Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Gov. Roy Cooper has repeatedly said the state isn’t doing enough to provide teachers with the supplies they need.
Classroom equipment and supply funding has fallen by tens of millions of dollars over the past decade and, in response, Cooper has pushed legislative leaders for more funding and even held his own school supply drive.
Republicans hold a supermajority in the North Carolina legislature and recently passed their budget plan mostly without the help of Democrats.
Since then, Democrats have criticized Republicans for what they see as "pork" in the budget. Cooper made one such attack on May 30, when he tweeted a graphic that reads:
"One legislative Republican’s district gets almost all the school supply funding."
Base vs. new funding
Sadie Weiner, Cooper’s communications director, highlighted in an email a key distinction that’s not included in the tweet: It’s referring to new, additional funding — not the base budget for all school districts in the state.
"That tweet is talking about new school supply funding in the 2018-19 budget. Republicans will argue that their budget has $47 million for school supplies and instructional equipment. That is routine funding in the base budget, it is not new funding, and the Governor’s recommended budget includes the same $47 million," she wrote.
"The Governor included $15 million in new funding that would go directly to teachers in the form of a school supply stipend," Weiner continued. "That money would go to all state-funded teachers, not just those in a single district as the Republican budget has done."
She referred to Senate District 41, represented by Cornelius Republican Jeff Tarte, who faces a competitive re-election race in November. The budget includes $200,000 for DonorsChoose.org, a New York-based nonprofit. The bill instructed the group to use the money on supplies for teachers in certain schools within Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools — all within Tarte’s district.
Donors Choose declined the money, saying the grant didn’t provide "equitable" funding across the state. The Charlotte Observer posted a story about the group’s decision less than an hour after Cooper posted the tweet.
While Cooper's tweet doesn't differentiate between base and new school supply funding, Weiner noted that Cooper was more specific in his press conference on Wednesday.
The budget, he said, "falls short on textbooks and digital learning, offers new schools supply money only to a few in-tech schools."
Other supply funding
Jonathan Sink, an aide to House Speaker Tim Moore, said in an email that the budget provides five new grants for classroom supplies, materials and equipment. In addition to DonorsChoose, the following groups get money:
· Franklin County Education Foundation: $60,000 to support grants for supplies to teachers in Franklin County Schools
· Town of Holly Springs: $50,000 to support four programs, one of which is the Teacher Classroom Supply Program
· Cary Chamber of Commerce: $25,000 to support a Cary Teacher Classroom Supply Program
· Robeson County Career Center: $7,500 for purchase of classroom equipment at the Robeson County Career Center in the Public Schools of Robeson County.
Cooper tweeted: "One legislative Republican’s district gets almost all the school supply funding." Cooper has a point that budget writers designated a large portion of new school supply funding to schools in one Republican legislator’s district.
But his tweet lacks important context, giving the impression that school districts might go without new school supplies this year — which isn’t true. We rate this claim Mostly False.
A post by the Twitter account for Gov. Roy Cooper on May 30, 2018.
The online text of Senate Bill 99.
Email correspondence with Sadie Weiner, communications director for Gov. Roy Cooper.
Email correspondence with Jonathan Sink, deputy general counsel in House Speaker Tim Moore’s office.
Phone interview with Todd Silberman, communications specialist at the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction.
Stories by The Charlotte Observer, "Why are these 35 CMS schools targeted for extra money in N.C. budget? Think election," published May 29, 2018; "Charity refuses to pass NC taxpayer money to schools in one senator's district," published May 30, 2018.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.