Get PolitiFact in your inbox.

By Eric Stirgus July 29, 2010

GOP comparison to Pelosi "inaccurate," congressman says

It seems like no one wants to be associated with Nancy Pelosi these days.

Many Republican politicians are using Pelosi, the U.S. House speaker, as the boogeywoman this election season. And there's no place better to do that than in Georgia politics.

Mike Keown, a Republican state lawmaker, tried to link the liberal Pelosi to his opponent, incumbent U.S. Rep. Sanford Bishop (D-Ga.), in the Nov. 2 election for Georgia's 2nd Congressional District, which is situated in southwest Georgia and includes Albany and most of Columbus.

Bishop "wants to distance himself from Nancy Pelosi," Keown said in one statement. "However, that is going to be difficult after his votes on Obamacare, every stimulus and bailout program and increasing the tax debt on every citizen in the 2nd district over $40,000."

A spokesman for the 18-year congressman from South Georgia fired back in a recent news release.

"Rep. [Mike] Keown's suggestion that Rep. Pelosi's voting record is similar to Congressman Bishop's is inaccurate," Bishop spokesman Ashton McRae wrote in an e-mail on Bishop's congressional Web site.

McRae quickly got in trouble for using the Web site to attack Bishop's opponent. McRae posted an apology two days later.

Despite the mea culpa, PolitiFact Georgia wanted to examine the claim the Bishop camp was trying to debunk. Do Bishop and Pelosi vote similarly?

Bishop has fashioned himself as a moderate Democrat. He has breezed through his past three elections, winning about two-thirds of the vote against his Republican challengers, but he is apparently taking no chances. His district does not lean one way. Democrat Barack Obama beat Republican John McCain in the district by about 7,000 votes in the 2008 presidential race. Sonny Perdue, a Republican, defeated Democrat Mark Taylor by more than 5,000 votes in the 2006 race for governor. In the 2004 presidential race, Republican George W. Bush beat Democrat John Kerry by about 20,000 votes.

McRae correctly points out that Pelosi and Bishop have voted differently on some issues, such as allowing gays to openly serve in the military. Pelosi is for it; Bishop is against it.

The Washington Post keeps track of votes by each member of Congress. Bishop voted on more items than Pelosi, so we checked every time they voted on the same issue. PolitiFact Georgia reviewed their records and found that Bishop and Pelosi have voted on the same items 97 times since June 2008. The two voted the same way 92 of those 97 times, according to the Post database. The Post database found Pelosi voted with the majority of Democrats every time during this current Congress. Bishop voted with his colleagues in the Democratic Party 97.7 percent of the time during this Congress, the Post found.

PolitiFact Georgia also checked the Web site of OpenCongress, which detailed information of each bill. We found 61 pieces of legislation (we excluded a comparison of how they voted on congratulating the New Orleans Saints for winning the Super Bowl) that both Bishop and Pelosi voted on. The two representatives voted the same way for 58 of those 61 bills. They differed on legislation such as the redeployment of military contractors in May 2007; the DISCLOSE Act, which would require corporations to name the top five donors in their political ads; and a resolution concerning the limitation of liabilities against doctors and hospitals. The OpenCongress database didn't go back further.

On Tuesday, PolitiFact Georgia contacted McRae, who works in Bishop's congressional office. He referred us to the Bishop campaign for comment. We spoke late Tuesday to Bishop campaign spokesman Tim Turner, who sent PolitiFact Georgia a statement late Wednesday. Turner argued the Post database is filled with ceremonial bills. He pointed us to the National Journal, which compiles an annual rating of each member of Congress based on his or her voting record. The Journal rated Bishop as a "centrist" based on his votes in 2009.

Turner argued that focusing on the percentage of times Bishop voted along with his fellow Democrats is misleading.

"It only makes sense that Congressman Bishop would vote with his party to end Republican obstruction," he said.

Pelosi and Bishop are not ideological twins, but two separate databases show the two Democrats vote similarly on legislation that came before them. The numbers are pretty similar. We rate the statement from the Bishop camp as False.

Featured Fact-check

Our Sources

E-mails from Mike Keown campaign spokesman Jay Walker, July 26, 27, 2010

E-mail from Sanford Bishop campaign spokesman Tim Turner, July 28, 2010

National Journal 2009 rankings

OpenCongress, Sanford Bishop voting history

OpenCongress, Nancy Pelosi voting history

by Sanford Bishop spokesman Ashton McRae, July 23, 2010

Washington Post, Sanford Bishop voting history

Washington Post, Nancy Pelosi voting history

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Eric Stirgus

GOP comparison to Pelosi "inaccurate," congressman says

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up