Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Limbaugh claims White House benefits from Haiti donations
After an earthquake hit Haiti last week, Rush Limbaugh made a series of controversial claims about the disaster, which killed tens of thousands and devastated the infrastructure and institutions of the poor Caribbean nation.
On the Jan. 13, 2010, edition of his show, Limbaugh said President Barack Obama's administration would use the quake to "build 'credibility' with the black community -- in the both light-skinned and dark-skinned black community in this country." He claimed Americans have "already donated to Haiti. It's called the U.S. income tax." While talking with a caller, he cast doubt on whether money donated through Whitehouse.gov would end up in Haiiti, and said the people who did donate through the White House would find their e-mail addresses receiving fundraising appeals from Obama.
On Monday, he suggested that the White House was somehow acting as a middleman for donations and then skimming off a high percentage for administrative costs.
Limbaugh noted the criticisms of the charity run by Wyclef Jean ("Is Wyclef Jean a rap star or is he just reggae kind of music?" Limbaugh asked) has high administrative costs.
"What about the administrative costs of donating through WhiteHouse.gov, for crying out loud?" Limbaugh asked. "Do you know that one of the reasons the welfare budget is as high as it is -- and these numbers are I guess 10 years old, but in 1999, maybe earlier than that, for every dollar that was budgeted for welfare or food stamps, AFDC, whatever it is, 28 cents of it was spent on administering it, so 72 cents out of every dollar got there. I mean the high administrative costs are actually when you donate through the government," he said.
"I don't know of a president ever who has asked people to donate to a relief effort through a White House Web site. It's never happened before. ... Nobody here ever said don't donate. We just pointed out you already contribute to the government with your income taxes. If you want to donate above and beyond that, go through a charity that's constantly on the ground in Haiti, or the Red Cross, if you want to go that route or whatever. Nobody said do not donate, which is what is being reported."
In one respect, Limbaugh is right: He never said Americans shouldn't donate to Haiti. He did say to do it through private groups. But his point here was that the White House was somehow acting as an inefficient middleman.
That got us wondering: Would donating through WhiteHouse.gov be inefficient compared with donating directly to the Red Cross or some other charitable organization? Do "high administrative costs" happen "when you donate through the government"? Instead of helping the people displaced by the quake, would the money instead be used to pay government salaries?
We started looking around and discovered this: You never could actually donate through WhiteHouse.gov. On seemingly every White House Web page that mentions Haiti, there is a link to the Red Cross or the Clinton-Bush Haiti Fund. (There are no links to Wyclef Jean's group.) But those are just links to those sites -- not some kind of PayPal for the Obama White House.
"I can confirm that we are not processing/have never processed any donations to Haiti through whitehouse.gov, but are just directing folks to other groups," White House spokesman Matt Lehrich wrote in an e-mail. Lehrich also said there was no overhead being delivered to the White House nor the federal government, and that e-mail addresses of donors to the Red Cross or the Clinton-Bush Haiti Fund wouldn't be shared.
So it makes no difference whether you click the link from WhiteHouse.gov or go directly to the groups' own sites.
To address Limbaugh's point that some charities make more efficient use of donations than others, we checked to see how the ones recommended on the White House site stack up.
We looked at Charity Navigator, a Web site that grades and ranks charities. It gives the Red Cross a rating of three stars out of four. The Clinton-Bush Haiti fund, a joint effort of Bush's Communities Foundation of Texas and Clinton's William J. Clinton Foundation, was only formed last weekend and doesn't have a rating yet. But the William J. Clinton Foundation has a full four-star rating, and the Communities Foundation earned three stars.
We looked at another charity ranking system, the Better Business Bureau's Wise Giving Alliance. The American Red Cross made its list of recommended Haiti charities. But the Clinton Foundation only fulfilled 13 of the 20 standards for charity accountability. The Communities Foundation hasn't been rated yet.
In comparison, Wyclef Jean's Yele Foundation, which sparked Limbaugh's complaint, isn't rated by Charity Navigator. But in a blog post, the organization seems skeptical of Yele. The Wise Giving Alliance doesn't have a rating for Yele, but its director told the Associated Press the organization was "questionable." (Jean has defended the organization.)
So Limbaugh is seriously distorting the truth, suggesting that people can donate through the White House when in fact the White House site has simply posted links to groups that earn generally positive ratings. There's no evidence the White House is using any of these donations for administrative costs, and the charities aren't sharing donors' e-mail addresses with the White House. Limbaugh is making a ridiculously false claim that the Obama administration is capitalizing on a tragedy. That's enough to set the meter ablaze. Pants on Fire!
Rush Limbaugh, Obama Leaps into Action on Haiti, January 13, 2010
Rush Limbaugh, Of Course, I Never Told Anyone Not to Donate to a Charitable Cause, January 15, 2010
Rush Limbaugh, I Never Said "Don't Donate" to Haiti, January 18, 2010
The White House, Haiti Earthquke Relief
American Red Cross, Support Haiti Relief and Development
Clinton Bush Haiti Fund
E-mail interview with Matt Lehrich, White House Spokesman, January 20, 2010
Charity Navigator, Help Survivors of the Earthquake in Haiti
Wise Giving Alliance, Charities Providing Haiti Earthquake Relief, January 13, 2010
Wise Giving Alliance, Charity Review of William J. Clinton Foundation, January 2010
Charity Navigator Blog, Wyclef Jean's Yele Haiti Foundation, January 16, 2010
Associated Press, Groups Raise Doubts About Wyclef Jean's Charity, January 15, 2010
Read About Our Process
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Kevin Robillard
Limbaugh claims White House benefits from Haiti donations
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.