Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
When a presidential candidate says a controversial solar factory had robots that whistled Disney songs, then says, "I'm not kidding," we just can't resist. Really?
We've checked other recent claims about Solyndra, the once-hot solar panel manufacturer that won $535 million in federal loan guarantees, then collapsed into bankruptcy court this year. But only this one had us humming a merry tune.
Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, who is seeking the Republican nomination, talked about the robots to distinguish between his private sector experience and government largesse in a recent speech to conservatives in Washington.
"You see in the private sector, as you know, you have no choice about balancing budgets. You either balance your budget, or you go broke. And you spend every dollar like it's your own, because it is. Now someone should have told that to Solyndra.
"The federal government gave them a $535 million startup loan to build a factory in Fremont, Calif. The footprint of their facility covered five baseball fields. They had robots that whistled Disney songs. I'm not kidding. They had, what was described as, spa-like showers with liquid crystal displays that told you what the water temperature was. The company headquarters was called, the 'Taj Mahal' of office buildings.
"That's how government starts a business. Now let me compare Solyndra with Staples, a company that I helped get started in a small way. Our headquarters was located in the back of an empty food warehouse. We got used office furniture, old Naugahyde chairs. You actually had to be kind of an athlete to get out of them once you sat into them. Yet every penny we had went into selling and attracting customers. That's the difference between the private sector and government, fiscal responsibility."
The Disney reference planted an irresistible image of Snow White's dwarfs stacking solar panels. We asked Romney's campaign for evidence for his claim.
Spokesman Ryan Williams provided us with a Bloomberg article from Sept. 28, 2011: "Solyndra plant had whistling robots, spa showers."
"The glass-and-metal building that Solyndra LLC began erecting alongside Interstate 880 in Fremont, California, in September 2009 was something the Silicon Valley area hadn’t seen in years: a new factory.
"It wasn’t just any factory. When it was completed at an estimated cost of $733 million, including proceeds from a $535 million U.S. loan guarantee, it covered 300,000 square feet, the equivalent of five football fields. It had robots that whistled Disney tunes, spa-like showers with liquid-crystal displays of the water temperature, and glass-walled conference rooms.
"'The new building is like the Taj Mahal,' John Pierce, 54, a San Jose resident who worked as a facilities manager at Solyndra, said in an interview."
Later in the story were more robot details.
"Robots that resembled 'a big freezer with wheels' maneuvered around the factory transporting panels from one machine to another, said George Garma, 49, a former Solyndra equipment maintenance technician from Fremont. The Disney tunes alerted workers to the robots’ presence."
We chatted with Pierce, the facilities manager, who now works at a California university, and Myron Moreno, Solyndra's director of automation, who's since picked up a job at another solar company.
They explained that at an automated plant like Solyndra's, when stacks of panels need to be moved around the factory, a machine called an "automated guided vehicle" does the work. It's basically a driverless forklift. Just like a forklift, it sounds an alarm when it moves to alert workers to stay out of the way. (You can see them at work in this Solyndra video.)
Versions of the vehicles have been around since the 1950s, according to the American Society of Safety Engineers. Their main benefit is that they reduce labor costs.
But the incessant beep-beep-beeping can drive workers nuts — and sometimes they tune it out, presenting a safety hazard. So vehicle makers have experimented with other sounds to make sure the alarms get heard. For example, melodies.
Moreno said the new factory used about 10 automated guided vehicles from equipment manufacturers Murata and Savant, in two sizes. One carried about 1,000 pounds, the other about 2,000 pounds.
The Japanese Murata vehicles came preloaded with a beeping noise and music. The other machines Solyndra equipped with an alarm box that included music.
"They gave you a menu, so we had each one playing a different medley," Moreno said. "Any time they're moving, it's preferable to have some music versus the alarming sound. I've been in factories all over the U.S., and that's the typical thing."
Of course, even the wordless music had its downside: Songs could get stuck in your head, Moreno said. So they avoided the better-known movie soundtracks, like E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial and Raiders of the Lost Ark, he said.
It was a relief, Moreno said, that some of the tunes were Japanese folk songs.
"Those weren't too bad, because nobody knew what those were," Moreno said.
What about Disney songs? Neither Pierce or Moreno specifically recalled any.
We were heartened that Romney was able to quickly provide a source for his information about Solyndra's factory. But as an example of wasteful spending, "robots that whistled Disney songs," doesn't quite hold up. Automated guided vehicles are common in warehouses and factories, as a labor-saving device. Some of them come preloaded with melodies as an alternative to beep-beep-beep — to boost workers' attention to them, and thus safety. The Solyndra vehicles may have played some Disney tunes along with their movie medleys and Japanese folk songs, but it wasn't their most memorable feature. We rate Romney's claim Half True.
CQ Transcriptwire, Former Gov. Mitt Romney, R-Mass., Presidential Candidate, Delivers Remarks At Americans For Prosperity Foundation Summit, Nov. 4, 2011
Americans for Prosperity, Defending the American Dream Summit, Nov. 4, 2011
Bloomberg, "Solyndra plant had whistling robots, spa showers," Sept. 28, 2011
E-mail interview with Meghan Womack, Bloomberg, Nov. 4, 2011
E-mail interview with Ryan Williams, spokesman for Mitt Romney, Nov. 4, 2011
E-mail interview with John Pierce, former facilities manager for Solyndra, Nov. 15, 2011
Interview with Myron Moreno, former director of automation for Solyndra, Nov. 16, 2011
PolitiFact Florida, "Solyndra ad claims President Barack Obama gave taxpayer money to help his campaign donors at failed solar company," Nov. 15, 2011
Solyndra, Solyndra Fab 2, video uploaded Dec. 8, 2010
Solyndra, Solyndra 200 Series, video uploaded May 5, 2011
American Society of Safety Engineers, Safety Practices for Automated Guided Vehicles, accessed Nov. 16, 2011
Material Handling & Logistics Conference, The AGV Revolution, accessed Nov. 16, 2011
Oakland Tribune, "Solyndra workers loved their jobs at the solar company," Sept. 26, 2011
Recovery.gov, Recipient profile: Solyndra, accessed Nov. 4, 2011
Recovery.gov, Loans - Award Summary: Solyndra, accessed Nov. 4, 2011
Washington Post, "Solyndra employees: Company suffered from mismanagement, heavy spending," Sept. 21, 2011
Los Angeles Times, "Solyndra's collapse is a tale of too much dazzle," Sept. 24, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.