Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
- North Carolina health secretary Mandy Cohen said "Covid-19 is now the leading cause of death in the United States."
- When it comes to deaths per day, Cohen has a point.
- In the bigger picture, the CDC says heart disease and cancer are still the leading causes of death.
With North Carolina in the middle of a stay-at-home order, the state’s top health official tried to emphasize the severity of COVID-19.
The novel coronavirus has killed more than 200 people in North Carolina and reached 93 of North Carolina’s 100 counties, according to the NC Department of Health and Human Services.
On top of that, health secretary Mandy Cohen on April 20 said the virus has reached a new status among other illnesses in America.
"Covid-19 is now the leading cause of death in the United States," Cohen said.
Is that true?
If you look at average daily deaths, yes. If you look at the bigger picture, no.
If you look for the answer to this question online, you’ll likely get mixed results.
Several media outlets -- such as Live Science, Newsweek and others -- recently reported that coronavirus is the top cause of death in America. But those claims look at death rates in a very small window, while the U.S. Centers for Disease Control tend to label diseases based on their toll in a given year.
Live Science and Newsweek based their claims on a chart created by Dr. Maria Danilychev, who practices at Scripps Health in San Diego. Her chart takes the number of COVID-19 deaths in America as reported by Worldometer.com. Then it compares the deaths to the average daily deaths from other illnesses as reported by the CDC.
For instance, if you look at the number of total deaths caused by heart disease reported in 2018 (647,457) and divide that by 365 (the number of days in a year) you get about 1,774 deaths per day. On April 20, Worldometer reported 1,939 coronavirus deaths across the U.S.
Cohen’s office told PolitiFact that she also based her claim on how daily coronavirus deaths compare to past heart disease death averages. In an email to PolitiFact, DHHS spokeswoman Tracy Zimmerman cited the 30-day rolling average for COVID-19 deaths as documented on OurWorldInData.com.
Over the phone, Zimmerman added that Cohen didn’t mean for her comment to be taken as a broad statement about historical death trends.
At the CDC, experts tend to look at a bigger picture when classifying something as a top cause of death.
In fact, a spokesman for the National Center for Health Statistics has pushed back at the idea that COVID-19 is the leading cause of death.
"There are no data to support that theory," Jeff Lancashire, a spokesperson for the National Center for Health Statistics, said in an email to CNN on April 10.
"We have limited data on 2020 deaths by cause, and no final official numbers yet for 2019, but we do know by looking at the final death totals in 2018 for the two leading causes of death in the U.S., Heart Disease and Cancer, there is no way that at this point COVID-19 comes anywhere close to those totals," Lancashire said.
PolitiFact emailed the CDC on Tuesday to ask if its opinion had changed. "Not really," CDC spokesman Brian Tsai said in an email.
"One can argue that for some weeks, it is the leading cause for those particular weeks, but we typically talk about leading causes in terms of annual deaths," the spokesman said.
"When looking at the data year-to-date (i.e., January-April), COVID-19 wouldn’t be the leading cause. In a typical year, there are more than 200,000 heart disease deaths from January-April. For cancer, the number is a little less than 200,000 for that period.
By contrast, when Cohen made her claim on April 20, the CDC reported coronavirus deaths at 39,000.
Cohen said "Covid-19 is now the leading cause of death in the United States."
That’s true only if you compare the number of people dying of coronavirus daily against estimates of other causes from previous years. The CDC has advised against using those daily numbers to make sweeping claims about the biggest causes of death in America.
Cohen’s claim is partially accurate but leaves out important details that would give a different impression about the broader situation of health risks in America. We rate it Half True.
Email correspondence with Brian Tsai, spokesman for the CDC.
Email and telephone interviews with Tracy Zimmerman, spokeswoman for the North Carolina DHHS.
Story by the News & Observer, "Coronavirus now the leading cause of death in US; new program to help feed kids in need," posted April 20, 2020.
Story by Live Science, "COVID-19 is now the leading cause of death in the United States," posted April 10, 2020.
Story by Newsweek, "Coronavirus becomes number one cause of death per day in u.s., surpassing heart disease and cancer," posted April 9, 2020.
A chart created by Dr. Maria Danilychev, who practices at Scripps Health in San Diego.
Stats on the coronavirus posted by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Stats on the coronavirus posted by Worldometer.com.
Stats on the coronavirus posted by OurWorldInData.org.
Story by CNN, "No, the coronavirus is not the leading cause of death in the US, CDC says," posted April 10, 2020.
Story by the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "CDC disputes claim coronavirus has become top killer in US," posted April 11, 2020.
Story by The State, "Is coronavirus the leading cause of death in the US? Yes, but no," posted April 20, 2020.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.