Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Set to sorrowful music, a new ad from Crossroads GPS reels off a bunch of depressing claims about the economy.
Here’s part of the script:
"It wasn’t supposed to be this way. Over three years with crushing unemployment. American manufacturing shrinking again. President (Barack) Obama’s plan: Spend more. He’s added $4 billion in debt every day. The economy is slowing but our debt keeps growing. Tell him for real job growth cut the debt."
Crossroads GPS is a conservative advocacy group; its ad has aired in Florida and other swing states.
That $4 billion in debt a day figure sounds pretty massive. We wanted to check if it was that high and if Obama is to blame.
A spokesman for Crossroads GPS pointed us to the total debt figure as of July 5 -- about a week before the ad launched -- so we will use that date as our starting point.
There are two kinds of federal debt and interest -- the debt held by the public and the total debt. About $11 trillion -- yes, trillion -- of that debt is held by the public, which includes individuals, companies and state, local and foreign governments, according to the U.S. Treasury Department. The rest, about $4.8 trillion, is held by the Federal Financing Bank, government trust funds, and other funds and accounts.
To see how fast the public debt is growing, we looked at the total on two dates.
On Jan. 20, 2009 -- the day Obama was sworn in as president -- the total debt was about $10.6 trillion and rose to about $15.9 trillion by July 5. The amount of time between those two dates was 1,262 days. That works out to about $4.16 billion a day.
We agree with the math. But is Obama solely to blame here?
We contacted a few experts on the federal budget: Jason Peuquet of the Center for a Responsible Federal Budget, a bipartisan public policy think-tank; J.D. Foster of the conservative Heritage Foundation, Gary Burtless of the centrist Brookings Institution and Joshua Gordon of the Concord Coalition which advocates reducing the debt.
No one placed the blame entirely on Obama.
The rising debt stems from several factors, including the 2009 stimulus and expansions of TARP, and the economic downturn that led to falling employment and wages and more spending on programs linked to poverty and unemployment, Peuquet said.
"Blame for the economic downturn can go toward many people, political parties, institutions, lenders, borrowers, and economic uncontrollables, etc. And it’s not just the president who was responsible for the legislative initiatives either – he had to work with Congress on those," Peuquet told PolitiFact.
Both parties share in the blame for the debt that is set to rise down the road as result of enacting expansions in entitlement programs and tax cuts, and for failing to reach an agreement on how to control rising debt.
The economic downturn explains most of the new debt and that began before Obama took office, Gordon said. The tax cuts that have lowered revenue and increased deficits over the last three years have had bipartisan support, as have nearly every spending bill over the last two years.
"So, it is impossible to attribute the debt to any single politician or party," Gordon told PolitiFact. "Furthermore, the increase in debt tells you nothing about what legislative proposals by the candidates would do in the future -- and it is the future debt growth that matters most."
Burtless said that most of the debt added under Obama would have happened even if he followed the tax and spending policies in effect when he took office. But Obama embraced policies that increased the public debt -- including signing the stimulus package and agreeing to other measures that held down taxes and increased unemployment benefits.
"However, I believe the overwhelming share of extra public debt accumulated since Jan. 2009 would also have been accumulated even if none of those new policies had been proposed or adopted," Burtless said. "The reason is straightforward. The Bush administration was committed to a certain level of spending (for defense, non-defense discretionary, and mandatory non-defense programs) and to a particular schedule of income and payroll taxes. Those policies, if maintained by President Obama, would have produced sizeable annual deficits – deficits nearly as large as the ones we actually saw."
But Obama is not off the hook here.
"Was not deficit spending the core feature of his economic stimulus plan? Has he objected to it in any way? Has he proposed changes in fiscal policy that would have materially altered the course? Each answer is obvious, and each leads to the same conclusion -- it is perfectly fair to argue that Obama is responsible for this debt increase," Foster told PolitiFact. "Did he sign every bill that produced the debt? Of course not. But is it entirely consistent with his policy."
Crossroads GPS has its math correct what it says that Obama has "added $4 billion in debt every day." But the ad suggests that Obama is solely to blame. That’s not true, because other factors -- including the struggling economy he inherited and decisions made before he took office -- contributed to that debt. We rate this claim Half True.
YouTube, Crossroads GPS "Tried" Ad, July 12, 2012
PolitiFact, "Senators ring alarm about ‘$4 billion’ daily debt," April 11, 2011
PolitiFact, "Vern Buchanan estimates debt growth during marathon Wimbledon match,"June 24, 2010
PolitiFact, "Sen. Warner estimates national debt grew $15 billion over weekend,"Dec. 9, 2010
PolitiFact,"Rick Perry says national debt, Obama’s refusal to control spending led to credit rating downgrade," Aug. 30, 2011
PolitiFact, "U.S. Rep. Leonard Lance says government debt has grown by $3.4 trillion during the first 29 months of the Obama administration,"July 28, 2011
PolitiFact, "Jim Renacci says Obama has racked up more debt than any other president," June 27, 2012
Crossroads GPS press release, "Crossroads GPS launches new TV issue ad on jobs and debt,"July 12, 2012
TreasuryDirect, The Daily History of Debt Results, Jan. 20, 2009 through July 30, 2012
Converterunits.com, Number of daysbetween Jan. 20, 2009 and July 5, 2012
Interview, J.D. Foster, Senior Fellow in the Economics of Fiscal Policy at The Heritage Foundation, Aug. 2, 2012
Interview, Jason Peuquet, Research Director, Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, Aug. 2, 2012
Interview, Gary Burtless, senior fellow of economic studies at Brookings Institution, Aug. 2, 2012
Interview, Joshua Gordon, policy director for the Concord Coalition, Aug. 2, 2012
Interview, Nate Hodson, spokesman for Crossroads GPS, Aug. 2, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.