Get PolitiFact in your inbox.

Katie Sanders
By Katie Sanders October 30, 2012

Bill Young says he opposed $716 billion Medicare cut

U.S. Rep. C.W. Bill Young, the Indian Shores Republican incumbent of 42 years, touts his credibility with seniors in a TV spot clearly aimed at the 65-plus crowd.

An ensemble of older men and women, and even former Gov. Jeb Bush, praise Young for being there for seniors.

"Florida seniors couldn’t have a bigger champion than Congressman Bill Young," Bush says.

Amid the endorsements are claims about Young’s record on Social Security, the Medicare prescription drug program, support for a balanced budget amendment, and, of course, Medicare.

"Young opposed $716-billion cut to Medicare," bold text shows.

Below that text is a citation: "House Roll Call Vote 165 - 3/21/2010."

It’s the House vote on the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, which Young voted against. Does that mean he rejected "the $716 billion cut to Medicare?"

We also checked a dueling Medicare claim from his challenger, Democratic lawyer Jessica Ehrlich, over whether he voted for the Ryan budgets that "end the current Medicare system."

The $716 billion cut

You could say we’ve heard this line a time or two.

This attack line is a viral one in the political world, used by Mitt Romney against President Barack Obama, Rep. Connie Mack against Sen. Bill Nelson, and in many, many, many other races across the country.

It’s not a "cut" in the traditional sense. Medicare is an open-ended entitlement program with a growth problem that threatens its future viability. Both parties agree changes should be made.

Obama did not propose a cut to Medicare’s budget in his health care law. Rather, the law made several changes to slow the growth of Medicare costs. These changes primarily affected insurance companies and hospitals -- not beneficiaries.

The government, for example, will pay hospitals less if they have too many readmissions or fail to meet new benchmarks for care. The law also deals with Medicare Advantage, which is a subset of Medicare plans run by private insurers started under President George W. Bush with the goal of reducing costs through marketplace competition. The plans have actually proven more expensive than traditional Medicare in recent years, so the health care law aims to reduce payments to private insurers as a way to rein in costs.

The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office determined in 2011 that the federal health care law would reduce Medicare outlays by $507 billion between 2012 and 2021. In a more recent estimate released this year, the CBO looked at the years 2013 to 2022 and determined the health care law affected Medicare outlays by $716 billion.

It’s worth pointing out Young could not have known he was specifically voting against $716 billion in Medicare "cuts," as that had not been tabulated in time for the health care vote that happened two years earlier.

Still, it was known at the bill’s passage that there were major reductions in store for Medicare service providers, said economist Gail Wilensky, senior fellow at the international health foundation Project HOPE and Medicare director under President George H.W. Bush.

A tricky point for Young’s claim is that he also voted for the budget blueprint of Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis. -- twice, actually. The budget is a congressional resolution that does not carry the force of law, and Ryan’s ideas have not been turned into detailed legislation.

Even so, Ryan has said his most recent budget factors in the same $716 billion in reductions in Medicare spending.

Obama campaign spokeswoman Stephanie Cutter made this point on Face the Nation in August, saying Ryan "protected those cuts in his budget." PolitiFact rated her statement True.

The Romney campaign responded to Cutter’s remark with a statement that Romney intended to repeal the health care law and end the Medicare "raid." Ryan said he factored the $716 billion savings in his budget it "was already in the baseline," the Wall Street Journal reported. "We would never have done it in the first place." However, his budget assumed reversal of other Obama spending decisions, the Journal pointed out.

A month later, former President Bill Clinton reprised the attack in his Democratic National Convention speech, quipping, "it takes some brass to attack a guy for doing what you did." We rated it True.

Ehrlich’s position

Ehrlich is in an interesting spot here. She, too, opposes this "cut."

Even though she supports the health care law, she told the Tampa Bay Times, "I am against the $500 billion cuts to Medicare in both the Affordable Care Act and the Ryan budget. I also oppose the Independent Panel Advisory Board in the Affordable Care Act and would support legislation to overturn that provision."

She has attacked Young for voting for the Ryan budgets that reshape how Medicare works.

When we asked her to elaborate on her position in an interview, she said she wanted to keep Medicare "fully funded."

"I think we have to maintain the integrity of the program, make sure that it’s fully funded, and not advocate for cutting until we look at the budget as a whole," she said.

She did not provide specifics for reducing the program’s spending.

Young said she could not have had it both ways if she were a member of Congress at the time of the vote.

"If you voted for the bill, you voted for the Medicare cut," he said.

Our ruling

Young’s ad says he voted against the controversial $716 billion Medicare cut.

What he voted against was the Affordable Care Act, which implements an estimated $716 billion reduction in payments to hospitals and private insurers in effort to reduce the program’s ever-increasing costs. He could not have known the amount would be $716 billion, as that estimate came two years after the health care vote. Meanwhile, the Republicans have their own plan for reducing future Medicare spending, by bring more private insurance companies into Medicare and offering voucher-like premium support.

The claim excludes several points. We rate it Half True.

Our Sources

Tampa Bay Times, "Jeb Bush appears in new ad for Bill Young," Oct. 17, 2012

Tampa Bay Times, Candidate guide for U.S. House District 13,  Oct. 17, 2012

Interview with Harry Glenn, Bill Young spokesman, Oct. 23, 2012

Interview with Kiel Brunner, Jessica Ehrlich spokesman, Oct. 26, 2012

Interview with Jessica Ehrlich, Oct. 29, 2012

Interview with Gail Wilensky, senior fellow at the international health foundation Project HOPE and Medicare director under President George H.W. Bush, Oct. 30, 2012

PolitiFact, "Clinton said Ryan attacked Obama for Medicare cuts reflected in his own budget,"

Congressional Budget Office,Letter to the Honorable John Boehner providing an estimate for H.R. 6079, the Repeal of Obamacare Act, July 24, 2012
Congressional Budget Office,CBO's Analysis of the Major Health Care Legislation Enacted in March 2010, March 30, 2011
Congressional Budget Office,H.R. 2, Repealing the Job-Killing Health Care Law Act, February 18, 2011
Congressional Budget Office,The Long-Term Budgetary Impact of Paths for Federal Revenues and Spending Specified by Chairman Ryan, March 20, 2012
PolitiFact, "Medicare 'cuts' in the health care law will hurt seniors, says 60 Plus Association," Sept. 20, 2010
The Kaiser Family Foundation,Health Reform and Medicare: Overview of Key Provisions, July 2010

PolitiFact, "$500 billion from Medicare for Obamacare, Mitt Romney says," June 16, 2011

PolitiFact, "Ryan’s Medicare plan includes $700 billion "cuts," says Stephanie Cutter," Aug. 15, 2012

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Katie Sanders

Bill Young says he opposed $716 billion Medicare cut

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up