Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden attacked President Trump in a new digital campaign ad, which claims California firefighters "spoke out" against the president over his controversial tweet during the state’s deadly November 2018 wildfires.
Trump’s tweet, which was his first public comment on the fires, blamed the state’s poor "forest management" for the infernos and threatened to withhold federal funding.
Biden’s ad includes images of California burning and the head of the state’s largest firefighters union calling Trump’s statement "idiotic."
"Firefighters say the tweet contained so much misinformation, they had to speak out," the ad claims.
Is Biden’s ad right? Did California firefighters, beyond the union president, really criticize Trump during the wildfires? We set out on a fact check.
The Camp Fire rages through Paradise, Calif., on Thursday, Nov. 8, 2018. Noah Berger / AP Photo
Background on the fires
The ad references Northern California’s Camp Fire and Southern California’s Woolsey Fire, both of which broke out in November 2018.
The Camp Fire killed 86 people in Butte County and destroyed nearly 19,000 structures, including 14,000 homes, making it the state’s most deadly and destructive wildfire in history. The Woolsey Fire killed three people and destroyed more than 1,600 structures.
Here’s Trump’s tweet from Nov. 10, 2018:
Shortly after, PolitiFact California fact-checked Trump’s claim that forest management is the sole reason for the fires. We rated it False.
Forestry and climate experts told us stronger winds, higher temperatures and drier conditions driven by climate change are also making California’s fires worse. They said forest management is one factor, but not necessarily the driving force.
In another tweet two days later, Trump thanked California’s firefighters and first responders. He also approved California's request for a major disaster declaration, freeing up federal aid for fire response and recovery.
Criticism from firefighters
The most vocal fire leader to criticize Trump was Brian Rice, president of the California Professional Firefighters.
Rice is shown in the Biden ad saying "That statement was idiodic," referring to Trump’s tweet. The comments were lifted from an interview Rice did with a San Francisco TV news station. In the full interview, he added: "It was ill timed. And it’s ignorant. It’s a statement of an ignorant man. … I love my country. I am proud to be an American. But I am disgusted with my president."
In an interview this week, Rice called Biden's ad "fair and accurate." A union spokesperson said Rice "clearly spoke out," citing a formal statement he issued at the time. "The statement pretty clearly indicates that Mr. Rice believes Mr. Trump’s tweet was misinformed," he said.
Rice said his chapter fully supports the decision of its national union to endorse Biden’s 2020 presidential bid. The International Association of Fire Fighters announced its support for Biden in April.
Biden is in a virtual tie with Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren among likely voters in California’s Democratic primary, according to a Real Clear Politics average of polls.
A spokesperson for Biden’s campaign attributed all of the ad’s statements, including the claim that firefighters spoke out against the president, to news coverage. The claim in question, that "Firefighters say the tweet contained so much misinformation, they had to speak out," comes directly from a TV reporter narrating a news story.
We found Rice wasn’t the only fire leader to criticize Trump’s words.
The Biden ad includes a brief clip of Los Angeles Fire Chief Daryl Osby, pulled from a separate TV interview. In it, he says the state is "in extreme climate change right now." That by itself isn’t a biting critique. But Osby goes on to say in his full interview: "I personally find that statement unsatisfactory … It’s very hurtful for all first responders that are putting their lives on the line to protect lives and property."
Tom O’Connor, president of the San Francisco Fire Local 798, also criticized Trump’s tweet, telling a TV station after asked about the tweet that, "Now is not the time for politics. It’s a time for leadership. It’s not the ‘red and blue states of America.’ It’s the United States of America."
Finally, Scott Austin, president of the Pasadena Firefighters Association said in a tweet: "Mr. President, with all due respect, you are wrong. The fires in So. Cal are urban interface fires and have NOTHING to do with forest management. Come to SoCal and learn the facts & help the victims. Scott Austin, Pres IAFF 809."
The Trump campaign did not respond to a request for comment.
Former vice president and current Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden attacked President Trump in a recent campaign ad over his comments last year on California’s deadly wildfires.
The Biden ad claimed California firefighters "spoke out" against the president over a controversial tweet he made as the fires raged. The tweet included a threat to withhold federal funds.
The ad shows two fire leaders, including the president of the state’s largest firefighter union, speaking out when asked about Trump’s statements. Full interviews with those leaders show they went on to make even stronger critiques of Trump.
Additional news reports show other top fire leaders calling out the president’s tweet as misinformed and an inappropriate use of politics during a time of crisis.
This backs up the main assertion about firefighters speaking out.
We rated the claim in the Biden ad as True.
TRUE – The statement is accurate and there’s nothing significant missing.
Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Ask PolitiFact California!
Do you have a question about California politics or government?
Send it to us here and one of our reporters will consider it for our next ‘Ask PolitiFact California’ report.
Biden for President, campaign ad, accessed December 2019
President Trump, tweet, Nov. 10, 2018
PolitiFact, Does Donald Trump believe in man-made climate change?, June 5, 2017
PolitiFact California, Trump’s overly simplistic and false claim on California’s wildfires, Nov. 12, 2018
KPIX CBS, Firefighters Respond To Trump's 'Misinformed' Tweet About California Wildfires, November 10, 2019
California Professional Firefighters, CPF President Responds to President's Threat to Cut Off Aid to Fire Victims, Nov. 10, 2018
Michael Gwin, spokesperson, Biden for President, phone interview Dec. 17, 2019
Carroll Wills, spokesperson, California Professional Firefighters, email exchange, Dec. 17, 2019
Sacramento Bee, Trump’s tweet on California fires drives firefighter union to Joe Biden for 2020, Dec. 12, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.