Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Talk-radio host and former Providence Mayor Vincent A. "Buddy" Cianci Jr. recently referred to a member of Governor Chafee’s staff as "the guy who still owes $250,000 to the state."
Cianci’s jab at Michael F. Trainor, aired on Sept. 1, 2011 on WPRO’s "The Buddy Cianci Show."
Because it wasn’t the first time that Cianci had made the comment -- and because a bankruptcy judge had "discharged" most of Trainor’s debt nearly a year ago -- we thought it was worth looking into.
Trainor has built a career in public relations representing some of the state’s high-profile politicians and corporate players. He was an advisor and spokesman for Lincoln Chafee during Chafee’s successful 2010 run for governor.
But Trainor has had his own public relations problems ever since it became known late last year that he and a business partner from Connecticut defaulted on a $250,000 federal small business loan granted through the Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation.
According to the EDC and bankruptcy court documents, here’s what happened:
The duo and two of their partners started a Rhode Island company, called Genesis Distribution & Marketing, in 2006 to distribute and market retractable window screens and hurricane shutters.
Trainor and his partners had already bought a company in Connecticut that distributed and installed hurricane shutters. And they planned to buy three more in the South that made the shutters. In January 2007, the EDC loaned the business $250,000 through the federally funded Small Business Loan Fund to buy inventory, furniture, fixtures and equipment and hire three employees.
But the business was short-lived.
Just two months after receiving the EDC loan, the partners fell behind on their payments. In 2008, the company folded.
Trainor and his partner from Connecticut, who had pledged their homes as collateral for the loan, talked with representatives from the EDC about a settlement. But the talks broke off in August 2009, when Trainor notified the agency that he was filing for bankruptcy.
By then, the housing market had tanked along with the value of Trainor’s house.
The partners had repaid $36,326 of the loan; with interest and late fees, the debt on the loan at the time totaled $250,723.
In September 2010, a bankruptcy judge granted Trainor’s petition for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
An explanation of the ruling in the bankruptcy court documents states: "The chapter 7 discharge order eliminates a debtor's legal obligation to pay a debt that is discharged.’’
The EDC loan was written off on Nov. 30, 2010. The agency concluded that it couldn’t recover any money from its lien on Trainor’s home because the mortgage balance exceeded the property’s value.
In December, 2010, Trainor, who was being considered for a job in the Chafee administration, told The Providence Journal that he had not walked away from his obligations, saying he’d like to negotiate a settlement with the EDC.
Governor Chafee discussed Trainor’s situation on Channel 12 "Newsmakers" in December 2010, saying that there would be an effort made to repay the EDC. "[We’ll] make sure Mike does that,’’ he said.
So it certainly sounded then as though Chafee and even Trainor himself believed that Trainor still owed the EDC the money.
Chafee hired Trainor as spokesman when he took office in January, a job that paid $129,235.
That month, Trainor also repaid the state $20,788.75 in taxes -- which were not dischargeable in the bankruptcy -- owed on his failed business. In return, the state Division of Taxation removed the lien on his property.
Six months later, in July, the bank sold his house at a foreclosure auction.
Trainor served seven months as Chafee’s spokesman before he was transferred, in August, to the Department of Higher Education. His salary has dropped to $88,177.
So, does he still owe the $250,000, as Cianci claims?
"That debt was discharged,’’ Andrew S. Richardson, a lawyer and the U.S. Bankruptcy Court Trustee in the Trainor case, said. "(He) can no longer be forced to pay the obligation -- nor can the creditor take any steps to try and collect it.’’
In other words, Richardson said, there’s no legal obligation that Trainor repay the loan.
But other lawyers who specialize in bankruptcy see it differently.
"Most people understand (bankruptcy) as destroying the debt … but technically the discharge in bankruptcy doesn’t destroy the debt at all,’’ Jason Kilborn, a lawyer, law professor and resident scholar at the American Bankruptcy Institute in Virginia said. "It does not destroy the obligation from a moral or even a legal obligation. It just prevents the creditors from collecting on that debt.’’
The American Bankruptcy Institute was founded in 1982 to provide Congress and the public with unbiased analysis of bankruptcy issues.
In other words, the debt remains, even though the creditors are forced to write it off as uncollectable.
So if the debt remains but Trainor isn’t obligated to repay it, does he really "owe" the state money?
We called Cianci and challenged him on his use of the term "owes." Trainor’s bankruptcy discharge, he maintained, doesn’t change the fact that Trainor still owes the EDC the $250,000.
"Maybe it was discharged,’’ he said, "but in the mind of the taxpayer who fronted the 250 grand? Yeah, he still owes it."
Said Richardson, the trustee: "I think it depends on whose point of view you’re looking at, the creditor or the debtor.’’
Practically speaking, the bankruptcy ruling and the fact that the mortgage on the Trainor’s home exceeded its value made it impossible for the EDC to recoup its money.
But even after the debt was discharged in bankruptcy Trainor and Chafee both said they’d make an effort made to repay the EDC.
After all, a debt can be owed even if it’s never collected.
For that reason, we rule Cianci’s statement Mostly True.
The Providence Journal, "Chafee advisor and partners defaulted on $250,000 EDC loan,’’ Dec. 2, 2010, accessed Sept. 2, 2011
The Providence Journal, "Chafee to retain his spokesman," Dec.30, 2010, accessed Sept. 1, 2010
The Providence Journal, "Political Scene: Governor’s staff continue to grow,’’ Sept. 5, 2011, accessed Sept. 5, 2011
Channel 12 "NewsMakers" interview with Governor Chafee, December 2010, accessed Sept. 9, 2011
E-mails,Melissa Chambers, spokeswoman for the Economic Development Corp., Sept. 2, 6, 7, 2011
Interviews,Michael F. Trainor, Sept. 6, 7, 2011
Interviews and e-mails,Christopher Lefebvre, bankruptcy lawyer, Sept. 6, 2011
Interviews, Andrew S. Richardson, lawyer and trustee for U.S Bankruptcy Court, Sept. 6, 9, 2011
Interview, Jason Kilborn, a lawyer and resident scholar at The American Bankruptcy Institute and law professor at John Marshall Law School in Chicago, Sept. 7, 2011
Interview, David Coleman, president of Coleman Realtors, Sept. 8, 2011
Interview,Vincent A. "Buddy" Cianci Jr., Sept. 8, 2011
Records, U.S. Bankruptcy Court
Land records, Barrington, R.I. Town Hall
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.