Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
The Republican Party of Texas marveled — not in a good way — at an admission of sorts by U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi about the long-stalled health care overhaul before Congress. According to an e-mail the GOP sent Friday, Pelosi said “the Democrats have to pass their terrible health care bill so that the American people can actually find out what's in it.”
Talk about a banana-peel moment. Did Pelosi improbably denigrate her party’s promised legislation and say people can find out what’s in it after it passes?
GOP spokesman Bryan Preston pointed us to the text of Pelosi’s March 9 speech in Washington to the National Association of Counties.
We learned, for starters, that while the Texas GOP thinks the legislation is terrible, Pelosi clearly doesn't. Instead, Pelosi's remarks celebrate aspects such as a ban on denying health coverage because of a pre-existing conditions, “robust support for public health infrastructure,” more spending on community health centers and reductions in uncompensated care by hospitals. Pelosi also says in the speech that the plan won't require anyone to pay a deductible for preventive health care doctor visits.
She summarizes: “It’s going to be very, very exciting.”
Yet there’s heft to the GOP's claim that Pelosi said the legislation has to pass so people can find out what’s in it.
Pelosi adds: “But we have to pass the bill so you can find out what is in it, away from the fog of controversy.”
Pelosi's words stirred critics from the right including Marguerite Higgins, a senior editorial services associate at The Heritage Foundation. In a blog, Higgins named the moment the video of the week and called Pelosi’s statement a “stunning demonstration of political condescension.”
Separately, Pelosi spokesman Brendan Daly offered this interpretation of Pelosi's comment: "She meant there was so much talk about process (in Congress) that people have lost sight of what’s actually in the bill. Once it’s passed, we can remind them of all the good things that are in it."
Capital fusses aside, we wondered if Pelosi spoke accurately; will the plan need to pass before people know what's in it?
We called the non-partisan Kaiser Family Foundation, which has posted side-by-side comparisons online of health care plans approved by the House and Senate. Its spokesman, Craig Palosky, reminded us that Congress posts the entire legislation online.
Of course, that's not to say the final deal is settled — or, it stands to reason, open to public view.
Palosky declined to comment precisely on Pelosi's forecast, saying her comment seemed more about politics than policy. "It’s not our role to police such comments," he said. "If you want to know what members of Congress are doing, you have to speak to members of Congress.”
His nudge led us to call U.S. Rep. Michael Burgess, R-Lewisville, among a handful of physicians in Congress and an opponent to the Democrats' proposal.
Burgess told us it's often true that the ins and outs of legislation aren't widely known until after a measure passes into law; that held true, for instance, for the Republican-steered measure providing government aid toward prescription drugs for seniors.
Pelosi's "right," Burgess said, though "I don’t think that’s a good strategy (to declare as much). I wouldn’t recommend anyone actually broadcasting that."
So how does the GOP's statement shake out?
The party's e-mail errs when it makes it sound as if Pelosi thinks the health-care measure is terrible. It's very much the opposite.
But it accurately quotes Pelosi as saying people will find out what's in the plan after it passes.
We rate the statement as Mostly True.
E-mail, Republican Party of Texas, March 12, 2010
The Heritage Foundation, The Foundry (blog), “Video of the Week: “We have to pass the bill so you can find out what is in it,” March 10, 2010
Interview, Craig Palosky, director of communications, Kaiser Family Foundation, March 15, 2010
Interview, Brendan Daly, communications director, U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, March 15, 2010
Interview, U.S. Rep. Michael Burgess, March 15, 2010
Speaker Nancy Pelosi,“Pelosi Remarks at the 2010 Legislative Conference for National Association of Counties,” March 9, 2010
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.