Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
The treatment of migrants at the U.S.-Mexico border has become a huge issue this summer, with members of Congress visiting Border Patrol facilities to see conditions for themselves.
A Republican congressman from Texas recently made the case that while resources are strained at facilities run by immigration authorities, children in the care of another government agency are being treated well.
"In the (Office of Refugee Resettlement) facilities...I've been to Casa Padre in Brownsville, Texas, yes it's a restored Walmart. You know what? There's not a lock on the door. Any child is free to leave at anytime, but they don't," said Rep. Michael Burgess, R-Texas, during a June 24 MSNBC interview. "You know why? Because they are well taken care of. And yes, at some point they’re going to live with family, generally not mother or father, but some family member, that’s a good thing."
Readers asked PolitiFact to look into Burgess’s claim about children being free to leave at any time from shelters but choosing to stay. We found that Burgess’s claim ignores critical facts and doesn’t capture the complexity of the issue.
• Children are in shelters because they are under federal custody, waiting to be placed with a sponsor and for a decision on their immigration case.
• Shelters are not detention centers, so their staff can’t forcibly restrain children if they walk out.
• If a child leaves a shelter without permission, staff will call law enforcement and ask for the child’s return.
Burgess’s press office sent PolitiFact a statement from the congressman.
"In my experience, all shelters I have visited are designed appropriately for the ages of the children who occupy them," Burgess said in the statement. "If an older teen decides to leave on their own volition, they are neither detained nor restrained."
Immigrant children in federal custody range in age. For instance, as of May 31, around 11,500 were ages 13 to 17, about 1,400 were ages 6 to 12, and 432 were 5-years-old or younger.
Children in the care of the Office of Refugee Resettlement are required to be placed in the least restrictive environment, as mandated by the Flores Settlement, HHS’s press office told PolitiFact via email. Because of that, the majority of children are placed in state-licensed residential facilities instead of locked detention centers (and state laws vary regarding locks at the residential facilities).
"If a child does leave without proper authorization, then local law enforcement and (the Department of Homeland Security) are notified. Just like if a child left a school without permission — the police would be called," HHS said.
Organizations that advocate for migrants and help children obtain legal aid told PolitiFact that there are varying levels of security at different facilities, which can include shelters, foster care homes, and secure facilities, such as a juvenile detention center.
But overall, children are not free to leave the facilities without consent, experts said, while noting that it has happened.
"If they leave, it is considered running away," said Rachel Prandini, a staff attorney at the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, which advocates for immigrant rights.
Prandini pointed to a federal policy which says that a child may be placed in a "staff secure facility" solely because he or she poses an escape risk. In the more secure facilities that HHS operates, children are not free to leave, she said.
PolitiFact sought information from the nonprofit Southwest Key, which operates the Casa Padre migrant children shelter in Brownsville, Texas. It sent us a link to a July 2018 post from The Texas Tribune, headlined: "Can separated immigrant children just walk out of shelters? Technically, yes."
The Texas Tribune post said that under state and federal guidelines, staff at Casa Padre and other shelters "are almost never allowed to forcibly stop a child" from leaving. The Texas Tribune linked to a June 2018 New York Times article that quotes a spokesman for Southwest Key, after a 15-year-old migrant walked off from the Casa Padre shelter.
The spokesman, identified by the New York Times as Jeff Eller, told the newspaper that a child could not be legally required to stay.
"We are not a detention center," Eller told the New York Times. "We talk to them and try to get them to stay. If they leave the property, we call law enforcement."
The doors at Casa Padre (a former Walmart store) are not locked but they have alarms that would alert staff if a child is exiting (and in the back area where children play outside, there is a fence), said Michelle Brané, senior director of the Migrant Rights and Justice program at the nonprofit Women's Refugee Commission.
Children are kept in enclosed facilities because they are undocumented and in immigration removal proceedings, and for child protection reasons, because the federal government is responsible for their care and custody, said Jennifer Podkul, senior director for policy at Kids in Need of Defense.
The facilities are meant to be temporary places for children while they await placement with sponsors. A sponsor (commonly a parent or family member) is expected to care for the child while he or she gets a decision from an immigration judge. On average, children spend fewer than 45 days in shelters.
In his statement to PolitiFact, Burgess also said that children could request to be returned to their home country.
Experts told PolitiFact that while children can ask to be sent back, that’s not always granted because it’s at the discretion of an immigration judge. If a judge allows a child to go home through voluntary departure, or if the child is issued a removal order, the child would be transferred over to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and that agency would facilitate the removal from the United States, Podkul said.
Burgess said, "In the (Office of Refugee Resettlement) facilities...I've been to Casa Padre in Brownsville, Texas, yes it's a restored Walmart. You know what? There's not a lock on the door. Any child is free to leave at anytime, but they don't. You know why? Because they are well taken care of."
There are varying levels of security at different facilities. We did not get a clear answer from HHS, the department in charge of the Office of Refugee Resettlement, or from Casa Padre on whether there’s a lock on the door at Casa Padre. An expert told us that the doors at that facility are not locked but they have alarms to alert staff if a child is exiting.
In 2018, a spokesman for the nonprofit that runs Casa Padre said that the facility was not a detention center and could not legally stop a child from leaving. But the facility calls the police if children leave without permission.
Children at these facilities are under federal custody, awaiting immigration proceedings, and placement with a sponsor in the United States. So children might stay for reasons other than "because they are well taken care of." While most children in federal custody are 13- to 17-years-old, hundreds of others are 12 or younger.
Burgess’s statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context. We rate it Half True.
Phone interview, Jennifer Podkul, senior director for policy at Kids in Need of Defense, July 8, 2019
Phone interview, Michelle Brané, senior director of the Migrant Rights and Justice program at the nonprofit Women's Refugee Commission, July 8, 2019
MSNBC, Rep. Michael Burgess interview, June 24, 2019
Email interview, Office of Communications, Administration for Children and Families (ACF), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, July 1, 2019
PolitiFact, The facts behind the detention of immigrants, July 8, 2019
HHS - ORR, Sponsors and Placement, last reviewed May 15, 2019
New York Times, Teenager Is Missing After Walking Away From Migrant Children’s Center in Texas, June 24, 2018
Email interview, Southwest Key press office, July 9, 2019
Email interview, Rep. Michael Burgess press office,
The Texas Tribune, Can separated immigrant children just walk out of shelters? Technically, yes., July 12, 2018
HHS - ORR, Children Entering the United States Unaccompanied: Section 1, 1.2.4 Secure and Staff Secure Care Provider Facilities, section revised Oct. 10, 2018
Email interview, Rachel Prandini, a staff attorney at the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, July 2, 2019
PolitiFact, Donald Trump's executive order ending his administration's separation of immigrant families, June 25, 2018
HHS, Latest UAC Data – FY2019, latest data posted was for May 31, 2019, Content last reviewed by HHS on June 26, 2019, checked July 9, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.