Facts are under assault in 2020.
We can't fight back misinformation about the election and COVID-19 without you. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
• The Biden campaign platform doesn’t propose taxing 401(k) accounts. He never said he’s going to tax your 401(k).
• Tax policy experts said that a Biden proposal to replace the current deduction with a 26% refundable tax credit wouldn’t constitute a tax on 401(k) accounts because everyone would still receive a tax subsidy for contributing to these accounts.
Joe Biden’s tax plan has become a regular target for misinformation, with social media posts falsely claiming that it would crush middle-income families, raise taxes on 82% of Americans, and even dissolve the stock market altogether.
Now, a popular post says the Democratic presidential nominee aims to tax 401(k) accounts if he’s elected.
"Biden slipped up and came out saying he’s going to tax your 401k. Are any of you EVEN paying attention?" it reads.
This Facebook post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
The post doesn’t cite any evidence or sources backing up its claims. We looked for a literal statement from Biden to this effect and didn't find one. The Biden campaign platform doesn’t include any reference to a tax on 401(k) accounts.
The only proposal that the post could be referring to is Biden’s plan to balance out retirement plan tax benefits so that they apply equally to people across incomes. Biden would do this by replacing the current deduction for retirement account contributions with a 26% refundable tax credit.
Tax policy experts told us that it’s still misleading and inaccurate to characterize this plan as a "tax" on 401(k) accounts. Here we’ll break down the proposal in detail, tackling both its direct and indirect impacts.
Under the current tax system, taxpayers get to deduct contributions to 401(k)s when they calculate their adjusted gross income on their income tax returns. Later, when those funds are withdrawn in retirement, the person will pay deferred taxes on their contributions and earnings.
This system tends to benefit upper income earners more than those with lower income, tax policy experts told us.
For example, a person with $8,000 of taxable income is currently subject to a 10% income tax rate. If this person contributed $100 to a retirement account, their taxable income would go down from $8,000 to $7,900, allowing them to save $10 in taxes. On the other hand, a person with $530,000 of taxable income is currently subject to a 37% tax rate. If this person contributed $100 to a retirement account, their taxable income would go down from $530,000 to $529,900, allowing them to save $37 in taxes.
"Even though these taxpayers both deducted the same amount of money from their taxable income, they save different amounts on their tax bills because they face different marginal tax rates," said Erica York, an economist with the Tax Foundation. "This phenomenon is true across all deductions."
Biden’s proposal aims to equalize the benefit of retirement contributions across income scales by giving people a 26% refundable tax credit deposited directly into their retirement account instead of a deduction. This would mean that each taxpayer would receive a flat benefit for contributions, rather a benefit that increases in proportion to taxable income. In effect, taxpayers in lower income brackets would see larger benefits from Biden’s plan, while taxpayers in higher income brackets would see reduced benefits.
Gordon Mermin, senior research associate at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, said that it’s not accurate to characterize the Biden plan as a tax on 401(k) accounts, because these accounts would still be tax subsidized for everyone.
"End of the day, everyone still sees their taxes reduced when contributing to a 401(k). Some contributors with incomes below 400,000 will get larger tax subsidies than under current law, some with incomes below 400,000 will see no change in their tax break for saving, and contributors with incomes above 400,000 will generally get smaller tax subsidies than under current law," he wrote in an email to PolitiFact.
A Facebook post claims, "Biden slipped up and came out saying he’s going to tax your 401k."
Biden doesn’t want to tax 401(k) accounts. Instead, he wants to balance out retirement plan tax benefits so that they apply equally to people across incomes by replacing the current deduction with a 26% refundable tax credit.
Tax policy experts said that it’s misleading to characterize Biden’s proposal as a tax on 401(k) accounts, because everyone would still see their taxes reduced when contributing to a retirement account.
We rate this claim False.
Facebook post, Oct. 19, 2020
Joe Biden campaign platform, Biden’s plan for older Americans
PolitiFact, Donald Trump Jr. misrepresents Joe Biden’s tax plan, Sep. 4, 2020
PolitiFact, Facebook post wrongly claims Biden would hike tax rates for family earning $75,000, Aug. 20, 2020
PolitiFact, No, Joe Biden doesn’t want to dissolve the stock market, Sep. 23, 2020
Tax Foundation, Biden’s proposal would shift the distribution of retirement tax benefits, Aug. 26, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.