Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

John McCain
stated on November 26, 2007 in Interview on Fox News:
"He was a member of the Iraq Study Group and was either fired or quit from a very important commission that was trying to figure out the way forward in Iraq."
true true
Amy Hollyfield
By Amy Hollyfield December 4, 2007

This attack is spot-on

Former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani was indeed an original member of the Iraq Study Group, formed at the request of Congress to conduct a bipartisan assessment of the situation in Iraq.

And he was either fired or quit from that panel after missing two official meetings.

Here's what we know.

Giuliani was appointed to the panel in March 2006, then missed two two-day meetings. On the dates of those meetings, he was paid for lucrative speaking appearances elsewhere.

On April 11-12, 2006, the first official meeting of the Iraq Study Group was held in Washington, D.C. Where was Giuliani? On April 12, he was a keynote speaker at the FT Asian Financial Centers Summit in South Korea. His net fee: $160,000.

The second official meeting of the group was May 18-19, 2006. Where was Giuliani? On May 18, he spoke at the Georgia 100 annual awards breakfast in Atlanta. His net fee: $80,000. Later that day, he attended a $100-a-plate fundraiser for former Christian Coalition leader Ralph Reed, then a candidate for lieutenant governor of Georgia.

James Baker, secretary of state under the first President Bush, was co-chair of the Iraq Study Group, along with former U.S. Rep. Lee Hamilton, D-Ind. Baker declined to comment for this story.

Featured Fact-check

But his co-chair explains how Giuliani left the group.

Hamilton says that after Giuliani told Baker he couldn't attend the second meeting in a row, "(Baker) said, 'I'm going to have to go to another person.' "

On May 31, 2006, the group announced former U.S. Attorney General Edwin Meese III would replace Giuliani.

At the time, Giuliani said: "My previous time commitments do not permit me the full and active participation that the Iraq Study Group deserves."

It's unclear whether he was fired or forced to quit, but consider this: During his two-month tenure on the panel, between March 15, 2006, and May 24, 2006, Giuliani made 30 paid appearances for a net revenue of $2.25-million, according to his financial disclosure forms.

Pretty simple to us; McCain's attack is True.

Our Sources

Public financial disclosure report, "Rudolph W. Giuliani," filed May 14, 2007

Iraq Study Group, Report

Press release, "Edwin Meese Replaces Rudolph Giuliani on Iraq Study Group," U.S. Institute of Peace, May 31, 2006

Event Program, FT Asian Financial Centers Summit, Seoul, South Korea, April 2006

Associated Press article, "Giuliani named to bipartisan panel reviewing U.S. policy in Iraq," March 16, 2006

New York Times article, "In a Southern Foray, Giuliani Helps a Friend but Skirts an Issue," by Patrick Healy, May 19, 2006

Atlanta Journal-Constitution article, "Giuliani endorses Reed for lieutenant governor, 300-plus turn out for fundraiser," by Jim Galloway, May 19, 2006

Atlanta Journal-Constitution article, "Giuliani shares secrets," by Maria Saporta, May 25, 2006

News conference, Rudy Giuliani in Tampa, Nov. 15, 2007

Interview with Lee Hamilton, former U.S. representative from Indiana and co-chair of Iraq Study Group, Nov. 15, 2007

Interview with Alan Simpson, former U.S. senator from Wyoming and Iraq Study Group panel member, Nov. 15, 2007

Interview with Leon Panetta, former White House chief of staff and Iraq Study Group panel member, Nov. 16, 2007

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Amy Hollyfield

This attack is spot-on

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up