Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Under fire recently for his stance on giving in-state college tuition rates to illegal immigrants in Texas, Gov. Rick Perry stated that in 2001, only four Texas legislators voted against the measure.
The statement came as Perry apologized in a Sept. 28, 2011, interview with Newsmax TV for saying anyone who opposed giving tuition breaks to the children of illegal immigrants did not "have a heart" — a comment he made in the Sept. 22, 2011, Republican presidential debate.
In an article about the interview, though, Newsmax noted that Perry stood by his view that the decision in his state to extend tuition breaks was the right one. "I was probably a bit over-passionate by using that word, and it was inappropriate," Perry was quoted as saying. "In Texas, in 2001, we had 181 members of the Legislature — only four voted against this piece of legislation — because it wasn't about immigration, it was about education."
Only four of the 181 members voted no?
We’ve written other items about this law in recent days, so our interest was piqued. (We checked statements about whether Perry gave illegal immigrants in-state rates and the difference in dollars between in-state and out-of-state tuition.)
According to the journals for the 2001 session kept by the Texas House and Senate, Perry is darned close.
Versions of the proposal cleared House and Senate education panels with no opposition. The House passed the measure 142-1, with Rep. Will Hartnett, R-Dallas, being the lone "no" vote; five House members were absent, according to the April 23, 2001, House Journal entry.
After amending the bill, the Senate approved it 27-3 on May 21, 2001, with Republicans Mike Jackson of La Porte, Jane Nelson of Flower Mound and Jeff Wentworth of San Antonio in opposition.
Three days later, the House approved the Senate's changes 130-2; the "no" voters were Hartnett and Rep. Jerry Madden, R-Richardson. Sixteen members were not present.
Perry signed the measure into law June 16, 2001.
Our count: Five of the 181 legislators referred to by Perry (31 state senators, 150 House members) voted against the tuition legislation. That's close enough for us to rate his claim True.
Newsmax, news article, "Rick Perry to Newsmax: I Regret 'Heartless' Comment on Immigration," Sept. 28, 2011
Newsmax, video of interview, "Perry: 'Heartless' Poor Word Choice In Immigration Debate," Sept. 28, 2011
Texas House of Representatives, journal entry, April 23, 2001
Texas Senate, journal entry, May 21, 2001
Texas House of Representatives, journal entry, May 24, 2001
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.