Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
For years, Austin taxpayers have indirectly helped fund schools elsewhere in accord with the state’s more than 20-year-old system for equalizing aid among school districts, some of which have vast differences in taxable property wealth.
Kirk Watson, the Democratic state senator from Travis County, attached an ear-catching figure to those costs during a November 2016 Texas Tribune panel discussion about hot issues in the 2017 legislative session.
"In Austin, Texas," Watson said, "the average homeowner is paying about $1,300 to $1,400 just for recapture," as in funds shifted to less property-rich districts elsewhere. "And so that’s going to the state to fund state obligations. We have got to look at how we’re doing our school finance system so that we can do right by the people in this state and have a fair and equitable system."
We asked Watson’s office how he arrived at his figure for how much average Austin homeowners are paying to schools elsewhere. By email, Kate Alexander said Watson relied on September 2016 testimony by the Austin school district’s chief financial officer.
According to Nicole Conley's prepared remarks for a Sept. 28, 2016, appearance at a joint hearing of the Texas House committees on appropriations and public education, Conley described the Austin school district as the state’s largest single payer of recapture.
"Our payment alone comprises 13 percent of all state collections," Conley’s testimony says. "During the next five years—between fiscal years 2016 and 2020—Austin ISD is projected to pay almost $2.6 billion in recapture payments to the state. By 2019, more than half of every tax dollar collected in Austin will go to the state."
Later in her testimony: Conley said: "So to put it in perspective, we could lower our tax rate by 35 cents if we weren’t sending $406 million to the state under the recapture system. For the average homeowner in Austin, that would amount to about $1,400 in lower taxes. That’s fairly substantial; that’s pretty significant tax relief. That would certainly make Austin more affordable for some of our taxpayers."
To our inquiry, district spokesman Jacob Barrett told us Conley reached her savings figure for the average homeowner starting from the district’s 2016-17 budget indicating it expects to pay $406 million in recapture to the state in accord with the school funding system. That payment amounts to 38 percent of the district’s $1.061 billion in budgeted property taxes, Barrett noted.
Barrett said the district got to the average homeowner’s share of the budgeted recapture payment starting from its average taxable value of a home in the district of $328,844 (as of June 2016) on which such an owner expected to pay $3,548 in school maintenance and operations property taxes at the M&O tax rate of $1.079 per $100 valuation. Finally, Barrett said, multiplying the 38 percent by that $3,548 delivers the portion of taxes on an average-value residence that goes to recapture of $1,355.
Barrett also emailed us a December 2012 district document showing that by amount, the Austin district's 2015 recapture payment was followed by what was paid by the Highland Park (Dallas); Eanes; Cotulla; and Karnes City districts, respectively. Also, the document says, the Austin district’s annual recapture payment is projected to exceed $630 million in 2019 when "more than half of every school property tax dollar collected locally will be ‘recaptured’ by the state."
Next, we asked non-district experts--Joe Wisnoski, a former Texas Education Agency official; Tom Canby of the Texas Association of School Business Officials; and Christy Rome, who advocates for districts required to make recapture payments--to evaluate how the Austin district determined the average Austin homeowner will pay $1,355 in school property taxes toward the district’s 2016-17 recapture total.
Solid, each expert said.
By email, Wisnoski cautioned though: "The average doesn’t really describe much about the distribution of payment amounts, so you don’t really know how many taxpayers are clustered close to that amount, and how many are really far away (high or low) compared to the average."
Finally, we looked into how much a district resident with the median value home might be paying toward its recapture total. For that, we ran the median value of homes in the Austin district as of Aug. 8, 2016--$261,487--through the district’s equation. Result: The median-value homeowner will be expected to pay $2,821 in M&O school taxes, of which $1,078 would be her or his share of the district’s recapture payment.
Barrett, the district spokesman, didn’t question our math. He noted, though, that Watson referred to "the average homeowner." It’s fair, Barrett said by email, "to use the variable that we do."
Watson said the average Austin homeowner pays about $1,300 to $1,400 just for recapture, as in funds ultimately spent in other districts.
By the Austin district’s analysis, the owners of a home at the district’s average taxable value for 2016-17 stands to pay $1,355 in school property taxes toward the district’s more than $400 million recapture payment for the year.
We rate this claim True.
TRUE – The statement is accurate and there’s nothing significant missing. Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Email, Kate Alexander, policy director, state Sen. Kirk Watson, Dec. 7, 2016
Emails and telephone interview, Jacob Barrett, media relations coordinator, Austin Independent School District, Dec. 12-14, 2016
Written testimony, Nicole Conley, chief financial officer, AISD, prepared for joint hearing of Texas House Appropriations and Public Education committees, Sept. 28, 2016; Video of the hearing including Conley’s testimony about the 4:27 mark, Texas House
Document, "Finance at Austin ISD," AISD, December 2012 (received by email from Jacob Barrett, Dec. 12, 2016)
Telephone interview, Tom Canby, associate executive director, Texas Association of School Business Officials, Dec. 12, 2016
Email, Joe Wisnoski, associate, Moak, Casey & Associates, Dec. 14, 2016
Email, Christy Rome, executive director, Texas School Coalition, Dec. 14, 2016
Email, Marya D. Crigler, RPA, chief appraiser, Travis Central Appraisal District, Dec. 14, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.