Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Austin lawyer Mindy Montford, seeking the Democratic nomination for a state district judgeship, says she’s got vast courthouse experience, much of that from eight-plus years as a Travis County assistant district attorney, which followed her job as a Harris County prosecutor.
Montford, running for judge of the 299th state district court, says on her campaign Web site that she’s had over 100 trials and handled thousands of cases, a claim that seems possible considering she worked nearly a decade as a prosecutor.
We were exploring those claims when we came across a more dramatic Montford mailer that reached voters in mid-February. It states that Montford "has tried over 100 jury cases in Travis County courts."
Talk about close-to-home experience. We shifted gears to check her Travis County claim.
Montford earlier had told us she reached her total for Travis County jury trials by estimating trials she had worked on while in the Travis County DA's office, from October 1999 through the end of her tenure there in May 2008. Montford said she averaged 10 jury trials a year. "Some years there were fewer than 10 and some years there were more than 10," she said.
Using Montford's claimed average, that adds up to 87 jury trials over eight years and eight months. Montford said she also had one jury trial as a lawyer in private practice, in 2009.
That brings us to 88 Travis County jury trials, short of her mailer's claim to over 100 jury trials.
After we asked her about the mailer, Montford admitted it was in error. "You are correct that some of our campaign literature mistakenly says that I have tried over 100 jury trials in Travis County," she said. "That was an oversight and one that was never meant to mislead anyone. In every speech I have made on the trail, I have never claimed that all my jury trials were in Travis County and our Web site correctly states the information."
On her campaign site and on other mailers, Montford's claim to over 100 jury trials does not say they were all in Travis County.
UPDATE: After our initial post of this item Feb. 27, PolitiFact Texas came across a door hanger distributed by Montford's campaign including the statement that she'd tried over 100 cases in Travis County courts. Her consultant, Mark Littlefield, then said that 1,000 of the door hangers were printed and distributed though he said volunteers spent time marking out the Travis County trials' claim on the hangers--a cross-out that didn't appear on the hanger we fielded. Littlefield said there are no other campaign items with Montford's trials-in-Travis County claim.
Seeking an independent count of Montford's Travis County trials, we contacted the Travis County DA’s office. Spokesman Rudy Magallanes said Montford was the first- or second-chair prosecutor in 61 trials. She topped out at 14 trials in 2000. She had her low of two trials in 2006.
Counting the single jury trial that Montford reports having as a lawyer in private practice, her confirmed jury trials in Travis County would number 62.
There’s a small wrinkle, though.
Travis County District Attorney Rosemary Lehmberg, who bested Montford in a 2008 runoff for the Democratic nomination for district attorney, vouched for the 61 Montford jury trials reflected in a list kept by the executive assistant to the first assistant district attorney. But Lehmberg said the list might be incomplete. "There could have been more (Montford) trials that we did not write down," she said.
We also checked with Harris County and compiled a list of 36 trials that had Montford as a prosecutor there. Like Lehmberg, Scott Durfee, an assistant general counsel for the Harris County District Attorney’s office, cautioned that the tabulation of trials by each attorney might be incomplete.
So how does Montford’s statement of "over 100 jury trials" in Travis County stand up?
As she admitted, not well; it was an erroneous mailing.
Using Montford's own annual estimate, we reached a total of 88 Travis County jury trials. The DA's list is even shorter, prompting us to presume just 62 Montford jury trials in the county. In both counts, we take Montford at her word that she handled a single jury trial as a private lawyer.
Even if the DA's office failed to count a few Montford trials, it wouldn't be enough to make her statement accurate, though Montford's trials confirmed by Travis and Harris counties plus the one she says she had in private practice add up to 98, which is close to 100.
Montford owned up; we agree her mailer was wrong. We rate her statement as False.
E-mails, Rudy Magallanes, executive assistant to the district attorney, Travis County District Attorney’s office, Feb. 22, 2010
E-mails and interview, Mindy Montford, Feb. 23, 24 and 25, 2010
Harris County District Attorney's office, list of Mindy Montford trials,
Feb. 24, 2010
Interview, Scott Durfee, assistant general counsel, Harris County District Attorney's office, Feb. 23, 2010
Interviews, Rosemary Lehmberg, district attorney, Travis County, Feb. 24 and 25, 2010
Interview, Mark Littlefield, consultant to Mindy Montford campaign, March 3, 2010
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.