Documentary filmmaker Michael Moore’s response to the mass shooting in Las Vegas was to propose rewriting the Second Amendment, providing a laundry list of statistics to support his arguments for increased gun control.
Moore suggested his "proposed 28th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution" in an Oct. 4, 2017, Facebook post, three days after a gunman killed 58 and wounded 489 in a massacre at a Las Vegas country music festival.
His recommendations included limiting the number of bullets a firearm magazine may hold, banning all automatic and semi-automatic guns, and storing guns outside of the home.
"People who die from a home invasion make up a sad but minuscule .04 percent of all gun murders in the US. And over a third of them are killed by their own gun that the criminal has either stolen or wrestled from them," Moore wrote.
Polling shows that self-defense is the top reason most gun owners purchase their weapons, but we wondered whether Moore’s numbers were right. Do homicides during home invasions comprise 0.04 percent of all gun deaths in the United States? And are a third of those people killed with their own weapon?
We attempted to contact Moore to learn what sources he used, but didn’t hear back. The figures we found in both cases are difficult to confirm, even for the experts.
Problem No. 1: The term "home invasion" isn’t necessarily used in crime-tracking data. Broadly, the term usually describes a break-in at a residence while the people who live there are present, or more specifically, when someone breaks into a home to rob or hurt the residents.
Some jurisdictions use it and some don’t, but there is no universal definition or dataset. What would be called a home invasion is often reclassified as the eventual crime committed by the suspect — a robbery, a physical attack or so forth.
Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s National Violent Death Reporting System tracks the location, weapon and crime being committed at the time of a violent death. But there’s no distinction about whether it was during a home invasion, or with the victim’s own firearm.
The Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Uniform Crime Report and its Supplementary Homicide Report, which compile data voluntarily provided by local law enforcement agencies, track the number of homicides and whether another crime was being committed. Home invasion is not a specific category, however.
Several experts on firearm statistics told us they hadn’t seen a recent study on either home invasions ending in homicide or who owned the weapon used, but Moore’s first point sounded somewhat reasonable.
"Every year, there are about 100 burglary homicides in the U.S. If half of these were gun homicides, he would be in the right ballpark," University of Chicago Crime Lab co-director Harold Pollack said. "So the statistic isn’t wildly off base, but I haven’t seen a rigorous analysis. There’s no question that lethal home invasions are terrifying but rare events."
When we checked 2015 FBI figures, for example, there were 13,455 reported homicides, and 102 of those happened during burglaries. That’s 0.76 percent of all homicides — but there was no mention of the term home invasion, or the weapon used to commit the homicide.
It turns out there is one study that did come close to defining things the way Moore did, but Moore overstated the reported figure.
A 2010 report from the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics noted that "between 2003 and 2007, approximately 2.1 million household burglaries were reported to the FBI each year on average. Household burglaries ending in homicide made up 0.004% of all burglaries during that period."
That’s about 86 people killed during a burglary annually, but the 0.004 percent is from all burglaries, not just ones classified as home invasions. Furthermore, the report’s 0.004 percent is 10 times less than the 0.04 percent figure Moore stated.
The study also does not specify a gun was the murder weapon, but rather counts every homicide regardless of how it was committed.
Shannan Catalano, a statistician at the Bureau of Justice Statistics, said the datapoint was actually only a side note in her larger report from 2010, but showed how few homicide-related burglaries there were overall.
Moore appeared to take the figure from her study, she said, but for some reason got the percentage wrong. Catalano suggested it may have been a typographical error, but had no way of knowing Moore’s intent.
Catalano’s broader study used data from her agency’s National Crime Victimization Survey, which uses statistical samples from a cross-section of addresses around the United States to estimate crimes. She said she will update the study in 2018, using the National Incident Based Reporting System.
Like everyone else we contacted, Catalano also did not know of a statistic that supported Moore’s second assertion about a third of people being killed with their own gun during these attacks at home. Several studies show owning a firearm greatly increases the risk of unintentional gun-related deaths.
Philip Cook, a public policy professor at Duke University, said if a statistic showing people killed by their own weapon in home burglaries exists, it’s not widely known.
"I’m quite sure that it’s not part of any of the standard databases," Cook said. "So it must be a one-time study by someone, probably of limited scope."
Moore said, "People who die from a home invasion make up a sad but minuscule .04 percent of all gun murders in the U.S. And over a third of them are killed by their own gun that the criminal has either stolen or wrestled from them."
While Moore has a point that guns are rarely used when someone breaks into a home, it is difficult to confirm. After interviewing several experts and agencies, we only found one study that came close to supporting Moore’s assertion about the number of home invasion deaths. Even then, the report’s author said Moore misstated the scope and specifics.
Our sources conceded that the homicide rate during burglaries is a tiny fraction of overall gun deaths, committed during burglaries or otherwise. But none of them, including federal agencies that track crime, could independently verify Moore’s figures about the owner of the weapon used in those crimes the way he claimed.
We rate this statement Mostly False.
Michael Moore, Facebook post, Oct. 4, 2017
JAMANetwork.com, "Weapon Involvement in Home Invasion Crimes," June 14, 1995
Injury Prevention, "Association between handgun purchase and mortality from firearm injury," March 2003
Accident Analysis & Prevention, "Firearms in US homes as a risk factor for unintentional gunshot fatality," September 2003
American Journal of Epidemiology, "Guns in the Home and Risk of a Violent Death in the Home: Findings from a National Study," November 2004
U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, "Victimization During Household Burglary," September 2010
The Nation, "We Fear Each Other, When Guns Themselves Are The Real Danger," Dec. 20, 2012
The Atlantic, "Gun Violence and the Irrational Fear of Home Invasion," Dec. 23, 2012
U.S. Justice Department, "The Nation’s Two Measures of Homicide," July 2014
RasmussenReports.com, "Why Are Americans Buying So Many Guns?," April 13, 2016
Crime Prevention Research Center, "Violence Policy Center keeps using using Justifiable Homicide data to make false claims about defensive gun use," Sept. 24, 2017
FBI Uniform Crime Report, "Expanded Homicide Data Table 10, Murder Circumstances by Relationship, 2015," accessed Oct. 18, 2017
Interview with Garen Wintemute, University of California Davis Violence Prevention Research Program director, Oct. 5, 2017
Interview with Daniel Webster, Johns Hopkins University health policy and management professor, Oct. 5, 2017
Interview with Harold Pollack, University of Chicago Crime Lab co-director, Oct. 5, 2017
Interview with John Lott, Crime Prevention Research Center president, Oct. 5, 2017
Interview with Philip Cook, Duke University public policy professor, Oct. 11, 2017
Interview with Garrett McDonough, Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence spokesman, Oct. 11-12, 2017
Interview with Lilly Athamanah, Joyce Foundation spokeswoman, Oct. 12, 2017
Interview with Courtney Lenard, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control spokeswoman, Oct. 13, 2017
Interview with Mary Fan, University of Washington law professor, Oct. 18, 2017
Interview with David Hemenway, Harvard University health policy professor, Oct. 18, 2017
Interview with Stephen Fisher, FBI media productions chief, Oct. 19, 2017
Interview with Shannan Catalano, U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics statistician, Oct. 18-25
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.