Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
"If you don’t believe me that Medicaid is broken, just ask our president," Texas Gov. Rick Perry told the Conservative Political Action Conference on March 14, 2013.
"Four years ago, he said, and I quote, ‘We can't simply put more people into a broken system that doesn't work,’ end quote."
In Perry’s speech at the American Conservative Union’s annual gathering of activists, he described Medicaid as "on its way to bankruptcy" and vowed he wouldn’t join other Republican governors who had gotten on board with Obamacare’s expansion of the state-federal program, which insures low-income Americans.
But did President Barack Obama say it was "broken"?
An Internet search will quickly enough direct the curious reader to Obama’s remark, made June 2, 2009, at the White House before a health-care discussion with Senate Democrats. Between the quotation marks Perry indicated, he captured Obama’s words; here we present them with more context:
As we move forward on health care reform, it is not sufficient for us simply to add more people to Medicare or Medicaid to increase the rolls, to increase coverage in the absence of cost controls and reform. And let me repeat this principle: If we don't get control over costs, then it is going to be very difficult for us to expand coverage. These two things have to go hand in hand. Another way of putting it is we can't simply put more people into a broken system that doesn't work.
So we've got to reform the underlying system. And this means promoting best practices, not just the most expensive practices.
Perry spokesman Josh Havens confirmed by email that the governor was referring to this Obama speech, and pointed out a precedent in Obama’s 2006 book, "The Audacity of Hope":
As initially passed in 2010, Obamacare would have required states to expand Medicaid by opening the program to all households with income below 138 percent of the federal poverty level — which in 2013 is $15,865 for an individual, $32,499 for a family of four. A June 2012 Supreme Court decision gave states the choice to opt in or opt out of expanding their Medicaid rolls, which is the decision Texas currently faces.
But much more was at stake in mid-2009. Obama’s health-care overhaul would not pass the Senate until Dec. 24, 2009; the House passed it March 21, 2010.
A CNN timeline shows Obama had told Congress in February 2009 that health care reform would not wait another year and held a White House summit on health care in March 2009.
In June 2009, Obama launched what news stories in the Washington Post, New York Times and other papers described as a full-on push to get comprehensive health care legislation drafted and passed.
In each, Obama called the health-care system "broken" and specified that rising health care costs were the problem, citing Medicaid as a factor in the letter but not in the speech.
Obama’s letter said, "Soaring health care costs make our current course unsustainable" and "the ever-increasing cost of Medicare and Medicaid are among the main drivers of enormous budget deficits." In the radio address, he did not name Medicaid or Medicare but said, "We will seize this historic opportunity to finally fix what ails our broken health-care system" by attacking "the root causes of skyrocketing health care costs."
White House spokeswoman Joanna Rosholm declined to comment on Perry’s claim.
We asked Havens for his thoughts on Obama’s references to the health-care system (not just Medicaid) as broken. Havens replied by email: "No matter how you want to look at it, the president specifically referred to Medicaid when he was talking about a broken system that doesn’t work."
Perry said that Obama called Medicaid "broken." In context, it’s clear the president was including Medicaid as a significant part of the entire health care system and that his larger point was that health care costs need to be reined in. Still, Obama described expanding the Medicare and Medicaid rolls as putting "more people in a broken system."
We rate the governor’s statement as Mostly True.
Texas Gov. Rick Perry, speech at Conservative Political Action Conference, Washington, D.C., March 14, 2013
President Barack Obama, "Remarks by the president before meeting with Senate Democrats to discuss health care," White House State Dining Room, June 2, 2009
Email interviews, excerpted, with Josh Havens, spokesman for Gov. Rick Perry, April 2-8, 2013
President Barack Obama, "The Audacity of Hope," chapter 5, book published 2006
CNN.com news story, "Timeline of the health care law," June 17, 2012
Washington Post news story, "Fix Health System, President Urges," June 7, 2009
The New York Times news story, "Obama to Forge a Greater Role on Health Care," June 6, 2009
The New York Times news story, "Obama Urges Effort on Health Care," June 7, 2009
Boston Globe news story, "Obama lays out health overhaul; Open to requiring coverage for all," June 4, 2009
San Francisco Chronicle news story, "Efficient system could save U.S. billions, Obama economist says," June 3, 2009
President Barack Obama, letter to U.S. Sens. Ted Kennedy and Max Baucus, June 2, 2009
President Barack Obama, weekly radio/Internet address, June 5, 2009
Telephone interview with Joanna Rosholm, White House spokeswoman, April 9, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.