Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
On ABC's This Week on Sept. 12, 2010, Austan Goolsbee, the new chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, picked up on President Barack Obama's recent attacks on House Republican Leader John Boehner.
"I would point out that Representative Boehner has a different view and is calling for repealing the rest of the stimulus, which would raise taxes on 110 million middle class people," Goolsbee said.
That Boehner has called for a halt to stimulus spending is undisputed. The question is whether that means Boehner would put the kibosh on the Making Work Pay tax credits included in the economic stimulus package that passed in early 2009. The tax credits came to $400 for working individuals, $800 per couple, per year in 2009 and 2010. It was estimated to benefit about 110 million Americans.
We asked Boehner's spokesman Michael Steel about Goolsbee's statement.
"That is not correct," Steel wrote in an e-mail. "The savings we outline from cancelling unspent stimulus funds does not include Making Work Pay."
We can see where the confusion arose. In his public statements about stopping stimulus spending, Boehner hasn't been particularly clear on the point.
For example, in February 2010, Boehner released a statement calling on the Obama administration to start cutting spending immediately, and "that can begin by repealing spending from the stimulus." He doesn't make clear if he is leaving out the tax credits.
More recently, when David Gregory questioned Boehner in an NBC Meet the Press interview on Aug. 8, 2010, about how Republicans would offset the cost of extending all of the Bush tax cuts, as they have proposed, Boehner responded, "Why don't we stop the stimulus spending? ... Why don't we stop it. It's not working."
Making Work Tay tax credits are stimulus spending. And while they are set to expire in just a few months (the end of 2010), in theory, the government could cut them off tomorrow.
But we think Steel has credible evidence to support the claim that Boehner's call to repeal stimulus spending did not extend to Making Work Pay. His previous comments have focused entirely on the stimulus spending programs, not the tax cuts.
For example, in the Meet the Press interview, Boehner voiced support for spending cuts outlined by Republican Reps. Paul Ryan and Jeb Hensarling -- which suggested there was $266 billion in unspent stimulus that could be redirected to pay down the deficit. In a previous item, we looked into the claim that there was really that much "unspent" stimulus, and concluded there was actually much less, even if you included money from Making Work Pay that the government hasn't yet paid out.
More importantly, though, the plan from the Republican caucus of the Commitee on the Budget to "Cancel remaining 'stimulus' funds" specifically references H.R. 3140, introduced by Rep. Tom Price, R-Ga. Price's bill targets "unspent stimulus," and the legislative language makes clear that the stimulus package's tax sections -- including the Making Work Pay tax credit -- would not be impacted.
According to a section by section summary of the bill from the Republican Study Committee, Price's bill "rescinds or repeals all of the spending in the 'stimulus' excepting only the tax provisions and the unemployment benefits." Press releases issued from legislative co-sponsors of the bill also note that the tax provisions of the stimulus would not be impacted.
There are some political games being played by both sides here, of course. Republicans like Boehner want to attack the stimulus without acknowledging that it included tax relief (an idea Republicans traditionally support). And Democrats want to remind that it does. But in this case, we think Goolsbee is overreaching to make his point. Yes, Boehner and other Republicans have talked about putting a halt to all unspent stimulus -- and without being more specific, one might wonder if that includes money not yet spent on tax credits. But when you dig into the nitty-gritty of the Republicans' plan, it specifically notes that it does not include repeal of Making Work Pay. And so we rule Goolsbee's claim False.
ABC's This Week, Transcript: Goolsbee, Sept. 12, 2010
H.R. 3140, Reducing Barack Obama’s Unsustainable Deficit Act
Republican Committee on the Budget, "Cut Spending Now: Democrats' Budget Failure; Republican Solutions," May 25, 2010
Republican Study Committee, Press release: Reducing Barack Obama's Unsustainable Deficit (REBOUND)
Republican Study Committee, Section-by-section summary of H.R. 3140, the Reducing Barack Obama’s Unsustainable Deficit (REBOUND) Act.
CBS News, "Boehner Makes Demands for Debt Commission," by Jill Jackson, Feb. 5, 2010
House Republican Leader John Boehner's website, Full Text: Boehner Delivers Remarks on Jobs & The Economy in Cleveland, OH, Aug. 24, 2010
E-mail interview with Michael Steel, spokesman for Rep. Boehner, Sept. 13, 2010
E-mail interview with Conor Sweeney, spokesman for the Republicans on the House Budget Committee, Sept. 13, 2010t
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.