. 7, 2009
Washington Post, TV's Gupta Is Obama's Pick for Surgeon General , Jan. 7, 2009
Columbia Journalism Review, The TV Doc As Surgeon General , Jan. 8, 2009
New York Times, The Trouble With Sanjay Gupta , Jan. 6, 2009
New York Times, CNN Reporter Tops List for Surgeon General , Jan. 6, 2009
Surgeongeneral.gov, Duties of the Surgeon General , accessed Jan. 13, 2009
Gawker.com, New Surgeon General: Dr. Sanjay Gupta , Jan. 6, 2009, accessed Jan. 13, 2009
Time.com, Surgeon General: Sanjay Gupta , Jan. 8, 2009, accessed Jan. 12, 2009
Surgeongeneral.gov, Previous Surgeons General , accessed Jan. 13, 2009
USPHS.gov, U.S. Public Health Service Commissioned Corps , accessed Jan. 13, 2009
The Surgeon General's Vital Mission: Challenges for the Future , House of Representatives Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, July 10, 2007, accessed Jan. 13, 2009
Center for Science in the Public Interest, Nomination of Dr. Sanjay Gupta as Surgeon General Supported by CSPI , Jan. 7, 2009, accessed Jan. 13, 2009
Interview with Gerard Farrell, executive director of the Commissioned Officers Association of the U.S. Public Health Service, Jan. 12, 2009
Interview with former Surgeon General Richard Carmona, Jan. 13, 2009
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.