Grumbling about the salaries and benefits of public employees is a longtime favorite sport of political observers.
That was certainly the case following the recent appointment of Melody Rose as interim chancellor of the state’s seven public universities. Rose, who previously served as vice chancellor, replaced George Pernsteiner, who announced his resignation in January.
Rose faces many challenges as the state revamps its higher education system, and she will apparently be compensated well for her work — too well, according to Keizer resident Gene H. McIntyre.
In a Feb. 22 guest opinion column for the Keizertimes, McIntyre wrote that "We will pay (Rose) a basic salary of nearly $300,000 a year, and that’s to start, an amount that does not include the costs of this public employee’s benefits, perks and living expenses for a lavish house, an upscale car, a spending allowance, and fine dining almost every day on the taxpayer dollar."
That got our mouths watering and our minds wondering. Fine dining practically every day? A lavish house and upscale car? (Perhaps journalism was not our true calling?)
We obtained a copy of Rose’s employment agreement, which shows that she earns an annual base salary of $260,004.
Rose receives $14,424 in annual medical benefits, the same as other employees in the Chancellor’s Office, according to Di Saunders, spokeswoman for the Oregon University System.
Rose is not enrolled in the Public Employees Retirement System. Instead, she chose the Optional Retirement Plan, a defined contribution plan created in 1996 for unclassified academic and administrative employees. The university system contributes the maximum $51,000 toward her retirement every year.
Rose also receives a $12,000 annual car allowance for her to drive to various campuses and meetings. She does not receive mileage reimbursements.
Then there’s the annual $20,694 she receives "for professional development and expenses," according to her contract. The money is paid to Rose like salary and is considered taxable income, Saunders said.
The money is intended to cover membership dues for civic clubs, conference fees, and "appropriate and necessary expenses that might not be eligible for expense reimbursement under OUS policy," Saunders wrote in an e-mail.
"Let’s say there’s somebody coming to speak at a conference, and they take them out to dinner," Saunders said. "It’s things that you wouldn’t want to use your general fund budget for, but they’re expenses a chancellor should take care of."
Rose is not required to submit receipts for those expenses, so she could theoretically use all of that money at upscale restaurants. If she spent $100 on each fine-dining meal, she could treat herself to about 207 fancy meals.
Now about that "lavish house." The chancellor is offered Treetops, a mansion adjacent to the University of Oregon in Eugene. The 8,000-square-foot mansion, built in 1911, was the official home of Pernsteiner, who split his time between Eugene and Portland.
Rose declined to move to Treetops and lives in Portland with her family, Saunders said.
All told, Rose receives $358,122 annually in salary, benefits and expenses. She’s also entitled to the usual reimbursements for work-related expenses and travel.
Is Rose’s compensation out of line? Saunders directed us to a 2011 chart on the website of The Chronicle of Higher Education that shows median salaries— not including benefits — of senior college administrators. Administrators at Rose’s level have an overall median salary of $322,700.
McIntyre based his column on information he had gathered through his years working in education and state government, he said in a phone interview from his Keizer home. McIntyre says he’s a retired language arts and social sciences teacher who served about a decade on the now-defunct Oregon Educational Coordinating Commission, which oversaw the distribution of federal education money.
"I know people can live very, very well on a lot less money than we’re paying these people," he said. "We have a lot of social problems — a lot of kids are going hungry, a lot of folks have lost their homes — and yet, we continue to pay some of these people just what I’d consider excessive amounts of money."
But is it true that Rose receives "a basic salary of nearly $300,000 a year" and "benefits, perks and living expenses for a lavish house, an upscale car, a spending allowance and fine dining almost every day on the taxpayer dollar" as McIntyre wrote in his column?
Rose earns $260,004 in base salary -- not quite the $300,000 McIntyre cites. It’s accurate to say her base salary does not include the $65,424 she gets in medical and retirement benefits.
McIntyre’s description of Rose’s other perks is partially true: Rose receives a car allowance and an expense account, but she does not live in Treetops and likely isn’t treating herself to fine dining almost every day.
We rate this statement Half True.
Gene H. McIntyre column, Keizertimes, Feb. 22, 2013
Interview with Gene McIntyre, March 6, 2013
Interview with and e-mails from Di Saunders, spokeswoman, Oregon University System, March 6-7, 2013
The Chronicle of Higher Education, Median Salaries of Senior College Administrators by Job Category and Type of Institution, 2010-11, Feb. 21, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.