Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
The exchange of kidnapped Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl for five high-risk Taliban detainees from Guantanamo Bay has elicited criticism of the Obama administration.
Politicians and lawmakers have taken issue with the administration’s action on several grounds, including President Barack Obama’s decision to ignore a law requiring advance congressional notification and the questions surrounding Bergdahl’s original disappearance.
But Charles Krauthammer, a conservative columnist and Fox News contributor, has come out supporting Obama’s decision to make the swap, despite concerns that Obama made Bergdahl’s release a highly public "cause for celebration."
"We have long engaged -- and all other countries in the West have long engaged -- in hostage swaps where the West always comes out on the short end," said Krauthammer to Fox News host Bret Baier. "And the reason is that we put a value on an individual human life the way that the barbarians at the other end of the table don't."
To demonstrate that other western countries have been on the short end of such swaps, Krauthammer cited an Israeli hostage exchange from 2011.
"The best example is the Israelis, who gave up 1,000 terrorists in return for one sergeant," Krauthammer said.
We decided to see whether Krauthammer’s claim was accurate. We found that it was.
In 2006, the Islamic terrorist organization Hamas captured Israeli Sgt. Gilad Shalit after tunneling into Israel and attacking an army outpost.
Israel’s first attempt to free Shalit, by launching a military invasion into Hamas-controlled Gaza, failed.
Shalit was held captive for five years. During that time, many Israelis pleaded with their government to strike a deal for Shalit’s return. Israel had already failed to secure the freedom of Air Force Navigator Ron Arad, who had crashed his warplane in Lebanon 25 years before his death in 2008 while in the control of Shiite captors. Many Israelis worried that Shalit’s capture would end the same way.
But it didn’t.
Shalit returned home on Oct. 18, 2011, following Israel’s freeing of 1,027 Palestinian prisoners.
It's not clear that all 1,027 were "terrorists," but some were indeed terrorists serving several life sentences for killing Israeli citizens. (In addition, the definition of "terrorist" varies quite a lot depending on who is using the term.)
One Israeli minister who voted against the exchange called it "a great victory for terrorism." That fear has been echoed in the wake of the Bergdahl exchange.
Krauthammer took issue with such claims in an op-ed in the Washington Post.
"The (Obama) administration might have tried honesty here and said: Yes, we gave away five important combatants. But that’s what you do to redeem hostages," Krauthammer wrote.
As for what to do with Bergdahl, Krauthammer concludes that the right course is, "Free him, then try him."
Krauthammer said Israel "gave up 1000 terrorists in return for one sergeant." In 2011, Israel freed 1,027 Palestinian prisoners in exchange for Sgt. Gilad Shalit, who had been held captive by Hamas since 2006. While we can't confirm that all 1,027 were terrorists, some definitely were, and the definition of "terrorist" is often fuzzy. We rate this statement True.
Huffington Post, "Charles Krauthammer Supports Bergdahl Swap," June 5, 2014
CNN, "Why Israelis believe one soldier is worth 1,000 Palestinian prisoners," Oct. 18, 2011
Politico, "Five Questions for the White House on Bowe Bergdahl," June 3, 2014
Washington Post, "Free him, Then Try Him," June 5, 2014
PolitiFact, "What's the definition of 'terrorism'?" July 9, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.