Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Lost in the spectacular turmoil over who took Florida in the 2000 presidential election was a kerfuffle in Milwaukee, Wis., over 10 packs of cigarettes and some homeless voters.
Though it was never proven, the story goes that a few days before the polls opened, a New York Democratic activist gave men from the Milwaukee Rescue Mission cigarettes in exchange for their votes.
Conservative pundit Tucker Carlson alluded to this episode during the banter on Fox News’ noontime show Outnumbered Oct. 2.
"I don't think as a general matter you should be encouraging people who don't know anything about what they're voting for to vote," Carlson said. "That's what the Democrats do, giving Newports to the homeless to get them to the polls. That's literally true. Republicans shouldn't follow suit on that. You shouldn't pander to people."
A reader asked us to check whether there was any substance to Carlson’s dig at Democrats.
The basic events in Milwaukee
On the Saturday before the election on Nov. 7, 2000, Connie Milstein, a long-time Democratic donor from New York, was in Milwaukee. Milstein and some colleagues went to the mission and offered to give anyone who was interested a ride to City Hall to pick up an absentee ballot. About two dozen men took up the offer and at some point, 10 of them were given a pack of cigarettes each.
We don’t know, however, if they were promised the cigarettes in advance or asked for a smoke afterwards and were treated to a full pack. And we don’t know if the promise of cigarettes was in exchange for a vote.
In Wisconsin, it’s illegal to give a person anything worth more than $1 to induce them to vote. The cigarettes cost about $3.25 a pack. Republicans cried foul and pressed local prosecutors to file charges against Milstein.
The Milwaukee County District Attorney’s office was reluctant, if only because it might have cost thousands of dollars to bring the case to trial. Months later, after an investigation, Assistant District Attorney Kurt Benkley said he didn’t think the evidence proved anyone was guilty.
In May 2001, Milstein agreed to pay $5,000 in a civil forfeiture, a legal term that admitted no guilt and closed the case. Milstein’s lawyer Stephen Glynn told PunditFact that there was no evidence of a quid pro quo (a smoke for a vote).
"No one said that, ‘If I went to vote, I would receive cigarettes,’ " Glynn said.
Nonetheless, the campaign for Al Gore distanced itself from Milstein and released a statement right after the event happened saying her efforts were "not the kind of help we ask for and it’s the kind of help we flat out reject."
We emailed Carlson and asked for any background he could provide for his statement. We did not hear back. We could find no other example of cigarettes being offered to voters.
The oddest feature in Carlson’s statement is he specifically named Newport cigarettes.
Benkley, the assistant district attorney, said he has no idea where that came from because the brand of cigarette had nothing to do with the case.
"Those facts would never have come into the public domain," Benkley said. And he added, "I don’t recall the brand."
Bottom line: The Newport brand appears to be an invention.
Carlson said that Democrats give Newports to the homeless to get them to the polls.
Based on the evidence, Carlson is citing an isolated case where authorities were unable to prove that votes were traded for cigarettes, or that the cigarettes were an enticement.
On one occasion in Milwaukee, as many as three Democrats gave rides to homeless men to City Hall to cast absentee ballots. At some point, they gave some of the men cigarettes. There is no evidence that the cigarettes were Newports, and investigators did not find that the cigarettes were offered as an inducement to vote.
Calson emphasized that his account was "literally true," but by that standard, it is inaccurate on several points.
We rate the claim Half True.
Fox News, Outnumbered, Oct. 2, 2014
CNSNews.com, Wisconsin Homeless Reportedly Given Free Cigarettes For Gore Votes, July 7, 2008
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Incentive to voters questioned; Homeless men given cigarettes; Republicans may seek charges, Nov. 6, 2000
ABC News, More From Campaign Watchdog, Nov. 6, 2000
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Cigarettes case involves 15 to 25, Nov. 15, 2000
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Charge volunteer, leaders say; More evidence of election bribery needed, DA says, March 16, 2001
Associated Press, Democratic worker agrees to pay fine, May 4, 2001
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, $5,000 settles election case; Allegation involved cigarettes for votes of homeless men, May 4, 2001
Interview, Kurt Benkley, Milwaukee County assistant district attorney, Oct. 27, 2014
Interview, Stephen Glynn, lawyer, Oct. 27, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.