Facts are under assault in 2020.
We can't fight back misinformation about the election and COVID-19 without you. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact
I would like to contribute
A fake news story makes the explosive claim that, on the heels of his inauguration, President Donald Trump personally greenlighted the chairman of a powerful congressional watchdog committee to pursue criminal charges against Hillary Clinton.
The story appears on the website Federalist Tribune alongside a video clip in which Rep. Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, recalled Trump speaking in general terms about Chaffetz’s oversight authority during a backstage meeting at the Jan. 26 Republican retreat in Philadelphia.
But at no point does the chairman of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee claim that Trump even mentioned Clinton’s name -- much less that Trump urged him to ramp up an investigation into the 2016 Democratic nominee, as the story claims.
The Federalist Tribune story, which has more than 5,000 page views at the time of this writing, is just one of several websites to use the Chaffetz video to advance the unsubstantiated claim that Trump encouraged Congress to aggressively pursue charges against Clinton.
And it’s worth noting that as it stands now, we’ve rated Trump’s campaign promise to appoint a special prosecutor to investigate Clinton as Stalled.
The fake article opens with the inflammatory allegation that Trump has "finally given Congress the authorization" to pursue charges against Clinton over her use of a private email server while secretary of state.
It then mischaracterizes Chaffetz’s recollection of his meeting with Trump by claiming Chaffetz’s statement "hint(s) that charges against Hillary could be happening soon" -- before promising that "Hillary Clinton may finally be indicted."
In truth, the video shows Chaffetz merely recalling how Trump offered him words of encouragement about staying focused on his oversight mission, without mentioning any specific investigations.
Chaffetz recalled Trump telling him, "‘I understand that I’m the president. But you have a job to do. You do the oversight. You don't slow down. You go after everything you want to go after. You look at anything you want to look at.’"
Chaffetz said Trump’s words at the Philadelphia convention were an inspiring message about how Trump views his committee’s government watchdog role.
"If you sat there and heard what he said to me about pursuing oversight of the government and the function that we fulfill, you’d be pretty inspired," Chaffetz said. "And for him to convey a message of 'Don't slow down, go do your job, there’s a lot to get after with the government,' I think was a good message."
It’s wrongheaded to extrapolate from Chaffetz’s statement that Trump gave his imprimatur to a ramped-up investigation into Clinton.
Chaffetz’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
For his part, Chaffetz said after the election that Clinton’s defeat would not signal an end to his committee’s investigation of her email practices and handling of classified information while in government.
But there’s no evidence Trump has personally urged him to keep the pressure up.
A number of bloggers said President Trump greenlighted Congress to ramp up the Clinton investigation -- and used a video clip of Chaffetz to advance this claim.
But these bloggers have mischaracterized the video. In it, Chaffetz describes a meeting in which Trump offered general words of encouragement and emphasized the importance of Congress’ oversight function, without reference to Clinton, or any specific investigation.
At no point in the video does Chaffetz say Trump greenlighted, encouraged or even hinted at the need to ramp up an investigation into Clinton.
We rate this statement Pants on Fire.
Federalist Tribune, "Trump Gives Chaffetz the Thumbs Up for Investigating Hillary Clinton's Email Server," May 10, 2016
USA Newsflash, "Trump Authorizes Congress To Pursue Criminal Charges Against Hillary,"
The Washington Feed, "Breaking: Trump Authorizes Congress To Pursue Criminal Charges Against Hillary"
The World Updater, "BOOM! President TRUMP JUST Authorizes Congress To Pursue Criminal Charges Against Hillary Clinton," May 11, 2017
USA Supreme, "President Trump Has Authorized Congress To Pursue Criminal Charges Against Hillary Clinton According To Jason Chaffetz!" Jan. 31, 2017
YourNewsWire.com, "Trump Authorizes Congress To Pursue Criminal Charges Against Hillary,"
Washington Post, "Top House Republican says he’ll continue probe of Hillary Clinton’s private email server," Nov. 9, 2016
PolitiFact, "Appoint a special prosecutor to investigate Hillary Clinton"
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.