Half-True
Abele
Says he balanced the Milwaukee County budget "without raising taxes five years in a row."

Chris Abele on Monday, November 2nd, 2015 in a TV ad

Milwaukee County Executive Chris Abele says he's balanced 5 budgets without raising property taxes

Facing an election challenge from a state senator in his own party, Milwaukee County Executive Chris Abele unveiled two campaign ads on Nov. 2, 2015.

Both TV spots make the same boast about taxes.

In the ad titled "Foundation," the narrator puts it this way: "As county executive, he balanced the budget without raising taxes, five years in a row."

Really? Then why is the property tax levy millions of dollars higher than when Abele took office?

It’s been well documented that the county Board of Supervisors has generally raised property taxes in making changes to Abele’s budgets.

But Abele has, in his own way, adopted those increases as well.

The numbers

Abele has proposed five county budgets since winning a special election in April 2011 to finish out the final year of Scott Walker’s term, after Walker was elected governor. Abele won a full four-year term in 2012, running unopposed. But he faces a serious challenge from state Sen. Chris Larson of Milwaukee in the April 2016 election.

(Although both Abele and Larson are Democrats, the county executive position is officially nonpartisan.)

As the following table shows, for each of his five budgets, Abele proposed a property tax levy freeze -- in other words, he proposed levying the same total amount of property taxes that was levied the previous year.

But it’s also clear that Abele’s proposed levy has increased every year, and was $13 million higher in 2016 than it was in 2012.

Budget Year

Property tax levy proposed by Abele`

Property tax levy adopted by County Board following vetoes and veto overrides

2011

(Proposed by Scott Walker)

$269.6 million

2012

$269.6 million

$275.4 million

2013

$275.4 million

$279.3 million

2014

$279.3 million

$279.3 million

2015

$279.3 million

$282.9 million

2016

$282.9 million

$287 million*

 

*The County Board on Nov. 9, 2015, adopted the 2016 budget, though Abele can still issue vetoes.

The pattern was essentially the same each year:

  • Abele proposed a budget that would have frozen the levy.

  • The County Board approved changes in the budget that -- except for 2014, when the levy stayed the same -- raised the levy.

  • Abele issued a number of budget vetoes, some or all of which were overridden by the County Board.

  • The result was that, except for 2014, the County Board ultimately adopted a budget that contained a property tax levy larger than what Abele proposed.

So, by proposing the freezes, and issuing the vetoes, each year, Abele tried to keep the property levy from going up.

But when it came time to propose a budget for the next year, Abele used the previous year’s levy.

In other words, each year, Abele took advantage of the fact that the County Board had adopted a levy that was higher than he proposed.

So, the "freeze" he proposed each year was on the higher amount adopted by the board, not the lower amount that he had proposed and tried to preserve with his vetoes.

This was the same pattern Walker followed as county executive.

Our rating

Abele says he balanced the Milwaukee County budget "without raising taxes five years in a row."

That claim has the ring of finality to it, as though Abele has presided over five budgets without a tax increase.

In reality, Abele did propose a freeze in the property tax levy each year and he issued budget vetoes that would have kept the levy down. But the County Board ultimately adopted a budget that raised the total property tax take in four of the five years, and Abele took advantage of those actions when he proposed a freeze the following year. So, taxpayers are paying more than when he took office.

For a statement that is partially accurate, our rating is Half True.

More on Milwaukee County

Edward Flynn: In Milwaukee County, juveniles arrested for car theft "get sent immediately home, because under the point system in juvenile court" on holding suspects, "a stolen car gets zero points." Mostly False,

Facebook posts: Milwaukee "incarcerates 1.2% of white men" and has "incarcerated over 50% of black men in their 30s." Half True.