Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Conventional wisdom holds that there is a 4-3 conservative majority among the seven justices on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.
That would indicate the balance of power is at stake in the April 2, 2013, election.
Justice Patience Roggensack, who is seeking a second 10-year term, is considered to be one of the conservatives on the high court. She faces Marquette University law professor Edward Fallone, who is supported by labor unions and Democratic elected officials.
The race is officially nonpartisan.
Roggensack has resisted the conservative label and contends her support comes from both sides of the political aisle. In particular, she has emphasized her endorsements from Wisconsin sheriffs.
In a candidates forum on March 26, 2013, in Madison, Roggensack said:
"I run nonpartisan. But (in) this race, I have tried very hard to have bipartisan support. I'm supported by 53 sheriffs throughout the state, Democrats and Republicans; district attorneys throughout the state, again, Democrats and Republicans. I have strong law enforcement support. The Wisconsin Professional Police Association has just endorsed me; again, Democrats and Republicans."
Roggensack made a similar statement several days earlier in an interview and has issued several news releases touting the endorsement from sheriffs.
Given Roggensack’s reputation as a conservative, one would expect she has strong support from Republican sheriffs. But for her claim of bipartisan backing to be true, she’d also need to show significant support from Democratic sheriffs.
Let’s see what there is.
Roggensack lists the 53 sheriffs who have endorsed her on her campaign website. We ran our own check of the list, given that it doesn’t include party affiliations. We also consulted the 2011-2012 Wisconsin Blue Book.
We did tallies in two ways:
-- Of the 53 sheriffs listed as having endorsed Roggensack, 42 are Republican and 11 are Democrats. That’s a 79 percent to 21 percent Republican-Democrat split.
The Republican sheriffs include Dan Trawicki of Waukesha County, Maury Straub of Ozaukee County and Dale Schmidt of Washington County.
The Democratic sheriffs include David A. Clarke Jr. of Milwaukee County, Sam Wollin of Adams County and David Kaminski of Rusk County, who is president of the Badger State Sheriffs’ Association.
-- The 11 Democrats backing Roggensack make up 42 percent of the 26 sheriffs statewide who are Democrats, according to the Blue Book.
Clarke is a conservative and frequent critic of policies favored by Democrats, but runs as a Democrat in a county that leans heavily in that direction.
Fallone, meanwhile, lists two sheriffs among the officials who have endorsed him: Dave Mahoney of Dane County and Bob Spoden of Rock County. Both are Democrats.
Roggensack said she has bipartisan support, including "53 sheriffs throughout the state, Democrats and Republicans."
As expected, Roggensack has plenty of support from GOP sheriffs, but she has significant backing from Democratic sheriffs, as well. A little more than one-fifth of the sheriffs backing her are Democrats and those Democrats make up more than 40 percent of all the Democratic sheriffs in the state.
We rate Roggensack’s statement True.
WisconsinEye, video (quote at 13:15) of candidates debate, March 26, 2013
Wausau Daily Herald, video of Pat Roggensack interview (quote at 44:00), March 22, 2013
Pat Roggensack campaign, news release on nine sheriff endorsements, Jan. 9, 2013
Pat Roggensack campaign, news release on 17 sheriff endorsements, Jan. 7, 2013
Pat Roggensack campaign, endorsements
2011-2012 Wisconsin Blue Book
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.