In an interview on Super Bowl Sunday, Fox News host Bill O'Reilly asked President Barack Obama to react to a Wall Street Journal editorial that accused Obama of being "a determined man of the left whose goal is to redistribute much larger levels of income across society."
"Do you deny that you are a man who wants to redistribute wealth?" O'Reilly asked.
Obama first noted the robust conservatism of the Wall Street Journal's editorial page, then denied the charge "absolutely."
"I didn't raise taxes once. I lowered taxes over the last two years," Obama said.
We wanted to fact-check that statement, and we'll begin by saying Obama boils down an awful lot of complexity about federal tax policy into a short sound bite.
Looking at the whole statement, he's both right and wrong. For clarity's sake, we're going to take Obama's statement in two parts. Here, we'll look at his statement, "I lowered taxes over the last two years."
In a separate report, we checked the statement, "I didn't raise taxes once" and rated it False. Obama has raised taxes on cigarettes and indoor tanning, and the health care law includes a tax penalty on the uninsured. The health care law also includes new taxes on the wealthy, increasing the rates they pay on Medicare hospital taxes starting in 2013.
For this one, we'll begin by noting that Obama has not raised income tax rates. Obama and Senate Republicans compromised on tax legislation at the end of 2010, leaving in place the same income tax rates for all tax brackets. (The extensions were necessary because the tax cuts passed under President George W. Bush would otherwise have increased last month.)
It's also true that Obama has successfully supported tax reductions for workers who make less than $200,000 a year or couples who make less than $250,000.
Obama kicked off his tax cuts for workers with the economic stimulus, formally known as the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. He asked for tax cuts of $500 per worker per year; Congress agreed to $400. The tax cuts -- called Making Work Pay -- were implemented in early 2009 and people saw small increases in their paychecks.
The Obama administration liked giving people the money in their paychecks every week or two -- as opposed to mailing one big check -- because administration economists thought people would be more likely to spend the money and stimulate the economy. But the increases were small enough that a lot of people didn't notice them. A New York Times/CBS News Poll in September showed that fewer than one in 10 people knew that the Obama administration had lowered taxes for American workers.
Those tax cuts expired at the end of 2010.
But as part of last fall's tax compromise with Republicans, Obama won a different type of tax cut for workers: a 2 percent reduction in payroll taxes that go to Social Security.
Keep in mind that normally workers pay 6.2 percent in payroll taxes on up to $106,800 of their earnings. (Employers pay another 6.2 percent, while the self-employed are generally on the hook for the full 12.4 percent.) The new tax cut means workers will pay only 4.2 percent of their earnings. So that lowered taxes for workers.
Generally speaking, people who make more than $20,000 will get an even bigger tax cut than they did under Making Work Pay. (Workers who makes less than $20,000 will likely be worse off, but they'll still be paying lower taxes than in 2008.)
The tax compromise was a complicated piece of legislation, and not everybody ended up better off. Nevertheless, about 80 percent of tax payers end up with a tax cut under the deal, according to an analysis by the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. And the broad-based tax cuts on income are significantly larger than the new excise taxes, said Roberton Williams of the Tax Policy Center.
So yes, a majority of Americans have seen reduced taxes under President Obama. But he's also taken steps to increase a few taxes like cigarettes and tanning over the past two years. Overall, we find his statement Mostly True.
The Tax Policy Center, Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization, and Job Creation Act of 2010 as Considered by the Senate Baseline: Current Policy Distribution of Federal Tax Change by Cash Income Level, 2011, Dec. 13, 2010
Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 4853, Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization, and Job Creation Act of 2010, Dec. 10, 2010
Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 1, American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, Feb. 13, 2009
U.S. Treasury Department, Tobacco: Federal Excise Tax Increase and Related Provisions, accessed Feb. 7, 2010
PolitiFact, Snooki says Obama put a 10 percent tax on tanning, June 21, 2010
PolitiFact, The Obameter: No family making less than $250,000 will see "any form of tax increase," last updated April 8, 2010
Congressional Budget Office, Selected CBO Publications Related to Health Care Legislation, 2009–2010, December 2010
PolitiFact, Health reform includes a tax penalty if you don't have insurance, Sept. 28, 2009
Interview with Roberton Williams of the Tax Policy Center, Feb. 7, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.