As congressional Republicans decide how to repeal the Affordable Care Act, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., published an op-ed on FoxNews.com titled, "ObamaCare failed Americans. Now it's time for relief."
"By nearly any measure, Obamacare has failed: It didn’t lower costs, it didn’t increase choice, middle-class families continue to lose health plans they were promised they could keep, and Americans continue to call for Obamacare’s repeal," McConnell wrote on Jan. 9. "They spoke loudly again this November, and about 8 out of 10 favor changing Obamacare significantly or replacing it altogether."
"That doesn’t mean the law will end overnight," he continued. "There will be a stable transition period, and once repeal is passed we will turn to replacement policies that cost less and work better than what we have now."
What caught our eye in this passage was McConnell’s citation of the eight of 10 figure. When we took a closer look, we found a credible source for it, but also some missing context.
Let’s take a closer look.
Where the number comes from
McConnell’s office pointed to a Nov. 28, 2016, news release by Gallup that summarized one of its periodic polls on health care. The headline was, "Most Americans Want Changes to Affordable Care Act."
Gallup’s release goes on to say, "Whatever the exact course of action that ensues once Trump and the new Congress take office, it is clear that about eight in 10 Americans favor changing the ACA significantly (43 percent) or replacing it altogether (37 percent)." This data is based on a survey conducted on Nov. 9 to Nov. 13, 2016.
"The majority leader made an accurate statement that, according to Gallup, about 8 out of 10 favor changing Obamacare significantly or replacing it altogether," said Don Stewart, a spokesman for McConnell. "Given the myriad problems with the law and the impact on families, the poll was not a surprise."
An outside specialist in health policy and polling, Robert J. Blendon of Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public Health, said McConnell has a good basis for supporting his claim, given Gallup’s framing of the results.
"For years, politicians have taken what's in Gallup releases," Blendon said.
Why it can be misinterpreted
McConnell has been careful in how he relates what Gallup wrote. But the statistic's usefulness for supporting his larger point -- that Obamacare should be repealed in the way he's proposing -- is not as clear. Reading his op-ed, it’s easy to jump to the conclusion that 80 percent of Americans want to repeal the law. But that's not the case, according to the Gallup data.
It’s true that only 14 percent of respondents said they would keep the law as is, and that’s less than the 37 percent who wanted to repeal the law entirely. However, a plurality of respondents -- 43 percent -- said they wanted to keep the law but make "significant changes" to it.
Specifically, 28 percent said they approved of the law but wanted to see significant changes to it -- and this constituency included both people who generally approved of the law and those who generally disapproved of it. The inclusion of those who approve the law and want changes to it -- and who would be unlikely to be on board for a full repeal, as McConnell seeks -- is what inflates the number to 80 percent.
Other recent surveys fill in some of the blanks about what these respondents might be thinking.
An October 2016 survey by Harvard University’s Chan School and Politico gave respondents six options for handling the Affordable Care Act (not counting "don’t know," which registered 10 percent).
The first three categories include people who either support the law or think it should go even further than it does today:
Replace with universal Medicare: 14 percent
Expand the existing program: 8 percent
Keep the law as is: 18 percent
Collectively, then, 40 percent either support an even stronger law or keeping the law as is.
The other three categories align more closely with McConnell’s opinion, and they add up to 50 percent.
Replace with a tax credit program: 16 percent
Scale back and give states control: 14 percent
Repeal completely: 20 percent
The Politico-Harvard results broadly mirror other recent polls about repealing the Affordable Care Act. In general, more people favor a repeal than oppose one, but support levels for a repeal are in the 40 percent to 50 percent range, rather than the 80 percent range.
For instance, a Kaiser Family Foundation tracking poll taken in mid December 2016 found that 49 percent favored repeal, 47 percent opposed repeal, and 4 percent were unsure or refused to answer.
McConnell wrote that "Americans continue to call for Obamacare’s repeal. … About 8 out of 10 favor changing ObamaCare significantly or replacing it altogether."
McConnell has carefully worded a statistic from a credible source, the Gallup news release. However, it's worth remembering that a notable share of people whose favored "significant" changes to the law either want a single-payer plan or an even stronger Obamacare law -- two options that are off the table for McConnell. We rate his statement Mostly True.
Mitch McConnell, "Senate Majority Leader McConnell: ObamaCare failed Americans. Now it's time for relief," Jan. 9, 2016
Gallup, "Most Americans Want Changes to Affordable Care Act," Nov. 28, 2016
Gallup, results from health care poll, Nov. 9-13, 2016
Politico and Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, "The 2016 election: Clinton vs. Trump Voters on American Health Care," October 2016
Kaiser Family Foundation, "Poll: Public Divided on Repealing Obamacare, But Few Want It Repealed Without Replacement Details," Jan. 6, 2017
Email interview with Robert J. Blendon, specialist in health care and public opinion at Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Jan. 11, 2016
Email interview with Don Stewart, spokesman for Mitch McConnell, Jan. 11, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.