Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.

Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.

More Info

I would like to contribute

A small white camera on a Cobb County School bus can capture video of violators who pass a stopped bus. Photo by Phil Skinner / AJC A small white camera on a Cobb County School bus can capture video of violators who pass a stopped bus. Photo by Phil Skinner / AJC

A small white camera on a Cobb County School bus can capture video of violators who pass a stopped bus. Photo by Phil Skinner / AJC

Nancy Badertscher
By Nancy Badertscher November 11, 2014
April Hunt
By April Hunt November 11, 2014

Gwinnett spokeswoman on target with claim about school bus deaths

About two dozen Georgia school systems have added cameras to their school buses since 2011.

The cameras have one purpose: catching motorists who break a state law that requires them to stop for school buses that are picking up and dropping off students.

Gwinnett County, the state’s largest school district, will be issuing warnings soon — and tickets after the Christmas break — to violators caught by its cameras.

"Prior to the law being passed that allowed for the use of cameras to enforce the law that addresses those who illegally pass a school bus, Georgia led the nation in student fatalities resulting from motorists illegally passing stopped school buses," Sloan Roach, the executive director of communications and media relations for Gwinnett County Public Schools, told reporters Nov. 6.

That’s a grim statistic. PolitiFact Georgia decided to take a closer look.

Georgia law allows police officers who witness motorists passing a stopped bus to issue a $1,000 moving violation misdemeanor.

But after 5-year-old Karla Campos was killed when a driver sped past her stopped school bus in Cobb County in 2009, parents lobbied lawmakers to allow video cameras to catch violators.

Their case was bolstered by a report that Campos was one of five Georgia children to die that year in bus-related accidents. That accounted for 38 percent of the 13 child fatalities occurring in 50 states and the District of Columbia, according to the 2009-2010 National School Bus Loading & Unloading Survey by the Kansas State Department of Education.

They included a 7-year-old struck and killed crossing the street with another child to catch his bus. The elderly driver said he couldn’t see the boys because of fog. The 7-year-old’s companion survived.

Georgia changed state law in 2011 to allow the installation of video cameras on school buses to catch violators.

By the following school year, Cobb and Fayette County schools had already begun arming some of their district buses with cameras.

At the time, Cobb estimated that about 1,000 violations occurred per day, or nearly one violation for each bus the district has on the road.

By the end of the school year, the Cobb program caught 871 violators using cameras on 102 of the district’s buses. But because the law still required police to issue citations, those motorists only received warnings.

State lawmakers have since updated the 2011 law to allow the districts or outside vendors to issue violations. Fines are $300 for the first offense and up to $1,000 for the third offense in five years.

Featured Fact-check

There is evidence that the increased enforcement has cut violations. In April 2013, Cobb filed 1,300 citations. This April, there were 767 citations in the state’s second-largest school district.

A statewide poll of bus drivers, who reported the number of motorists who blew past a stopped bus, also saw a decline from 8,102 in the 2010-2011 school year to 7,619 last year, according to an annual survey conducted by the National Association of State Directors of Pupil Transportation Services.

Carlton Allen, Georgia’s representative to that group, said the new law has helped. So, too, did a blitz by the Governor’s Office of Highway Safety two years ago to focus on the problem.

But Georgia still had 13 student deaths during bus loadings and unloadings in the past five years, said Allen, who is director of of pupil transportation services at the Georgia Department of Education.

"To me, part of that is the loss of a school bus safety unit in the state patrol and a reduction in our staff," Allen said of his office, down to three trainers from seven plus a clerical worker.

That leaves it to the local systems to seek other ways to reduce violations, which in Gwinnett numbered 2,000 in a single day.

American Traffic Solutions, which has taken over the program in Cobb, now sends video of violators to the county police to confirm a violation before they issue a citation.

In the metro area, Decatur, Clayton and Marietta schools also use the video cameras. Atlanta and Fulton have signaled they plan to install the devices in the coming year.

Georgia at one time did lead the nation in the number of students killed by motorists passing stopped school buses.

That was in the 2009-2010 school year, before the state adopted a law allowing video cameras to help tackle the problem.

The state has since updated the law to make it easier to ticket offenders. A growing number of school districts have begun using the video cameras as deterrents.

Georgia has not had a year as bad as the record-setter of 2009-2010, with five child deaths. But it also has not been fatality-free as more than 40 states are each year.

Even with the cameras, some motorists remain a problem.

Roach correctly stated that a study showed Georgia led the nation for bus-related fatalities at the time lawmakers passed a bill allowing the use of the cameras.

We rated her statement as True.

Our Sources

General Assembly 2011-2012 Regular Session, Senate Bill 57

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Gwinnett will put cameras on school buses," Oct. 16, 2014

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Cameras on bus to focus on tickets," July 19,2012

Kansas State Department of Education, 2009-2010 National School Bus Loading & Unloading Survey

Kansas State Department of Education, Annual School Bus Loading and Unloading reports

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "School buses armed with cameras," Aug. 4, 2012

School Transportation News, "Another Georgia district adds school bus stop-arm video enforcement," Sept. 18, 2013

American Traffic Solutions, "School bus storm arm and school zone speed safety white paper," August 2014

National Association of State Directors of Pupil Transportation Services, National Stop Arm Violation Count

Email interview with Sloan Roach, director of communications and media relations for Gwinnett County Public Schools, Nov. 8, 2014

Interview with T. Carlton Allen, division director of pupil transportation services at the Georgia Department of Education, Nov. 10, 2014

Email interview with Charles Territo, American Traffic Solutions

Email interview with Jody Ryan, Redflex

Cameras are rolling in

Atlanta City Schools*

Athens-Clarke County Schools

Ben Hill County Schools

Brantley County Schools

Bartow County Schools

Carroll County Schools

Carrollton City Schools

Clayton County Schools

Cobb County Schools

City Schools of Decatur

Douglas County Schools

Fulton County Schools*

Gwinnett County Schools

Haralson County  Schools

Henry County Schools

Houston County Schools

Houston County Schools

Marietta City Schools

McDuffie County Schools

Meriwether County Schools

Muscogee County Schools

Newton County Schools

Paulding County Schools

Valdosta City Schools

*Atlanta and Fulton County are expected to be up and running in early 2015.

Source: Redflex Traffic Systems and American Traffic Solutions

 

 

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Nancy Badertscher

Gwinnett spokeswoman on target with claim about school bus deaths

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up