Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
Millions of buffalo were killed by hunters in the late 1800s. By 1873, welcoming the extinction of the buffalo to suppress Indigenous peoples had become “de facto government policy,” according to Andrew Isenberg, a professor of American History at the University of Kansas.
Ukraine and Russia are key exporters of agricultural products such as wheat and barley, which has caused concern about future food shortages in some parts of the world.
The U.S. is experiencing a baby formula shortage because of a large recall, pandemic-related supply chain issues, and the highly concentrated nature of the formula market. There is no evidence the shortage was intentionally created by the government.
Concerns about the country’s food supply are weighing heavily on many Americans as baby formula is hard to find and international conflict threatens commodities like wheat in some parts of the world.
A social media post invoking those fears harks back to U.S. history to suggest that the government is purposely creating food shortages.
"In 1873 the U.S. government killed 1.5 million buffalo to starve Native Americans so they would become more dependent on the government," read one such May 11 post. "Fast forward to today, and the government is creating food shortages to achieve exactly the SAME goal!"
It was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
The post has a point about why so many buffalo were killed in the late 1800s, but it makes an unfounded comparison: There’s no evidence the U.S. government is currently creating food shortages.
Andrew Isenberg, an American history professor at the University of Kansas and the author of "The Destruction of the Bison," said white hunters in the late 1800s likely killed "far more" than the 1.5 million buffalo mentioned in the post — a fact federal authorities knew.
"The U.S. federal government did not actively destroy bison in order to starve Indigenous people in the Great Plains into submission," he said. "But the federal government stood by and refused to prevent the wasteful destruction of bison by private white hunters and then welcomed the result of the near extinction of the species: Indigenous peoples’ surrender to the reservation system."
Bison skulls await industrial processing in Michigan in 1892. (Burton Historical Collection, Detroit Public Library and Wikimedia Commons)
Gen. William Sherman, who commanded the U.S. Army in the region, negotiated treaties with groups of Indigenous peoples in the Great Plains in the late 1860s, Isenberg said. The U.S. agreed to allow Native Americans to occupy large parts of the Great Plains "so long as the buffalo may range thereon in such numbers as to justify the chase."
Not long after those treaties were negotiated, Isenberg said, Sherman wrote a letter saying, "it will not be long before all of the buffalos are extinct near and between the railroads."
By 1873, welcoming the extinction of buffalo to suppress Indigenous peoples "had become de facto government policy," Isenberg said.
In an 1872 report, Interior Secretary Columbus Delano wrote that the buffalo’s disappearance "must operate largely in favor of our efforts to confine the Indians to smaller areas, and compel them to abandon their nomadic customs, and establish themselves in permanent homes."
Although the decimation of the buffalo population was ultimately the work of private hunters, "the idea that destroying bison was a way to force the surrender of Indigenous people in the Great Plains was quite overt," Isenberg said.
While there is concern about global food shortages because of the war in Ukraine, experts told PolitiFact in April that the U.S. is less vulnerable to food shortages than poorer nations that rely largely on imports.
"The U.S. food system has a good level of self-sufficiency, so currently, it is hard to imagine empty shelves in grocery stores," said Ohio State University agricultural economist Seungki Lee.
And though claims have surfaced suggesting the U.S. government is intentionally creating food shortages, we have found there is no evidence to back that up. A number of factors have contributed to the U.S. baby formula shortage, including a recall by a major U.S. manufacturer, existing supply chain issues associated with the COVID-19 pandemic and the highly concentrated nature of the formula market.
View of almost empty baby formula shelves at a Duane Reade in New York City on May 11, 2022. (AP)
A post claimed that the U.S. government’s inaction over buffalo killing that harmed Native American populations in the 1800s shows it is now "is creating food shortages" so that Americans are more "dependent on the government."
Millions of buffalo were killed by hunters in the late 1800s as part of a "de facto government policy" meant to force Native Americans in the Great Plains to abandon their customs and accept the reservation system.
This racist history, however, does not prove that the U.S. government is currently creating food shortages to force government dependence. We found no evidence to support that claim.
We rate this claim False.
Email interview with Andrew Isenberg, Professor of American history at the University of Kansas, May 16, 2022
The Atlantic, "‘Kill every buffalo you can! Every buffalo dead is an Indian gone,’" May 13, 2016
Smithsonian Magazine, "Where the buffalo no longer roamed," July 17, 2012
The Western Historical Quarterly, "The Frontier Army and the Destruction of the Buffalo: 1865-1883," archived Dec. 8, 2020
PolitiFact, "Looming food shortages? Probably not in the U.S.," April 16, 2022
PolitiFact, "No, food-plant fires aren’t attempt to create food shortages," April 26, 2022
PolitiFact, "No, Biden’s comments don’t prove governments are orchestrating food shortages," April 18, 2022
Indian Country Today, "Genocide by Other Means: U.S. Army Slaughtered Buffalo in Plains Indian Wars," Sept. 13, 2018
Native Hope, "How the destruction of the Buffalo (tȟatȟaŋka) impacted Native Americans," accessed May 17, 2022
The New York Times, "The Baby Formula Crisis," May 13, 2022
The New York Times, "Historians Revisit Slaughter on the Plains," Nov. 16, 1999
The University of Chicago Libraries, "Annual Reports of the Department of the Interior Volume 1," accessed May 17, 2022
Cambridge University Press, "The Destruction of Bison," accessed May 17, 2022
CNBC, "Here’s why food shortages are unlikely to occur in the U.S.," April 20, 2022
U.S. News, "What’s Going on With the U.S. Infant Formula Shortage?" May 13, 2022
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, "Abbott voluntarily recalls powder formulas manufactured at one plant," Feb. 17, 2022
Detroit Public Library, "Men standing with pile of buffalo skulls, Michigan Carbon Works," accessed May 19, 2022
Wikimedia Commons, "Bison skull pile," accessed May 19, 2022
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.