Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump has been repeatedly attacked by his opponents for his sometimes-derogatory statements about women.
At the Democratic convention in Philadelphia, delegates saw a video where some of those comments were repeated, but one caught our eye. At the end of the 30-second video a voice says, "So you treat women with respect."
The video shifts to a younger Trump saying sheepishly, "I can't say that either" and offering a half-laugh.
The clip is so short, we wondered if it was an accurate representation of the interview.
We emailed the Democratic National Committee about its source. They couldn't immediately provide it but, meanwhile, we found it thanks to The Washington Post Fact-Checker examination of two pro-Clinton ads in June.
The video shown at the Democratic convention was originally an ad released by the Hillary Clinton campaign.
The source of the quote comes from a 39-minute interview with Howard Stern conducted in 1993 on the E! cable channel.
Stern is not shown in the clip, although some might recognize his voice. The shock-jock is known for getting his guests to say outrageous things.
The interview was conducted after a New York magazine article on Trump said, "His contempt for beautiful women who liked to be abused is boundless." The article characterized his philosophy as, "You have to treat them like s---," a characterization by author Julie Baumgold, not a direct quote from Trump himself.
In the interview, Stern asks Trump about the quote.
"No, I never said that," Trump responds."But it was attributed to me."
After some chatter by Stern, Trump again denies saying it.
"I see," says Stern. "So you treat women with respect."
Trump smiles. "Ahhhh. I can't say that either," he says with a chortle.
"Alright, good," says Stern. "Somewhere in between."
Then Trump adds, "I treat women with great respect," his tone sounding more serious this time, but it's not completely clear because the camera, at this point, is on Stern instead of Trump.
Stern then insists, with the help of a chart, that Trump rank his wife and girlfriends.
When we asked the Clinton campaign if Trump's comment was taken out of context, deputy communications director Christina Reynolds responded with an emailed statement that "in a conversation about whether he respects (women), his first inclination is to say that he 'can't say.' That statement, coming during an exchange about previous disrespectful comments about women, speaks volumes and is perfectly in context with his lifelong record."
Hillary Clinton, in a campaign ad shown at the Democratic convention, said that when an interviewer asked Donald Trump if he treats women with respect, Trump replied, "I can't say that."
The four-second clip has not been doctored. But this is an example of where context can be crucial.
It omits the fact that Stern is the interviewer. The opening question of whether Trump said he treats women like feces, Trump's denial, Stern's assessment that it's "somewhere in between" and Trump's subsequent response that "I treat women with great respect" are all missing.
Because so much is ignored in this brief clip— information that could give a different impression — we rate the claim Mostly False.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/9e51f9c5-2a3d-4dd0-a2c3-6d8f7edac738
The Washington Post, "Pro-Clinton ads quote Trump's comments on women and nuclear weapons without context," June 24, 2016
YouTube, "Howard Stern : E! Interview Donald Trump," 1993, posted March 31, 2016, and "Hillary Clinton Releases Ad Featuring Quotes From Donald Trump for Women," June 10, 2016
New York, "Fighting Back; Trump Scrambles off the Canvas," Nov. 9, 1992
Email, Christina Reynolds, deputy communications director, Hillary Clinton campaign, July 26, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.