Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
U.S. Sen. Rand Paul invoked New Hampshire's state motto while speaking to its residents this week, seizing a chance to emphasize the idea that his libertarian-leaning ideals align with Granite State history.
"When the founders of New Hampshire came up with the motto Live Free or Die, they didn't leave a lot of wiggle room," he said to a crowd in Milford's town hall in his first New Hampshire appearance since announcing his run for president.
"New Hampshire founders didn’t seek out the mushy middle. They admonished you to live free."
The Kentucky Republican didn't just use the phrase. He attempted to explain where it came from.
And it looks like he got a little mixed up along the way.
We reached out to Paul’s New Hampshire advisors, but didn’t hear back.
The words "Live Free or Die," as cited by New Hampshire law, were written by General John Stark on July 31, 1809 – long after New Hampshire became a state.
A legendary military man, Stark offered the phrase as a toast. Because of his failing health, he declined an invitation to head up a reunion of the 1777 Battle of Bennington in Vermont, but left the group with those famous words.
A similar invitation was extended again the following year, saying, "The toast, sir, which you sent us in 1809 will continue to vibrate with unceasing pleasure in our ears, 'Live Free or Die; Death Is Not the Worst of Evils.' "
It must still have been vibrating in 1945, when the motto was formally adopted by the state Legislature.
Who "the founders of New Hampshire" are depends on your definition, but Stark isn't typically considered among them.
They could be the group that turned a community of towns into a "royal province" in 1679 – 49 years before Stark was born. They could also be the Congress of New Hampshire, which created in 1776 an independent constitution. Or they could be the people that ratified the U.S. Constitutiona few years later.
But none of those groups included Stark.
Nevertheless, a strong liberty-oriented sentiment existed in the state long before Stark, and even before it was called New Hampshire.
Among the earliest explorers of New Hampshire was Captain John Smith of England, who upon seeing the land is quoted as saying, "Here should be no landlords to rack us with high rents, or extorted fines to consume us. Here every man may be a master of his own labor and land in a short time."
And in 1775, less than a year before New Hampshirites drew up their own constitution, Patrick Henry uttered famous words, "Give me liberty or give me death," that people outside of New Hampshire often confuse with the state motto. Henry delivered those remarks during a speech in Virginia during the American Revolution.
It’s fair to assume liberty, and independence from the the royal rule of England, was on the minds of New Hampshire’s founders at the time it became a state, but not specifically Stark’s words.
New Hampshire’s motto is often invoked by politicians, like it was last month by Sen. Ted Cruz and in February by Texas Gov. Rick Perry, as the Associated Press reported.
And Paul isn't the first one to get the facts about Stark wrong. In 2011, Vice President Joe Biden referred to Stark as a former New Hampshire governor. That same year, Perry referred to him as "John Spark," Holly Ramer of The Association Press reported.
Rand Paul said "the founders of New Hampshire came up with the motto Live Free or Die."
New Hampshire’s motto is attributed to General John Stark, who was instrumental in defending it and the other colonies. But he wasn’t a founder of the state, and the motto wasn’t adopted until well after his death.
As one of the original 13 states to ratify the U.S. constitution, it’s not a stretch to think New Hampshire’s founders were focused on liberty, but not specifically the words of Stark.
We rate the claim False.
New Hampshire revised statutes, http://www.gencourt.state.nh.us/rsa/html/I/3/3-mrg.htm, April 10, 2015
New Hampshire Almanac, https://www.nh.gov/nhinfo/history.html, April 10, 2015
Constitution of New Hampshire, http://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/nh09.asp, April 10, 2015
Associated Press, Paul mixes up New Hampshire history in invoking state motto, April 10, 2015
SeacoastNH.com, Framers of freedom: John Stark, April 10, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.