Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
t’s no secret to many homeowners in the city of Atlanta that they are floating in high water and sewer bills.
Some say they’re drowning in the money they sink into city coffers.
The issue came up during a recent City Council committee meeting where officials discussed a voter referendum set for February. The referendum would extend a penny-per-dollar sales tax to pay for ongoing work to repair Atlanta’s century-old sewer system, reduce pollution in the Chattahoochee River and improve its water quality.
The sales tax, city watershed management officials say, is projected to bring in about $113 million in 2012. And if voters don’t continue the tax? Officials say they would have to raise monthly water and sewer rates on Atlanta users.
"We can’t do a rate increase," Councilman C.T. Martin said.
Particularly since homeowners saw their water bills rise by 12 percent in July, thanks to a series of annual rate increases passed by city leaders in 2008.
The council’s Utilities Committee debated how legislation authorizing the referendum should be crafted at its Sept. 13 meeting. Councilwoman Carla Smith, who said she was running low on patience about the discussion, made a comment about water and sewer bills that might surprise some recent Atlanta homeowners.
"We all know our water bills are the highest in the nation," said Smith, former chairwoman of the Utilities Committee. "Or the second-highest."
The claim is repeated so often in Atlanta that we thought it’d be worthwhile to check it out.
"We are pretty sure we are first," said Janet Ward, a spokeswoman for the city’s Watershed Management Department, focusing on research she’s seen. "Based on everything I know, we are No. 1."
Here are some recent surveys we found:
- Black and Veatch, an engineering, construction and consulting company, looked at residential bills for water and wastewater in 50 large cities for three amounts of use for 2009 and 2010: 3,750 gallons, 7,500 gallons and 15,000 gallons. Atlanta users paid the highest average monthly rates for 7,500 gallons and 15,000 gallons. The bills were $154.30 and $327.70, respectively. Atlanta was a close second to Seattle in the 3,750-gallon category.
- Raftelis, a Charlotte-based consulting firm, helped conduct a study for the American Water Works Association in 2010. Atlanta’s wastewater rates were the highest among 30 large systems it studied. The city was fourth in water rates among those systems.
- Circle of Blue, a network of scientists, journalists and experts conducted a survey of water prices for 30 of the nation’s largest water and sewer systems. The average monthly bill for a family of four using 150 gallons of water a day in Atlanta was $126. That was a distant second to Santa Fe, N.M., where the average monthly bill was nearly $243 a month.
- New York City’s Department of Environmental Protection conducted a study of water and sewer rates that found Atlanta had the highest average annual residential rates among 24 cities studied, as of March 2008 at nearly $1,500 -- or $125 a month. Atlanta -- by far -- also had the highest average commercial rates, at more than $16,000 a year.
Atlanta voters have twice passed referendums, by overwhelming margins, for the 1 percent sales tax for the water and sewer improvements.
Water and sewer rates are rising across the country at rates higher than inflation, experts say.
Circle of Blue found the average water bills increased by 9 percent in the past year in the cities it surveyed. Cities say it costs more money to treat water, buy it from wholesale suppliers and pay the workers -- and they are passing those higher costs along to customers, the organization found.
Raftelis’ chief operating officer, Piper Brandt, said water and wastewater rates have each risen by an average of nearly 5 percent in large cities since 1996. Another reason governments are raising costs, Brandt said, is use is down because people are conserving more water and using more efficient appliances. Brandt believes governments had below-market prices and are trying to catch up.
"Utilities have fixed costs and revenue is variable," Brandt said.
Based on the research we’ve seen, none of which has been disputed, Atlanta has the highest monthly bills in most categories. When it is not first, Atlanta is typically second.
Atlanta users may not want to toast a glass of H2O to this one, but Smith’s claim appears on target. We rate it as True.
Atlanta City Council Utilities Committee meeting, Sept. 13, 2011
Atlanta Watershed Management Department, Water/Sewer Rate Increase
Black and Veatch, "2009/2010 50 Largest Cities Water/Wastewater Rate Survey"
Circle of Blue, "The Price of Water 2011: Prices Rise an Average of 9 Percent in Major U.S. Cities," May 5, 2011
New York City Department of Environmental Protection Water and Sewer Rate Study
Telephone interview with Janet Ward, spokeswoman, Atlanta Watershed Management Department, Sept. 15, 2011
Telephone interview with Piper Brandt, chief operating officer, Raftelis Financial Consultants, Sept. 16, 2011
Telephone interview with Carla Smith, Atlanta city councilwoman, Sept. 19, 2011
Read About Our Process
Says Sarah Huckabee Sanders tweeted, “It’s ‘odd’ that the ANTIFA insurgency happened just as COVID-19 loses steam It’s ‘odd’ that COVID-19 happened the moment impeachment failed. It’s ‘odd’ that impeachment happened the moment Russian hoax failed. The Russian hoax happened because Hillary lost? Notice the pattern?”
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.