Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has become a popular villain for Republican candidates who have been trying to link her to their Democratic opponents.
Case in point: a recent TV ad titled "Her Congressman" from Scott Rigell, the Republican candidate for Congress in Virginia’s 2nd District, criticizing the voting record of Rep. Glenn Nye, the Democratic incumbent.
"Nye voted in lockstep with Nancy Pelosi, even on the wasteful stimulus bill," the ad says. "Nye votes with Pelosi 83 percent of the time. Glenn Nye is her congressman, not ours."
The National Republican Congressional Committee makes a similar claim in a TV ad, taking aim at Nye for supporting the economic stimulus package and other Democratic legislation. It says, "Glenn Nye voted with Pelosi 82 percent of the time."
PolitiFact has checked similar claims in other states and found they often exaggerated the correlation with Pelosi, so we decided to take a closer look.
Asked for the source for the claim, both Rigell’s campaign and the NRCC cited a Washington Post voting database.
We took a look at the database and quickly discovered the campaigns had blurred the details: Nye has voted with his party 82.5 percent of the time since he took office in 2009. But his rate of voting with Pelosi is actually significantly lower -- just 66 percent.
The Washington Post says its database shows "the percentage of votes on which a lawmaker agrees with the position taken by a majority of his or her party members" -- not the correlation with a particular party leader.
The average party loyalty is 90.6 percent for all House members and 92.2 percent for the 263 Democratic members. But contrary to the implication of the ad, Nye is actually ninth from the bottom for party loyalty among Democrats and Republicans. That indicates he has one of the most independent records.
Comparing the voting records of a member of Congress and a House speaker can be misleading because the speaker rarely votes. The Washington Post voting database shows Pelosi has voted 94 times since the start of 2009, while Nye has cast 1,551 votes.
"That is just a tradition for speakers -- they often don't vote," Pelosi spokesman Brendan Daly told PolitiFact. "She votes on some bills, not all."
Of the 91 times when they both voted on matters other than the routine roll call, Nye cast differing votes 31 times. That means they voted together 66 percent of the time.
And it’s important to note that Nye and Pelosi differed on health care reform, the signature issue for the Democrats. Nye voted against it, and has touted that vote in his campaign.
And before voting with fellow Democrats to pass the economic stimulus bill in February 2009, Nye voted twice with Republicans to delay action on the plan, saying he wanted more time and more tax cuts.
So let’s take stock of the facts.
Rigell’s ad says Nye "voted in lockstep with Nancy Pelosi." But the facts don’t support such a strong claim.
It is incorrect for Rigell to say Nye voted with Pelosi 82 percent of the time. That is the percentage for his votes with his party. The actual number with Pelosi is significantly lower -- 66 percent. And both measurements show he is one of the more independent Democrats. Only eight House members have lower party loyalty percentages.
It’s become a popular Republican tactic to link Democrats with Pelosi, but in this case, the voting records don’t justify the charge. And while Nye has voted with his party 82 percent of the time -- a clear majority of the time -- that’s a long way from being "in lock step."
So we find Rigell’s claim to be Barely True.
Editor's note: This statement was rated Barely True when it was published. On July 27, 2011, we changed the name for the rating to Mostly False.
Washington Post, House voting records for 111th Congress, Nye’s full voting record, accessed Oct. 19, 2010.
Washington Post, House voting records for 111th Congress, Nye’s votes with party, accessed Oct. 19, 2010.
Washington Post, House voting records for 111th Congress, Pelosi’s full voting record, accessed Oct. 19, 2010.
The Hill.com, "Boehner a rubber stamp for Pelosi?," Oct. 13, 2010.
Media General News Service, Perriello, Nye Side with GOP and Dems on Stimulus, Feb. 16, 2009.
Email from Brendan Daly, spokesman for House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Oct. 5, 2010.
Glenn Nye for Congress, Path TV ad, Aug. 26, 2010.
Email interview with Rigell campaign communications director Joy Weber, Oct. 19, 2010.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.