A week after the mid-term elections, in which the GOP gained considerable ground in Congress, U.S. Rep. Gwen Moore was asked if Americans had rejected President Barack Obama’s policies.
The Milwaukee Democrat responded, in part, by saying Republicans had take many steps to "discredit" Obama, including voting more than 50 times to repeal his Affordable Care Act.
"But the reality," Moore stated Nov. 11, 2014 on Wisconsin Public Radio, "is that Obamacare has lowered health care costs by $36 billion just this year. We've had the lowest health care inflation in history because of Obamacare."
The bolder claim about Obamacare -- that health care inflation in the United States is the lowest ever because of the law -- is one we want to check.
Inflation vs. spending
Health care inflation and health care spending are sometimes used interchangeably, but they are different. Inflation refers to health care prices from one year to the next, while spending is, well, how much is spent on health care.
It turns out that growth in both health care inflation and expenditures are at historic lows, at least dating back to when the federal government began tracking them in 1960.
Moore’s office cited data from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis that shows health care inflation, as of the end of 2013, at about 1 percent per year -- the lowest since the early 1960s.
Some economists prefer to consider actual health care expenditures, since that goes to how much health care is being used and how much is being paid for it.
The latest estimates from the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services put health care spending at $2.8 trillion, or $8,915 per person, in 2012. That marked the fourth straight year, dating back to 2009, that the annual increase was less than 4 percent. Again, those are historic lows dating back to 1960.
(A few weeks after Moore made her claim, the 2013 figure was released, showing health expenditures rose 3.6 percent, the lowest annual increase since 1960.)
So, Moore is on the right track in terms of the figures.
But the thrust of her claim is that the inflation slowdown is due to Obamacare.
Moore spokesman Eric Harris argued that Moore didn’t claim Obamacare is the sole cause of the slowdown in health care prices, although she believes it is an important one.
But Moore made her statement while defending the law and clearly gave it singular credit for the smaller increases in medical inflation.
There is not widespread agreement that the Affordable Care Act is the key factor in limiting medical inflation. The inflation rates are lowest since the law took effect in March 2010, though they were trending downward several years earlier and the law has been rolled out only in stages.
Even the president’s Council of Economic Advisers, in a November 2013 report, said "the causes of the slowdown are not yet fully understood" -- although it gave some credit to Obamacare, including the law’s reduction in Medicare payments to health care providers.
And the council’s chairman wrote in the Wall Street Journal that "many factors, including the recession and one-time developments like blockbuster drugs coming off patent, have contributed to the slowdown," but that Obamacare "has made a meaningful contribution."
We sought out some economists, as well.
Harvard University’s David Cutler, who served as the senior health care adviser to Obama’s 2008 campaign, told us "nobody has the complete answer" for the smaller increases in health care inflation but that Obamacare is "important."
Others downplayed the role of the health care reform law.
Charles Roehrig, director of the Center for Sustainable Health Spending at the nonprofit Altarum Institute, noted that Obamacare’s main aim is to expand health insurance coverage, not reduce prices. It is a factor in healthcare inflation, but the smaller increases in health prices are "mainly explained by slower overall price inflation," he said.
And like other economists, Gail Wilensky, who ran Medicare and Medicaid under President George H.W. Bush, told us much of the slowing in medical-price inflation is simply due to the "unusually slow recovery from the recession." The Affordable Act, she said, has had perhaps a "small effect."
Finally, the Washington Post Fact Checker arrived at a similar conclusion in rating a November 2014 claim by Obama that health care inflation "has gone down every single year" since the Affordable Care Act passed. The president, though he wasn’t as bold as Moore, was given "three pinocchios" for a statement that has "significant factual error and/or obvious contradictions."
"There are certainly some cost-controls contained in the law, but it remains unclear whether those measures have really had that much impact, especially because the Great Recession clearly had affected health-care inflation even before the law was implemented," The Fact Checker wrote. "Just as growth in health-care costs have slowed because the 2009 economic crisis, so has economic growth and general price inflation overall."
Moore said: "We've had the lowest health care inflation in history because of Obamacare."
There’s an element of truth in her claim, given that the Affordable Care Act is given some credit for the smallest increases in health care inflation on record.
But Moore’s claim gave virtually all the credit to Obamacare, when there isn’t evidence it played that large of a role.
We rate Moore’s statement Mostly False.
Wisconsin Public Radio, Joy Cardin Show interview of U.S. Rep. Gwen Moore (quotes at 5:50, 18:30), Nov. 11, 2014
Interview and email interview, U.S. Rep. Gwen Moore spokesman Eric Harris, Dec. 1, 2014
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, National Health Expenditure Accounts, Jan. 7, 2014
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, National Health Expenditures, selected calendar years 1960 to 2012
Council of Economic Advisers, "Trends in health care cost growth and the role of the Affordable Care Act," November 2013
Interview, Altarum Institute Center for Sustainable Health Spending director Charles Roehrig, Dec. 2, 2014
Interview, Harvard University applied economics professor David Cutler, Dec. 2, 2014
Interview, economist and Project HOPE senior fellow Gail Wilensky, Dec. 2, 2014
Health Affairs, "National health spending in 2012: Rate of health spending growth remained low for the fourth consecutive year," January 2014
The White House, "Recent Trends in Health Care Costs, Their Impact on the Economy, and the Role of the Affordable Care Act," (Figure 4-2) accessed Dec. 2, 2014
PunditFact, "Ed Schultz: Obamacare is driving costs down (Mostly False)," March 28, 2014
Wall Street Journal, "Medical-Price Inflation Is at Slowest Pace in 50 Years," Sep. 17, 2013
Wall Street Journal, "Jason Furman: Obamacare is slowing health inflation," Jan. 6, 2014
Kaiser Family Foundation, "Assessing the effects of the economy on the recent slowdown in health spending," April 22, 2013
Kaiser Health News, "Growth in U.S. health spending in 2013 is lowest since 1960," Dec. 3, 2014
Washington Post Fact Checker, "Obama’s claim that has reduced health-care inflation ‘every single year’ since it was passed," Nov. 6, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.