The PolitiFact report card on the presidential candidates
By Bill Adair
Published on Friday, December 30th, 2011 at 6:00 p.m.
In the Republican debates and the avalanche of TV ads in Iowa and New Hampshire, the presidential candidates have made lots of claims about the credibility of their opponents -- and themselves.
PolitiFact has checked hundreds of statements ranging from Mitt Romney's claim that Solyndra had robots that whistled Disney tunes (Half True) to Rep. Michele Bachmann's statement that the HPV vaccine can cause mental retardation (False).
Collectively, those fact-checks have formed report cards for each candidate that reveal patterns and trends about their truth-telling. With the Iowa caucuses three days away, PolitiFact is publishing the records to show how the candidates have fared on the Truth-O-Meter. A few findings:
● Rep. Ron Paul has the largest percentage of True statements. They account for 25 percent of the Paul claims we've checked. Romney and Rick Santorum are tied for second with 23 percent.
● Bachmann has the most ratings on the false end of the scale, with 72 percent Mostly False or lower. She is followed by Newt Gingrich with 62 percent and Texas Gov. Rick Perry with 50 percent.
● Bachmann also ranks first for the largest share of Pants on Fire ratings (23 percent). Gingrich is second with 21 percent.
The PolitiFact report cards represent the candidates' career statistics, like the back of their baseball cards. For President Barack Obama, Paul and Romney, they include claims we checked during the last presidential campaign. The totals also include statements the candidates made in past or current jobs, such as claims Perry made as Texas governor.
The Truth-O-Meter fact-checks were done by writers for PolitiFact National and our nine state sites. Of the Republicans, Perry has been checked the most (112), followed by Romney (88). Obama has been checked the most of anyone -- 331 times -- which is nearly as much as all the Republicans combined.
PolitiFact editors choose the claims to check based on whether a statement is significant, verifiable and whether people are likely to wonder if it's true. The tallies are not scientific, but they provide interesting insights into a candidate's overall record for accuracy.
Bachmann's Truth-O-Meter report card became a topic for the New York Times and Minnesota political writers because her first 13 ratings were either False or Pants on Fire. (Her 14th was a Mostly False.)
She has been asked about her PolitiFact record on Meet the Press, Face the Nation and Good Morning America. She has usually sidestepped the questions and used them as an opportunity to criticize President Obama.
Other candidates also have raised questions about her credibility. When Gingrich said at a Dec. 15 debate that she had her facts wrong about his work for Freddie Mac, Bachmann used an unusual tactic to defend herself -- she cited PolitiFact's fact-checking from the previous debate, which she said showed "everything I said was true."
But that, too, was incorrect, and she earned another Pants on Fire.
Of the 53 Bachmann claims we've rated, 59 percent earned a False or Pants on Fire, our rating for things that are ridiculously false. By comparison, Gingrich's share of False/Pants on Fire ratings is 44 percent, followed by Santorum with 31.
Leaning toward True
Take a look at the report cards and you can see some patterns.
Paul's record leans toward the True end of the scale. True and Mostly True ratings accounted for half of his Truth-O-Meter ratings. Romney's record is relatively even, with about the same number of True and Mostly True (35) as Mostly False/False/Pants on Fire (34).
Until recently, Gingrich had a relatively even record, with roughly the same number for each rating. But it has fallen lately because of a spate of False and Pants on Fires.
Perry's ratings lean False, with 51 percent of his ratings Mostly False or lower. Jon Huntsman's record is lumped in the middle, with more than three-fourths of the ratings between Mostly True and Mostly False. Santorum's ratings tilt toward the bottom of the scale, with three-fourths Half True or lower.
The 331 checks on Obama also reflect claims made by spokesmen from the White House and his re-election campaign. His record leans toward the True end of the scale, with almost three-fourths of his ratings Half True or higher.
It's probably no coincidence that the Republican candidates with better records -- Romney and Paul -- have run for president before. They have veteran campaign staffers who have checked their talking points.
But the new candidates haven't fared so well.
A key moment for Bachmann was her statement in September that the HPV vaccine causes mental retardation, a claim she made in several interviews. It was debunked by PolitiFact and other fact-checking organizations.
"She hurt herself very badly" with political analysts whose handicapping is influential with GOP supporters and contributors, said David Birdsell, dean of public affairs at Baruch College in New York.
"That was very much a pivot point in the coverage of her campaign," he said.
Birdsell said the impact of the ratings depends on the group. He said Republican primary voters discount the importance of fact-checks on claims they consider a matter of dispute, such as Perry's statement that scientists are questioning whether climate change is man-made (which PolitiFact rated False). But journalists and political analysts put greater importance on those fact-checks.
He said fact-checking "is not going to matter to all audiences all the time -- particularly in this environment of contested facts."
See Truth-O-Meter articles.
Researchers: Bill Adair
We want to hear your suggestions and comments.
For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.
Keep up to date with Politifact:
- Sign up for our e-mail (about once a week)
- Put a free PolitiFact widget on your blog or Web page
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Truth-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on GOP Pledge-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Obameter items
- Advertise on PolitiFact
- Shop the PolitiFact store for T-shirts, hats and other PolitiFact swag