Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.

Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Joshua Gillin
By Joshua Gillin July 11, 2016

Ritch Workman says he voted to remove Common Core, but it's more complicated than that

State Rep. Ritch Workman is looking to win a Florida Senate seat this fall, so he’s hoping to educate voters on his record of opposing Common Core.

In an online campaign ad posted June 20, 2016, Workman said that eight years ago he "promised to go to Tallahassee and cut taxes and shrink the size and scope of government." He said he followed through, passing tax cuts, changes to government pensions and ethics reform.

"I also voted to remove Common Core from our schools," he said in the video.

That statement riled up groups like Florida Parents Against Common Core, which accused Workman of "misrepresenting the facts." The group supports Workman’s opponent, Rep. Debbie Mayfield, who in 2013 sponsored a bill to repeal the standards. That bill never got out of committee.

But Workman told us he is telling the truth.

We wanted to find out whether Workman voted to get rid of Common Core standards in Florida.

A common history lesson

Common Core is a set of voluntary, state-based standards developed by the Council of Chief State School Officers and the National Governors Association. Created with input from teachers, parents and education experts, Common Core’s goal was to make an education in one state comparable with the education in another.

The final guidelines for math and English came out in 2010, and states could then decide whether to use them. Forty-five states, including Florida, voluntarily decided to accept the standards.

Like most states, Florida was good with the plan at first, and the state Board of Education adopted Common Core in 2010. But critics of Common Core attacked it as a federal takeover of education, and support for the guidelines waned.

Workman describes it on his Senate campaign website as "the federal government’s effort to nationalize our public schools."

But this fairly common misperception isn’t accurate. Washington is not in charge of creating or implementing the benchmarks, the states are — and they are free to change or abandon the standards as they see fit. What the federal government has done is encourage state standards and offer some grant money to aid the process. Florida, for example, won a $700 million federal grant for that purpose. That support has aroused suspicion among detractors.

Florida’s method of dealing with the backlash, meanwhile, has been complex.

Gov. Rick Scott initially supported Common Core, but in 2013 he ordered Florida to pull out of a consortium of states that were working together to create a new test they all would share to track progress. Eventually, the state chose to develop its own replacement to the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test, or FCAT.

Scott also called for public hearings that led state education officials in 2014 to recommend 98 changes to the benchmarks. Those proposed changes included things like 52 new calculus goals, guidelines for subjects beyond math and English, and a cursive writing requirement. The revisions were enough for the Florida Department of Education to consider the new guidelines separate from Common Core. Policy experts we talked to said they were more like extensions of the original standards.

"The resulting standards as we see them are closely aligned to the Common Core and high-quality (College and Career Readiness) standards in general," said Alyssa Schwenk, a spokeswoman at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, which works to reform education.

The state Board of Education approved the revisions unanimously in February 2014 and renamed them the Florida Standards.

So what, if anything, did Workman have to do with kicking Common Core out of class?

Featured Fact-check

A different standard

Workman told us the votes he mentioned came during the legislative session after Scott’s intervention and the education department’s changes, which Workman said he supported.

In April 2014, lawmakers passed HB 7031, a broad education bill that removed more than 30 mentions of the term "Common Core" from the books as the Department of Education adopted the Florida Standards. That bill passed the House and Senate unanimously.

Workman also voted for SB 1642, which froze sanctions based on school grading for a year, while the FCAT replacement (eventually known as the Florida Standards Assessment) was created.

"Those two bills repealed Common Core from the DOE's education policy," Workman told us in an email.

Keep in mind, the Florida Standards had already been adopted at this point. The Legislature didn’t decide to revise the guidelines, the Board of Education did. While Workman may have opposed Common Core, the provisions he’s touting as his votes to remove the benchmarks were largely procedural after the change had already been made.

So does that mean Common Core is out of Florida schools entirely? The name is certainly gone — "Common Core is out," Scott said in a 2014 interview — and the state says as much.

"My understanding is that Florida is no longer a participating state," Florida Department of Education spokeswoman Cheryl Etters told PolitiFact Florida.

But the Common Core State Standards Initiative still lists Florida as a Common Core state.

Olympia Meola, a spokeswoman for the Council of Chief State School Officers, told us the map showing those states on the initiative’s website lists both "states that have adopted the standards without any changes and those that have built upon and updated the Common Core State Standards to further fit their state’s unique context and priorities."

"It is common practice for states to revise their academic standards periodically, and, in doing so, to build upon previously adopted standards," Meola said. That’s what Florida did by adopting the Florida Standards.

Blair Mann, spokeswoman for the pro-Common Core nonprofit Collaborative for Student Success, noted "the standards are still remarkably similar, and considered comparable to, the Common Core State Standards that other states are implementing."

So while the term "Common Core" is gone, the bones of the standards remain. That means it’s not quite accurate to say Common Core is gone. A better term may be to say it has evolved.

Many critics of the Florida Standards agree, saying the new standards didn’t go far enough, and were essentially based on Common Core guidelines with "cosmetic changes."  

That makes it difficult for Workman to make the claim he did, according to Abigail Swisher, an analyst at the New America Foundation’s Education Policy Program.

"Given that Florida is still designated a Common Core State, it would appear contradictory for any one person to claim that they have ‘removed’ the Common Core in that state," she said.

Our ruling

Workman said he "voted to remove Common Core from our schools."

Workman did vote to literally remove the term "Common Core" from state records as Florida switched over to the revised Florida Standards. Indeed, the broad education bill that made it law was voted for unanimously.

But that was only after the Board of Education, and not the Legislature, agreed to revise the Common Core standards. Workman’s vote did not affect the decision to make that change. Furthermore, the new benchmarks were largely additions to the original standards, so it’s difficult to definitively say Common Core is out of schools.

The statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate it Mostly False.

 

Our Sources

State Rep. Ritch Workman, "Promises Review," June 16, 2016

Sunshine State News, "Florida Takes Home $700 Million in Race to the Top," Aug. 24, 2010

Tampa Bay Times, "Florida wins $700 million in federal grant money," Aug. 24, 2010

Tampa Bay Times, "Florida lawmaker has the zeal to repeal," Feb. 11, 2011

Orlando Sentinel, "Gov. Rick Scott: Let's compete for $100 million Race to Top grant for young kids," Aug. 27, 2011

Orlando Sentinel, "Florida loses out on Race to the Top grant for early childhood programs," Dec. 16, 2011

U.S. Department of Education, "Race To The Top, Florida Report, Year 2: School Year 2011-2012," Feb. 1, 2013

State Impact Florida, "Florida’s Education Budget By The Numbers," May 21, 2013

Tampa Bay Times, "Common Core curriculum standards spark political firestorm," Aug. 17, 2013

Tampa Bay Times, "Gov. Rick Scott reverses course on Common Core assessments," Sept. 23, 2013

State Impact Florida, "Gov. Scott Wants Another State To Manage PARCC’s Money," Sept. 23, 2013

Miami Herald Naked Politics blog, "Scott: Florida should pull out of PARCC," Sept. 23, 2013

Gov. Rick Scott, "Governor Rick Scott Announces Path Forward for High Education Standards & Decision to Withdraw from PARCC," Sept. 23, 2013

Tampa Bay Times Gradebook blog, "Why does Rep. Debbie Mayfield oppose the Common Core for Florida?," Sept. 3, 2013

PolitiFact Florida, "Common Core is turning U.S. Education Department into a national school board, Rubio says," Oct. 22, 2013

Tampa Bay Times Gradebook blog, "Florida has yet to spend much of its Race to the Top money," Dec. 30, 2013

State Impact Florida, "Education Commissioner Outlines Plans For Standards, School Grades, Evaluations And Privacy," Jan. 8, 2014

State Impact Florida, "Florida Activists Not Satisfied With Proposed Common Core Changes," Jan. 13, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "Florida education leaders recommend changes to controversial Common Core benchmarks," Jan. 13, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "Renaming 'Common Core' standards does little to end Florida's education debate," Jan. 19, 2014

Tampa Tribune, "Understanding Florida’s new Common Core standards," Jan. 20, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "Florida Board of Education approves Common Core tweaks during heated meeting," Feb. 18, 2014

Miami Herald Naked Politics blog, "Is a showdown looming over voucher expansion bill?," March 6, 2014

Florida Department of Education, "With Students as Top Priority Florida Chooses Replacement for FCAT," March 17, 2014

South Florida Sun-Sentinel, "Florida picks FCAT replacement for 2015," April 1, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "Florida House approves new school grading formula," April 30, 2014

Associated Press, "Scott approves 1-year pause on school grades," May 13, 2014

Tampa Bay Times Gradebook blog, "'Common Core is out,' Gov. Rick Scott says," May 23, 2014

News Service of Florida, "New Florida laws take effect Tuesday," June 30, 2014

Washington Post, "Common Core might be the most important issue in the 2016 Republican presidential race. Here’s what you need to know about it.," July 23, 2014

Tampa Bay Times, "Common Core creates political balancing act for Gov. Rick Scott," Sept. 7, 2014

South Florida Sun-Sentinel, "Scott takes first step to reduce testing in schools," Feb. 25, 2015

Florida Stop Common Core Coalition, "Statement on the Signing of HB 7069 Testing Bill," April 2015

Tampa Bay Times Gradebook blog, "Race to the Top winds down in Florida," May 6, 2015

TCPalm.com, "Reps. Mayfield, Workman will seek Sen. Altman’s redistricted seat in 2016," Dec. 18, 2015

Florida Today, "Senate race to pit House members Workman vs. Mayfield," Jan. 4, 2016

PolitiFact Florida, "Common Core was required to win Obama grants, U.S. Rep. David Jolly wrongly says," April 8, 2016

Sunshine State News, "Anti-Common Core Activists Slam Ritch Workman for 'False' Ads on Common Core Activism," June 29, 2016

RitchWorkman.com, Issues: Common Core, accessed June 29, 2016

TCPalm.com, Florida SD17 candidate questionnaire, accessed June 30, 2016

Florida Senate, SB 1642, accessed June 30, 2016

Florida House of Representatives, HB 25, accessed June 30, 2016

Florida House of Representatives, HB 7011, accessed June 30, 2016

Florida House of Representatives, HB 7069, accessed June 30, 2016

Florida House of Representatives, HB 7031, accessed June 30, 2016

Florida Department of Education, "Florida Standards," accessed June 30, 2016

Florida Department of Education, "Education Accountability Summit," accessed June 30, 2016

Interview with Lauren Schenone, Gov. Rick Scott spokeswoman, June 29-30, 2016

Interview with Cheryl Etters, Florida Department of Education spokeswoman, June 30 and July 1, 2016

Interview with Ritch Workman, state representative, June 30 and July 1, 2016

Interview with Abigail Swisher,  New America Foundation’s Education Policy Program analyst, July 1 and 5, 2016

Interview with Blair Mann, Collaborative for Student Success spokeswoman, July 1 and 5, 2016

Interview with Alyssa Schwenk, Thomas B. Fordham Institute spokeswoman, July 1 and 5-6, 2016

Interview with Olympia Meola, Council of Chief State School Officers spokeswoman, July 6, 2016


 

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Joshua Gillin

Ritch Workman says he voted to remove Common Core, but it's more complicated than that

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up