Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Republicans moved quickly to politicize what federal agents have described as a failed bomb plot cooked up by anarchists connected to the Occupy Cleveland organization.
The group, an offshoot of last fall’s anti-Wall Street demonstrations in New York, is not under investigation, officials stressed May 1, 2012, when announcing the arrests of five suspects.
But that did little to stop the GOP from buzzing about the movement’s support among Democrats.
The most direct attack came May 2, 2012, from the National Republican Congressional Committee. The group is working to unseat Rep. Betty Sutton, a Democrat from Copley Township near Akron. Redistricting put her into battle this fall against fellow Rep. Jim Renacci of Wadsworth.
In an email, the NRCC blasted Sutton for not immediately denouncing the accused anarchists and noted that the congresswoman attended an Occupy rally last October in New York.
The email, sent by NRCC Deputy Communications Director Andrea Bozek, accuses Sutton of missing votes to protest with Occupy Wall Street and being slow to criticize the "plot by Occupy members to blow up an Ohio bridge."
Bozek then delivered the punchy email’s parting shot.
"Sutton’s cowardly silence shows she would rather riot with Occupy than stand up for Ohio families."
When it comes to Occupy, it’s no secret Sutton has been a supporter. But a rioter?
PolitiFact Ohio decided to check that accusation.
Bozek provided a link to a story that was published last October in The Plain Dealer and online at Cleveland.com. The story reported on Sutton’s travel to the Occupy rally in New York.
Bozek also shared an NRCC video montage of Occupy protesters preaching communism and engaging in other unruly behavior. An oft-used image of a man defecating on a police car makes a cameo. The video targets another congressional Democrat, Steve Israel of New York.
Asked if any of the clips came from the event Sutton attended, Bozek replied: "That video demonstrates the kind of behavior that defines this radical group. Multiple arrests, sexual assaults, attacks on police officers and … vandalism. Is that what Betty Sutton supports?"
"The congresswoman does not ever condone or participate in riotous behavior," said Sutton spokesman Anthony DeAngelo.
The New York rally last fall is the only Occupy event Sutton has attended, DeAngelo told PolitiFact Ohio. We checked news reports from that day and found little to support the NRCC’s attack.
Yes, there were violent outbursts -- an element necessary to meet nearly any modern definition of riot. The New York Times City Room blog reported that 23 people were arrested during the Oct. 5 protests, including one charged with second-degree riot -- a misdemeanor.
According to New York penal code, rioting in the second degree occurs when someone in a group of at least four "engages in tumultuous and violent conduct," risking "public alarm."
But we suspect the New York Times would have noted an Ohio congresswoman among the group had Sutton been involved. But the newspaper didn’t because Sutton wasn’t. DeAngelo offered a few photos of his boss at the rally. Sutton appears more dressed up than her fellow demonstrators, and her dark coat and purple blouse look no worse for the wear.
Most coverage of the Oct. 5 protests indicated that violent behavior was the exception. That evening, on CNN’s broadcast of "Situation Room," reporter Susan Candiotti agreed with host Wolf Blitzer that the protests had been peaceful and that "there have been no confrontations."
The NRCC is correct that Sutton missed votes to attend the rally last October. It is also accurate to say that Sutton did not send out a formal condemnation of the five bomb plot suspects, though, in fairness, neither did Renacci until after the NRCC attack.
But the rhetorical flourish is where the NRCC’s claim departs from truthfulness. The NRCC email said that Sutton’s "cowardly silence shows she would rather riot with Occupy than stand up for Ohio families."
Did Sutton stand with the Occupy Wall Street protesters in October? Yes.
Did she engage in rioting? No.
Was there even rioting at the rally Sutton attended? News coverage indicates violent behavior was the exception and that protests at the event were generally peaceful. Meanwhile, the material provided by the NRCC fails to support the notion that Sutton would support rioting.
The NRCC claim is beyond False. On the Truth-O-Meter, the claim rates Pants on Fire.
Third Base Politics blog, "Ted Strickland also parroted the Occupy Wall Street nonsense" and "Occupy movement that Sherrod Brown praises tried to blow up NE Ohio bridge," May 2, 2012
Email from Andrea Bozek of the National Republican Congressional Committee, titled "Why hasn’t Betty Sutton condemned Occupy Cleveland," sent May 2, 2012
Additional email exchanges with Bozek, May 2-3, 2012
The Plain Dealer via Cleveland.com, "Rep. Betty Sutton to join Occupy Wall Street labor march in New York," Oct. 5, 2012
NRCC web video, "Steve Israel Stands with Occupy Wall Street," via YouTube, Oct. 18, 2011
Telephone interviews with Sutton spokesman Anthony DeAngelo, May 3, 2012;
The New York Times City Room blog, "23 Arrested Wednesday in Wall St. Protest," Oct. 6, 2011
New York State Unified Court System, penal law 240.05
Transcript of CNN’s "Situation Room," Oct. 5, 2011, accessed via Lexis-Nexis
Emailed photos of Sutton at Oct. 5, 2011 rally, sent by staffer Anthony DeAngelo, May 3, 2012
U.S. House of Representatives, roll call votes, 112th Congress, 1st Session, October 2011
The Plain Dealer via Cleveland.com, "Republicans try to tie Rep. Betty Sutton to Ohio’s attempted bridge bombers," May 2, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.