Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Gov. Andrew Cuomo put forth his agenda for the first 100 days of his third term in a recent speech, and he repeated a major theme from his 2018 re-election campaign, calling New York the "progressive capital of the nation" while the federal government is "taking us backwards."
He cited paid family leave as one of the policies that make New York more progressive than other states.
"We are the first state to truly attack economic injustice by raising the minimum wage to $15, and by passing the best paid family leave and free college tuition programs in the United States of America," he said.
We wondered, does New York have the best paid family leave program in the country?
The federal Family and Medical Leave Act provides up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave for 60 percent of the workforce. But only 13 percent of private-sector workers in the U.S. have access to paid leave through their employer, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Four states -- New York, New Jersey, Rhode Island and California -- have active paid family leave policies, according to the Congressional Research Service. Washington, D.C., Washington state, and Massachusetts enacted programs in 2017 or 2018 that will administer benefits in 2020 or 2021. Funding, eligibility criteria, the duration of benefits and the value of those benefits differ among the states. But every program provides leave to parents of a newly arriving child through birth, adoption or foster care, as well as the care of a close family member with a serious medical condition.
New York’s law is funded with employee contributions through a payroll tax. New York offered eight weeks of paid leave in 2018, and that increases to 10 weeks in 2019 and 2020, and to 12 weeks in 2021.
A spokeswoman for Cuomo, Hazel Crampton-Hays, wrote in an email that New York "offers the strongest active Paid Family Leave program in the nation," because it offers the longest amount of leave time, job protections for all employees, and the broadest uses of leave, including military-related leave.
Some experts agreed that New York has the strongest program that is currently active, but they warned that trying to determine the "best" has its pitfalls. Best for whom? Also, each program has its own complexities that can make comparisons difficult.
Isabel Sawhill, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, which employs experts with a variety of points of view, wrote in an email that "the most important parameters are probably the amount of the benefit and how long it lasts."
Sawhill wrote that New York’s program is "very generous," depending on what someone values most, and that it might be the best, "but I think that’s a stretch."
An expert with the National Partnership for Women and Families, an advocacy organization that is in favor of paid family leave, said New York’s program improves upon the three others in place in California, New Jersey and Rhode Island.
New York offers job protections to all workers, including those in smaller companies, while New Jersey and California do not, said Vicki Shabo, vice president for workplace policies and strategies at the National Partnership. While Rhode Island offers job protection, it only offers four weeks of benefits, while New York offers 10 weeks.
New York’s duration of benefits is greater than those in the three other states, Shabo said.
New York’s law is also stronger than all, or most other states, in other categories, Shabo said in an email. When New York’s law is fully phased in, workers will receive a higher replacement wage rate than in California (for all but low-wage workers) and Rhode Island. New Yorkers will also have a higher weekly maximum than New Jersey and Rhode Island. New York also offers benefits for military deployments of a close family member, while the other three states do not.
"New York’s law will be less generous in wage replacement and duration than new laws that are not yet implemented in Massachusetts or Washington state, but Gov. Cuomo’s statement is definitely accurate as of right now when comparing New York’s law to California’s, New Jersey’s or Rhode Island’s," Shabo said.
Washington state, which has a program that will begin to administer benefits in 2020, will offer up to 16 or 18 weeks of paid leave in some circumstances, though family leave and medical leave will each be capped at 12 weeks per year. Massachusetts will offer a maximum of 26 weeks per year when family and medical leave are combined, though family leave is capped at 12 weeks.
Cuomo’s spokeswoman, Crampton-Hays, said that those programs that haven’t been implemented "cannot be evaluated in theory. We have the best paid family leave program that is real and functioning in the nation today, period."
Aparna Mathur, a resident scholar with the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative-leaning public policy think tank, directs a project on paid family and medical leave in partnership with the Brookings Institution.
"It’s definitely more generous than existing states’ paid leave laws," Mathur said of New York’s law.
But she said a "more balanced picture" would look at the costs of the program, and how businesses would deal with the absence of workers on leave. Similarly, Sawhill questioned whether generous benefits is the ideal way to evaluate the programs, as the cost and burden on employers should be considered as well.
The Urban Institute, which is concerned about policy affects on low-wage workers, found that California’s program is favorable for these workers in at least one respect: Its eligibility requirements are lower, said research associate Alex Stanczyk.
Crampton-Hays, of Cuomo’s office, did not address the difference in eligibility requirements, but she called New York’s program better for low-wage workers because of a higher weekly minimum wage replacement of $100 to California’s $50, and better protections for workers in businesses of 50 or fewer employees, including job protection and continuation of health insurance.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo called New York’s paid family leave policy the "best" in the country.
Experts generally agreed that major features of New York’s policy, such as duration, wage replacement, eligibility, and job protection are more favorable for employees on leave than programs in other states.
Other states that have approved but not yet activated paid leave programs will offer more generous benefits in certain respects than New York does. It’s also worth noting that while workers eligible for and interested in paid leave may think one program is "best," their colleagues and employers may disagree.
We rate Cuomo’s statement True.
"Governor Cuomo Unveils 2019 Justice Agenda," YouTube, Dec. 17, 2018. Accessed Dec. 17, 2018.
Transcript, "Governor Cuomo Unveils Agenda for First 100 Days - Justice Agenda," Dec. 17, 2018. Accessed Dec. 22, 2018.
"Work, Skills, Community: Restoring Opportunity for the Working Class," Opportunity America, American Enterprise Institute, Brookings Institution, 2018. Accessed Dec. 19, 2018.
Email and telephone conversation with Hazel Crampton-Hays, first deputy press secretary, Office of Governor Andrew Cuomo, Dec. 19, 2018, Jan. 2, 2019.
State Paid Family and Medical Leave Insurance Laws, National Partnership for Women and Families, July 2018. Accessed Dec. 20, 2018.
Email conversation, Alexandra Nseir, Campaign Communications Specialist, National Partnership for Women and Families, Dec. 21, 2018.
Paid Family Leave in the United States, Congressional Research Service, Updated September 12, 2018. Accessed Dec. 21, 2018.
"These 4 States Already Have Paid Family Leave," The Motley Fool, Feb. 26, 2018. Accessed Dec. 21, 2018.
Employee Benefits Survey, Table 32, Bureau of Labor Statistics, March 2017. Accessed Dec. 21, 2018.
Phone conversation, Aparna Mathur, resident scholar, economic policy, American Enterprise Institute, Jan. 2, 2019.
Email conversation, Maya Rossin-Slater, assistant professor, Department of Health Research and Policy, Stanford University, Jan. 2, 2019.
Phone conversation, Alex Stanczyk, research associate, Urban Institute, Jan. 2, 2019.
Email conversation, Isabel Sawhill, senior fellow, Brookings Institution, Jan. 2, 2019.
Paid Family Leave in the United States: Time for a New National Policy, Urban Institute, May 2017. Accessed Jan. 2, 2019.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.