Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Reluctance by Senate Republicans to confirm President Barack Obama’s Supreme Court pick after the death of Justice Antonin Scalia is giving Democrats across the country plenty of political ammunition.
It’s also playing out in Nevada, where the state Democratic Party is repeatedly slamming Republican Senate candidate and U.S. Rep Joe Heck over his measured, non-committal position on filling the vacancy.
But one attack stuck out as particularly noteworthy — the claim that "every" Republican Senate candidate other than Heck has announced a position on taking up the vacancy.
Here’s what party spokeswoman Sarah Zukowski said:
"Every Republican Senate candidate has now taken a position on the issue of whether the Senate should go a whole year without doing its job, but all we get from Congressman Heck are non-answers and Washington-speak," she said in a press release on Feb. 23.
It’s quite a claim to say that literally every Republican senatorial candidate has taken a position on any issue, much less the politically-charged Supreme Court vacancy, so we decided to look into it.
Journalists at the New York Times and liberal websites Think Progress and Daily Kos have tried to chart out where individual Senate Republicans stand on the issue of approving a nominee either now or under the next president.
But those lists are mostly focused on the positions of sitting senators, and don’t include Senate hopefuls like Heck.
So we put together a more complete list of what candidates and incumbent senators up for re-election in 2016 have said about the court vacancy using candidates listed in political scientist Larry Sabato’s "Crystal Ball."
We found several who haven’t addressed the issue at all.
In Maryland, for example, at least 14 candidates have filed as Republicans to run for the open Senate seat currently held by Democratic Sen. Barbara Mikulski. Only a handful of the candidates have functioning websites, and we could only find two candidates — Mark McNicholas and Chrysovalantis Kefalas — who even addressed the vacancy issue.
It’s a similar case in Colorado, with 12 Republicans vying to take on incumbent Sen. Michael Bennet. Candidates there are all over the map, including some like state Sen. Tim Neville who have taken a similarly neutral or otherwise vague position.
"As far as the schedule is concerned, the U.S. Senate is going to have the final say on who gets approved," he said to the Aurora Sentinel. "So whether it happens now or after the next election, the Republican Senate majority needs to stand strong and only confirm a nominee that will stand firm in defense of the Constitution."
Duf Sundheim, a California Republican running a long-shot Senate bid, issued a similarly vague statement.
"Whether they approve or reject a nominee is a decision that should be made by each senator," he said. "But they should do so with the highest level of veracity and honor."
In total, we found at least 15 candidates who issued vague statements not specifically spelling out what they believe the Senate should do regarding the court vacancy, and many more who didn’t announce any position on their website or social media accounts.
It’s fair to point out that many of the listed candidates are, to put it generously, running grassroots campaigns with little money and little hope of ending up in office. Zukowski issued a backtracking statement to PolitiFact saying, "All serious GOP Senate candidates have made it clear where they stand on the GOP's refusal to do its job."
But the party is wrong in saying that the entire field of Republican Senate candidates have announced a clear stance on the issue, and in declaring that Heck stands alone in taking a guarded position on the vacancy.
The Nevada Democratic Party says that "every Republican Senate candidate" has announced their position on the Supreme Court vacancy, except for Heck.
Our research shows that’s not the case. There are more than a dozen candidates, at least, who issued similarly neutral statements, and even more who haven’t addressed the issue at all.
We rate the claim as False.
Email and phone interview with Brian Baluta, spokesman for Dr. Joe Heck, March 2, 2016.
Email and phone interview with Sarah Zukowski, spokeswoman for Nevada State Democratic Party, Feb. 29, 2016
Email interview with Greg Blair, spokesman for the National Republican Senatorial Committee, Feb. 25, 2016
Sabato’s Crystal Ball, "2016 Senate candidates," March 1, 2016
Nevada Democrats, "DO YOUR JOB WATCH: EVERY GOP SENATE CANDIDATE HAS NOW MADE A DECISION ON SCOTUS VACANCY…EXCEPT CONGRESSMAN HECK," Feb. 23, 2016
Think Progress, "Extreme Outrage To Conspicuous Silence: What Every Republican Is Saying About Scalia’s Replacement," Feb. 18, 2016
New York Times, "Where the Senate Stands on Nominating Scalia’s Supreme Court Successor," Feb. 17, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.